‘Jeopardy! The Greatest of All Time’ Is a Welcome and Thrilling Surprise (Column)

Before “Jeopardy!’s” current “The Greatest of All Time” tournament began, I was firmly against it. To be frank, the idea bummed me out; “Jeopardy!,” at its best, strikes me as a profoundly democratic show, one whose appeal is or was its rewarding random folks for their trivia prowess. The elimination of the five-night limit allowed certain dominant contestants to develop seemingly insurmountable advantages in the way of experience and confidence, making the show feel grimly uncompetitive; the institution of a sort of star system, bringing back past favorites over and above simply the Tournament of Champions, developed a sense that certain among “Jeopardy!’s” past performers were not just more successful but themselves more important to the show’s ongoing success than others, a jarring way to present a show on which the trivia is really the star. I was biased, as a former “Jeopardy!” contestant who had not been met with the success of Ken Jennings, but I nevertheless felt a pang of something bigger than my own fortunes. The show was, at its best, meant to showcase new minds, not keep celebrating familiar ones.

In short, I had a bad feeling about it. And then I watched its first three nights. It’s really fun! The tournament is obviously not what “Jeopardy!” itself is — the semi-egalitarian entity described above and still airing in syndicated daytime or early-evening TV. It’s, first, a suspension of the typical, like Monopoly played using unorthodox house rules or a substitute teacher letting you watch a movie instead of doing the lesson. And it’s a genuinely rollicking thrill to see players who are frankly too good at “Jeopardy!” to make the show watchable against normal competitors go up against one another.

Everything about this “Jeopardy” event seems maximalist — the fast-reaction buzzer moves, the wagers, the drama. And yet because all three participants have already been made wealthy (and because, perhaps more crucially, all are already legends within the game-show universe), the show feels pleasantly lower-stakes than the nightly version. Jokes can be exchanged between competitors; the contestant running a distant third, Brad Rutter, is at least presenting the image of being unbothered. 

Rutter’s competitors, James Holzhauer and Ken Jennings, are more widely-known; each came to prominence during the unlimited-run era, when champions’ stints lasted as long as their luck. Rutter lasted the requisite five nights on Jeopardy in 2000 before being cut off by the show’s own limit; his “Jeopardy!” fame stems from appearances in other, less-heralded “Jeopardy!” tournaments over time. Rutter’s bad fortune in the tournament after previously limitless success provides just enough pathos to watch. After all, on a normal episode of “Jeopardy!,” he’d be running the table so handily it really wouldn’t be much fun — like an aging but still-world-class athlete among high school varsity players. Here, among peers, his overzealous wagers are appropriately cordoned off. I’m glad not every episode of “Jeopardy!” features an unbeatably dominant star, that people still go two or three nights as champion then lose. But I’m glad, too, these episodes are the thrill that they are.

More TV

  • Front row: CBS THIS MORNING co-hosts

    At "CBS This Morning,' The Mission is The Same. The Anchor Team is Not

    Gayle King, Anthony Mason and Tony Dokoupil have many years of experience behind them, And yet, in the world of morning TV, they are the new kids on the block. In TV-news circles, this story is getting a little worn: CBS News retooled its morning program as King began gaining new traction with important newsmaker [...]

  • To All The Boys: P.S. I

    What's Coming to Netflix in February 2020

    There’s no better way to start the romantic month than to binge watch all your favorite romantic films and series coming to Netflix this February. Valentine’s Day is approaching quickly, but Netflix has got it covered when it comes to finding the perfect film or show to get viewers in the mood. Get ready to [...]

  • Hunters Amazon Prime Video

    Everything Coming to Amazon Prime in February 2020

    Jordan Peele’s upcoming show “Hunters” is among the slew of new movies and TV series that will be added to Amazon Prime Video next month. Peele executive produced “Hunters,” a drama following a group of Nazi hunters in New York City in 1977. The first season, created by David Weil, stars Al Pacino, Logan Lerman and [...]

  • Maya Rudolph and Natasha Lyonne Actors

    Maya Rudolph, Natasha Lyonne and Amazon Partner on Animated Series 'The Hospital'

    Maya Rudolph and Natasha Lyonne’s Animal Pictures banner and “Russian Doll” supervising producer Cirocco Dunlap are teaming up on the animated series “The Hospital,” which Amazon has put into active development. The series will follow Sleech and Klak, two brilliant alien doctors who specialize in rare sci-fi illnesses. When Sleech defies protocol and contracts a [...]

  • Jessica Biel, Michelle Purple's Iron Ocean

    Jessica Biel, Michelle Purple's Iron Ocean Sets First-Look Deal With Paramount Television Studios

    Iron Ocean Productions, the production company of Jessica Biel and Michelle Purple, has inked a two-year first-look deal with Paramount Television Studios. The deal covers scripted television projects. Iron Ocean’s previous shows include the critically-acclaimed drama “The Sinner” for USA Network, in which Biel also starred in the show’s first season. Biel received an Emmy [...]

  • Amazon Orders Animated Series About Los

    Amazon Orders Animated Series About Los Angeles Hypebeast Culture

    Amazon is set to explore the strange phenomenon of Los Angeles hypebeast culture. The streamer has issued a two-season order for “Fairfax,” an animated series which follows four middle school best friends on a never-ending quest for clout on L.A.’s titular Fairfax Avenue: the “pulsing heart of hypebeast culture.” The series hails from creators Matt Hausfater, [...]

  • Rick Haskins The CW

    The CW Promotes Rick Haskins to President of Streaming, Chief Brand Officer

    The CW has upped Rick Haskins to the role of president of streaming and chief brand officer. In his new role, Haskins will continue to oversee branding, marketing and promotion for The CW while also tackling the strategy and distribution of the broadcaster’s streaming platforms. That includes CW Seed, the network’s ad-supported streamer, as well [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content