No one wants to believe Jack and Rebecca’s marriage can’t be saved. Although it’s obviously not perfect (no one’s is), these two are the OG super couple of the show, and it seemed like, despite little hiccups here and there, they were ultimately happy and together until his untimely death. But the first season finale left them on a dark note that made many question whether or not that was a truth the show had set up or just wishful, positive thinking on the audience’s part. After learning Kate’s new bandmates include her ex, Jack lost it, and the two spun out in anger, culminating in Jack being unable to answer Kate when she asked why he loves her. It would have been the ultimate emotional cliffhanger that left a lump in throats in addition to wet eyes, but then they followed it up with an even more emotional answer from Jack.