×

‘Wendy’: Film Review

Director Benh Zeitlin reimagines the Peter Pan story through Wendy's eyes, using a style that hasn't grown up since 'Beasts of the Southern Wild.'

Director:
Benh Zeitlin
With:
Devin France, Yashua Mack, Gage Naquin, Gavin Naquin
Release Date:
Feb 28, 2020

Rated PG-13  Running time: 111 MIN.

Official Site: http://www.foxsearchlight.com/wendy/

Eight long years after “Beasts of the Southern Wild,” Benh Zeitlin brings that same rust-bottomed sense of magical realism to the legend of Peter Pan, reframing J.M. Barrie’s Victorian classic through the eyes of the eldest Darling. “Wendy,” as the indie-minded not-quite-family-film is aptly titled, re-envisions its title character as a working-class kiddo raised at a whistle-stop diner, who witnesses one of her young friends disappearing on a passing freight train and a few years later decides to follow it to the end of the line, where runaway urchins don’t age and the Lost Boys live like “The Lord of the Flies.”

Although the director’s feral energy and rough-and-tumble aesthetic make an inspired match for a movie about an off-the-grid community doing everything it can to resist outside change (that was essentially the gist of “Beasts” as well), cinema has hardly stood still since Zeitlin’s last feature. What felt so revolutionary in 2012 is no less visionary today, but packs a disappointing sense of familiarity this time around, like tearing open your Christmas presents to find … a huge stack of hand-me-down clothing. Or else, like watching a magic trick performed a second time from a different angle.

While it’s a positive thing to get a more progressive Peter Pan story — with Peter as a Caribbean child and Wendy as a more proactive protagonist — the movie’s a bit too intense, and more than a little too arty, to suit young audiences. In the time since “Beasts,” Zeitlin’s co-writer Lucy Alibar has gone in another direction, cooking up the relatively mainstream, misfit-kid comedy “Troop Zero” for Amazon Studios. That chicken-fried, “Little Miss Sunshine”-esque crowd-pleaser plays like something the newly rebranded Searchlight Pictures might have made in its heyday, whereas “Wendy” (which Zeitlin scripted with his younger sister Eliza) will prove a trickier prospect for the now-Disney-owned specialty division to market. Debuting at the Sundance Film Festival should help, but only if audiences respond to a film about aging delivered in a style that hasn’t necessarily matured.

Popular on Variety

Wendy scarcely seems old enough to crawl when we meet her (played by Tommie Milazzo at age 3), cracking eggs on the griddle of the small-town Louisiana diner where her single mom (Shay Walker) entertains a gallery of Normal Rockwell-worthy regulars. Actually, Zeitlin’s reference point is once again Emir Kusturica, with his child’s-eye view of reality, which transforms grubby, run-down locations into fantastical palaces of tetanus-shot splendor. Terry Gilliam also comes to mind, although Zeitlin is a more competent, but perhaps not quite so original, filmmaker.

There are no name actors among the amateur cast, but Zeitlin has a proven gift for finding unknowns with great faces and expressive features, and getting the performances he needs from them (as evidenced by the best actress Oscar nomination “Beasts” discovery Quvenzhané Wallis earned for that film). His strongest asset here is Devin France, who plays Wendy at age 10, a girl in whose alert blue eyes audiences can sense the independent woman she’s bound to become. That’s important, since she’s the character, as in Barrie’s play, who insists on returning home at the end.

Zeitlin wasn’t as lucky when it came to casting Peter (Yashua Mack), choosing a young black actor with an expressive face (cherubic at times, and downright devilish at others) but a nearly unintelligible voice. When Peter speaks, it’s hard to make out what he’s saying — and that’s despite the fact the exuberantly folksy score (which Zeitlin co-wrote with “Beasts” collaborator Dan Romer) isn’t mixed quite so loudly this time around.

From the beginning, Barrie recognized both the allure and the danger of Peter’s forever-young arrangement, and “Wendy’s” precocious young heroine senses that paradox as well. Her adventure begins Early on, she spots Peter running atop the same train that takes one of her childhood friends. Several years later, she decides to follow it, hopping aboard with twin brothers James and Douglas (Gavin and Gage Naquin) as far as the ocean, where Peter rows them to the movie’s version of Neverland: a volcanic island where time stands still and a child’s imagination can control nature (i.e., make the mountain erupt on command).

It’s thrilling to discover how “Wendy” reinvents the particulars of a fairy story audiences know so well, and which Disney has so strongly codified for nearly everyone alive today — although the omission of Tinker Bell and the other fairies will likely be a let-down. While the Louisiana-set framing device certainly feels original, the movie’s tropical setting (it was filmed on Montserrat, an island in the Caribbean) actually reaches back to the iconic Francis Donkin Bedford drawings that accompanied the first edition of “Peter and Wendy.”

In lieu of a crocodile, the film serves up a great big bioluminescent sea creature, which the kids call “Mother,” and whom the island’s adult pirates believe to be the secret to reversing time. The plot, which was stitched together by a loose kind of logic to begin with, starts to unravel after the children go swimming with this glow-fish. Douglas goes missing, and James decides (at Peter’s suggestion) that he must cut off his hand to recover his brother, or stop from aging, or both.

Wendy is horrified by the idea, which is strange, since later, once James has aged and replaced his hand with (you guessed it) a rusty hook, Peter tells her, “You’re not like him. You know how to believe.” (But didn’t James believe chopping off his hand would stop the aging, and wasn’t she the skeptic in that situation?) Things get increasingly confused once the kids are taken captive by the grown-up Lost Boys, and troubling questions come to mind, such as: If all your friends jumped off a cliff, would you? And when Peter interprets the resulting plunge as “flying,” was he right? By this point, the movie’s whimsical sense of surrealism no longer makes sense.

“Wendy” is fun for a while, but as it drags on, it becomes harder to follow — and worse, boring. The magic wears off long before the characters decide to leave Neverland, and while there are some lovely visual touches (a mix of practical and CG effects make Mother glow, for example), it’s not clear what Zeitlin’s trying to say. “Growing up is a great adventure,” the movie offers, after making it seem like quite a drag. Will Zeitlin’s next film feel quite as recycled as this one does? And if it takes eight more years to make, would it be so wrong to speed up time?

'Wendy': Film Review

Reviewed at Blakely Theater, Fox Studios, Los Angeles, Jan. 16, 2020. (In Sundance Film Festival.) MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 111 MIN.

Production: A Searchlight Pictures release and presentation, in association with TSG, of a Department of Motion Pictures, Journeyman Pictures production. Producers: Becky Glupczynski, Dan Janvey, Paul Mezey, Josh Penn. Executive producers: Michael Gottwald, Nathan Harrison.

Crew: Director: Benh Zeitlin. Screenplay: Benh Zeitlin, Eliza Zeitlin. Camera: Sturla Brandth Grøvlen. Editors: Affonso Gonçalves, Scott Cummings. Music: Dan Romer, Benh Zeitlin.

With: Devin France, Yashua Mack, Gage Naquin, Gavin Naquin, Ahmad Cage, Krzysztof Meyn, Romyri Ross.

More Film

  • Pulsar Boards 'Wild Indian' With Jesse

    Pulsar Content Boards 'Wild Indian' Starring Jesse Eisenberg, Michael Greyeyes (EXCLUSIVE)

    Pulsar Content, the Paris-based sales company launched at Toronto, has acquired “Wild Indian,” a thriller executive produced by and starring Jesse Eisenberg, along with Michael Greyeyes (“Fear the Walking Dead”). The film marks the feature debut of Lyle Mitchell Corbine Jr., whose shorts have played at Toronto and Sundance. “Wild Indian” was developed at the [...]

  • The Night Clerk

    'The Night Clerk': Film Review

    In “The Night Clerk,” Tye Sheridan and a very busy Ana de Armas star as a hotel clerk with Asperger’s and the solicitous beauty who shows up after a murder. The chemistry between Sheridan and de Armas is involving. The casting of Helen Hunt as a enabling mother and John Leguizamo as a police detective [...]

  • A still from Rebuilding Paradise by

    'Rebuilding Paradise': Film Review

    Ron Howard, over the last decade, has directed a handful of documentaries (all of them about popular musicians), and maybe it’s no surprise that he has turned out to be an ace craftsman of the nonfiction form. But “Rebuilding Paradise,” which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival, is a different kind of Ron Howard documentary, [...]

  • "Winerreise"

    MK2 Leaps Into 'A Winter's Journey' Made By 'Loving Vincent,' 'Despicable Me' Artists (EXCLUSIVE)

    MK2 has boarded Alex Helfrecht’s “A Winter’s Journey,” a feature blending live-action, CGI and hand-painted animation made by the creative teams behind “Despicable Me” and “Loving Vincent.” Adapted from Franz Schubert’s “Winterreise,” the film stars Gaspard Ulliel, John Malkovich, Martina Gedeck, Charles Berling  and newcomer Gabriella Moran. Set in 1812 Bavaria, the film tells the [...]

  • Shorta

    Berlin: Charades Scoops Up Edgy Danish Drama 'Shorta' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Charades has scooped up international sales rights to “Shorta,” the buzzed-about Danish project that was presented at Les Arcs’s work-in-progress and Goteborg’s Nordic Film Market. “Shorta,” directed by Frederik Louis Hviid and Anders Ølholm, unfolds in the aftermath of the killing of 19-year-old Talib Ben Hassi while in custody. The film follows two police officers, [...]

  • Stefan Ruzowitzky

    Berlin: Stefan Ruzowitzky, Stephen Susco join 'Alone' remake (EXCLUSIVE)

    Stefan Ruzowitzky, director of the Oscar-winning “The Counterfeiters,” and “The Grudge” screenwriter Stephen Susco have boarded “Alone,” a remake of the 2007 supernatural Thai thriller by Banjong Pisanthanakun and Parkpoom Wongpoom. The new film follows conjoined twin sisters from an Asian family in Boston whose loving relationship is tested when one of them befriends a [...]

  • A couple wearing face masks walk

    Coronavirus May Hurt China's Long-Term Entertainment Industry Goals

    Halting all film releases and closing cinemas over Chinese New Year was the most dramatic possible expression of the emergency response to the novel coronavirus threat that spread from the city of Wuhan in January. The movie distribution and exhibition sectors had been counting on a billion dollars of box office revenue over the 10-day [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content