Weinstein Defense Makes Last-Ditch Bid to Call NYPD Detective

Harvey Weinstein’s defense team made a last-ditch attempt on Monday to call Det. Nicholas DiGaudio, the NYPD detective who was removed from the case after allegedly withholding information from prosecutors.

Justice James Burke previously rejected defense requests to call DiGaudio and to obtain his personnel file. In a motion filed on Monday, defense attorney Damon Cheronis urged Burke to reconsider, saying DiGaudio’s testimony could affect the credibility of the prosecution’s entire case. Burke again denied the motion on Monday.

The defense has been prevented from putting the NYPD on trial in the case. The prosecution did not call any law enforcement witnesses, instead relying on testimony from six women who allege they were sexually assaulted by Weinstein. The jury has not heard much of anything about DiGaudio’s conduct, which was the subject of substantial pre-trial wrangling.

In October 2018, the prosecution agreed to drop one sex assault charge against Weinstein, after learning that DiGaudio had failed to disclose exculpatory information about the incident. DiGaudio also allegedly coached Jessica Mann, the primary witness in the case, that she could delete anything she did not want anyone to see before turning over her cellphone to prosecutors.

On the witness stand on Jan. 31, Mann testified that she was reluctant to turn over her phone because it contained naked pictures. She said that the detective told her, “If there are any pictures, we can delete them and won’t tell Joan,” referring to prosecutor Joan Illuzzi. Mann said she ended up turning over her phone without deleting anything.

In his motion, Cheronis argued that Mann’s testimony had made DiGaudio a relevant witness.

“Nicholas DiGaudio, by the People’s direct presentation of evidence, has undoubtedly become a witness with first-hand knowledge of a disputed issue,” he argued. “The People have presented a very lengthy case, including a significant amount of irrelevant or at-best tangentially relevant evidence in an effort to corroborate its charges, and to corroborate their stories and meet its burden of proof. The investigative omissions, and at times affirmative, corrupt, and even illegal behaviors of the People’s officers directly bears on whether it has met that burden in this regard.”

Cheronis also noted that prosecutors are usually eager to have their investigators testify. Yet in this case, the D.A.’s office has argued that allowing the defense to call the detective would create a distracting “sideshow.”

“The ability to put forward evidence and testimony casting doubt on the integrity of the investigation remains an indisputably relevant issue that the jury should be allowed to determine,” Cheronis argued.

In pre-trial proceedings, Weinstein’s attorneys argued that Manhattan D.A. Cy Vance, Jr., filed charges because he was under tremendous political pressure to do so. That claim has not come up at trial, either.

The defense has made several motions for a mistrial, arguing that various errors have made it impossible for Weinstein to get a fair hearing. Each has been denied.

The defense is expected to call its final witnesses on Tuesday, with closing arguments set for Thursday and Friday.

More Biz

  • United States President Barack Obama (L)

    Barack Obama on Kobe Bryant's Death: 'Nothing Is More Heartbreaking'

    President Barack Obama spoke about the heartbreaking deaths of Kobe Bryant, his daughter, Gianna, and the seven other victims of the shocking helicopter crash last month. “That loss is something that I know many are still grappling with — particularly, Kobe, because he was with his daughter and those families and those children. And those [...]

  • Kobe Bryant Dead

    How to Get Tickets to the Kobe and Gianna Bryant Memorial Service

    The Los Angeles Lakers have announced that fans that wish to attend the public memorial of Kobe and Gianna Bryant can register for tickets online beginning Friday. The memorial will take place at 10 a.m. on Feb. 24 at Los Angeles’ Staples Center. Kobe and Gianna Bryant were among the nine killed in a helicopter [...]

  • R Kelly Sexual Assult Accusations Mugshot

    R. Kelly Hit With New Charges Alleging Sexual Abuse Against a Minor

    R. Kelly has been hit with new federal charges in Chicago, alleging that he sexually abused a minor female for four years, beginning in 1997, according to the Chicago Tribune. The superseding indictment, which was made public Friday, alleged Kelly sexually abused a girl who was identified as “Minor 6.” Kelly is already in prison [...]

  • ViacomCBS

    Third Point Adds Stakes in ViacomCBS and Amazon

    Investor Dan Loeb has added small stakes in ViacomCBS and Amazon to the portfolio of his Third Point LLC investment firm during the final months of 2019. Third Point disclosed in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing on Thursday its ownership of shares in the newly merged Redstone empire and the high-flying e-commerce behemoth. Loeb [...]

  • Plume of black smoke rising from

    Universal Music Denies Accusation That It Is Downplaying Damage in 2008 Archive Fire

    The day after Universal Music Group revealed that it is planning an IPO within three years, an attorney for four artists who have claimed to have lost recordings in a 2008 fire that destroyed thousands of assets in the company’s archives has accused UMG of “gamesmanship” and downplaying and refusing to reveal the extent of [...]

  • Eric Braeden celebrates his 40th Anniversary

    TV Iron Man Eric Braeden Marks 40 Years on 'Young and the Restless'

    If not for a tennis game with actor Dabney Coleman in the late 1970s, Eric Braeden might never have landed his signature role as conniving business mogul Victor Newman on CBS’ “The Young and the Restless.” Braeden, 78, has become an Iron Man of daytime soaps who will mark his 40th anniversary on “Y&R” with [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content