Over the past six seasons, we’ve watched “The Walking Dead’s” Carol Petelier (Melissa McBride) evolve from an abused housewife to one of the most lethal and pragmatic survivors on the zombie drama. Last season, AMC’s companion series “Fear the Walking Dead” introduced its own unpredictable character in Victor Strand (Colman Domingo), an enigmatic businessman who will offer the other “Fear” survivors safe haven on his yacht, the Abigail, in Season 2.

Since both characters obviously have more than their fair share of secrets, Variety asked the cast and producers of “Fear the Walking Dead” to decide which character was the true master manipulator, “The Walking Dead’s” Carol, or “Fear’s” Strand.

“Fear the Walking Dead” premieres Sunday, April 10 at 9 p.m. on AMC.