‘Interrogation’: TV Review

Peter Sarsgaard, Kyle Gallner, David Strathairn, Kodi Smit-McPhee.
Release Date:
Feb 6, 2020

60 MIN.

“Interrogation,” a new drama on CBS All Access, depicts the aftermath of a gruesome murder, with a young man imprisoned, perhaps wrongfully. But it is really all about its unusual hook — that, after the pilot, episodes two through nine can be watched in any order ahead of episode ten’s finale. And it’s regrettable: There’s a good show somewhere inside “Interrogation,” but in order to make the show work even a little bit when screened in random order, much has to be sacrificed.

The stated reason for the shuffled order comes onscreen at each episode’s outset: “When cold case detectives reopen an unsolved case,” we’re told, “they abandon the linear narrative presented in the files of the original investigation.” This is carefully worded to have the ring of truth while not in fact making any sense: “Interrogation” depicts an ongoing investigation in which things happened in a linear order. Each episode is focused on a different individual actor in the case but does contain events happening along a timeline, one that rejiggering only confuses, sparking no new insight. Indeed, scrambling those events up is less like detective work, following leads as they inspire curiosity, than it is like complicating a narrative for its own sake.

In order to make the story track even despite the fact that viewers may watch it in entirely different orders, certain things are made overabundantly clear. Peter Sarsgaard’s police detective, the one who initially arrests a young man (Kyle Gallner) for murder, is not just a petty abuser of power but, whenever he appears across the show’s sweep of time, something like a madman. It’s as though the show worried we’d lose track of the character if he weren’t asserted with the outrageous cruelty of a silent-movie villain. It’s a legitimate concern, though; others of the show’s characters, like the young convict’s father (David Strathairn), are compelling, but fade in and out of the narrative, depending on the episode one’s watching, in a manner whose pace literally cannot be controlled by the show. You might lose Strathairn’s character for quite a while, and to watch “Interrogation” is to be okay with that.

“Interrogation” is just good enough to be frustrating for the ways in which it isn’t yet better, and most of them stem back to the original sin of the show’s format. I dipped around through half the show’s episodes, starting at the beginning and then moving to the penultimate episode in the show’s timeline to see if it would be comprehensible. It wasn’t, really — not nearly as much as were earlier episodes I caught up on, ones that filled in story points that hadn’t tracked at all later on. I felt, learning about a prison roommate of the protagonist’s only when, late in the show, he acted decisively and in a manner that relied backstory to understand, less like a detective than like a dupe. There is a right way to watch this show, it’d seem, and that’s… the way television has been watched since the beginning of the medium, in a temporal order.

Which raises the question of why the gimmick, if even the show itself seems to push back against it. A well-made and compelling show about the various forces aligned against a young man wrongfully imprisoned — one with some name actors but no superstars in front of or behind the camera — might just not be enough to break through on a streaming service that bubbles under Netflix and Hulu in name recognition. This, at least, creates something to talk about — even if it’s far less worth discussing than the straightforwardly good show a single-timeline “Interrogation” might have been.

'Interrogation': TV Review

CBS All Access. Ten episodes (five screened for review).

Production: Executive Producers: Anders Weidemann, John Mankiewicz, Henrik Bastin, Melissa Aouate, Ernest Dickerson.

Cast: Peter Sarsgaard, Kyle Gallner, David Strathairn, Kodi Smit-McPhee.

More TV

  • Michael Bloomberg and Elizabeth WarrenNinth 2020

    MSNBC Democratic Debate Moderators Lost Control of a Messy Night (Column)

    After what seems like countless Democratic debates, February 19th’s had a giant curveball in Mike Bloomberg, the former New York City mayor whose enormous fortune has given him a late, but undeniable, leg up in the race. So it was unsurprising that the prospect of Bloomberg making a play for the nomination at the 11th [...]

  • Combs Making the Band

    Diddy Sons Quincy Brown, Christian and Justin Combs Will Judge 'Making The Band'

    The panel of judges for the MTV reboot of “Making The Band” was revealed on Wednesday. Diddy’s sons Quincy Brown, Christian and Justin Combs along with creative director and celebrity choreographer LaurieAnn Gibson are all set to join the franchise. Diddy’s children all have careers spanning music, entertainment and fashion. “Making The Band” is based [...]

  • Lesley VisserFooty's Bubbles & Bones Gala,

    Lesley Visser to Receive Lifetime Achievement Award at 41st Sports Emmys

    Veteran sportscaster Lesley Visser will be honored with the lifetime achievement award at this year’s 41st annual Sports Emmys. It reps the first time a woman has received the accolade. “To be a pioneer at nearly every juncture of sports reporting isn’t easy despite how Lesley Visser makes it look, said Justine Gubar, executive director, [...]

  • TV News Roundup: Angelyne Signs on

    TV News Roundup: Angelyne Signs on to Produce Eponymous Peacock Series

    In today’s TV news roundup, Peacock’s limited series “Angelyne” got the titular woman as an executive producer, and Netflix announced premiere dates for “Ugly Delicious” and “Unorthodox.” DATES Netflix announced the premiere dates of new and returning shows coming this March: “Ugly Delicious” Season 2 is premiering March 6; “Marc Maron: End Times Fun” will launch March [...]

  • Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren,

    How to Watch the Nevada Democratic Debate Online

    The ninth Democratic presidential debate will take place Wednesday as six hopeful candidates take the stage ahead of the Nevada caucus on Feb. 22. NBC and MSNBC will broadcast the debate on their networks from 6 p.m. PT/ 9 p.m. ET to 8 p.m. PT/ 10 p.m. ET. Those wanting to tune in can also [...]

  • James Wolk

    James Wolk to Star in NBC Drama Pilot 'Ordinary Joe'

    James Wolk has been cast in the lead role of the NBC drama pilot “Ordinary Joe,” Variety has learned. The project explores the three parallel lives of Joe Kimbrough (Wolk) after he makes a pivotal choice at a crossroads in his life. The series asks the question of how different life might look if you made your [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content