Weinstein Defense Makes Third Request for a Mistrial

Harvey Weinstein’s defense team filed a formal request for a mistrial on Monday, arguing that numerous judicial errors have hopelessly prejudiced the jury.

The motion was the third request for a mistrial since the proceedings got underway earlier this month. In the motion, defense lawyer Damon Cheronis argued that Annabella Sciorra had given hearsay testimony last week, and argued that the court should not have allowed Lance Maerov, a former Weinstein Company board member, to testify about his hostile relationship with the producer.

Sciorra testified that she had told journalists about Weinstein’s alleged rape. Victims in sexual assault cases are allowed to give “prompt outcry” testimony in order to buttress their claims. But Cheronis argued that talking to a journalist, more than 20 years later, does not qualify as “prompt.” Cheronis also objected to the testimony of Rosie Perez, who said that Sciorra had told her about the attack soon after it happened.

Maerov was the first witness in the case. He told jurors that Weinstein had threatened to sue him. Cheronis argued that the testimony should not have been allowed because it was “improper character or propensity evidence,” which shed no light on whether he committed the rapes and sexual assaults that he is accused of.

The defense also took exception to the prosecution’s expert witness, Barbara Ziv, who gave testimony about why rape victims sometimes try to stay on friendly terms with their rapist, and why they might not report the incident. The defense argued that Ziv had exceeded her expertise, and gave improper testimony commenting on the accusers’ allegations.

The defense also asked Justice James Burke on Monday to prevent Weinstein’s accusers from discussing abuse they suffered as children, saying it’s irrelevant to the charges against him.

In her opening statement last week, Assistant District Attorney Meghan Hast said that both of the primary witnesses against Weinstein suffered from childhood abuse. Weinstein’s defense argued that such testimony would be prejudicial to Weinstein, and would serve “only to stir sympathy in the minds of the jury for the complaining witnesses.”

On Monday, the prosecution called Miriam Haley, who alleges that Weinstein sexually assaulted her at his apartment in 2006. Haley was allowed to testify that she and her mother both suffered domestic abuse at the hands of her stepfather.

The jury is also expected to hear later on from Jessica Mann, who alleges that Weinstein violently raped her. Hast said in her opening statement that Mann also suffered from childhood abuse. She said that Mann grew up in an Evangelical community, and had a tough, abusive childhood before leaving home at the age of 16. The defense argued that allowing the women to talk about their childhoods would lead the jury to decide the case “based on emotion rather than logic.”

The defense earlier made an oral motion for a mistrial, after Burke denied a defense request to excuse a juror who had written a novel about predatory older men. The defense also asked for a mistrial on the opening date of trial, complaining that Hast had prejudiced the jury by showing a photo of Weinstein with Bill Clinton. Both motions were denied, but the defense again appears to be creating a voluminous record in case of appeal.

More Biz

  • MadeFor Productions

    Endemol Shine Sets Up German Scripted Label Ahead of Banijay Acquisition (EXCLUSIVE)

    “Black Mirror” and “Peaky Blinders” producer Endemol Shine Group has set up a new scripted label in Germany, Variety can reveal. Based in Berlin and led by joint CEOs Nanni Erben and Gunnar Juncken, MadeFor Film will focus on both high-end TV series and feature films for the domestic and international markets, as well as [...]

  • Deborah Dugan

    Recording Academy in Mediation with Ousted CEO Deborah Dugan

    The Recording Academy and its ousted president and CEO Deborah Dugan have officially entered mediation, just over a month after their dispute broke into the open, sources confirm to Variety. While a report in Billboard states that mediation began today, a source tells Variety that the two parties have been in communication for at least [...]

  • Harvey Weinstein deliberation

    Weinstein Jury Ends Day With Request for Annabella Sciorra's Testimony, No Verdict

    The jurors in the Harvey Weinstein trial ended their third day of deliberations on Thursday with a request to hear the testimony of Annabella Sciorra. The jury has now been deliberating for more than 14 hours, and will return for further deliberations on Friday morning. In a note to the judge late Thursday afternoon, the [...]

  • EFM Euro Film Policy Seminar

    Berlin: European Film Policy Seminar Examines Changing Landscape

    The Berlinale’s European Film Market opened on Thursday with the inaugural European Film Politics Seminar, offering a look at the pressing challenges facing independent European producers in a fast-changing landscape increasingly dominated by the growing number of U.S. streaming giants. The seminar was hosted by Steven Gaydos, executive vice president of global content of Variety. [...]

  • Gloria Allred clients suing Harvey Weinstein

    Are Harvey Weinstein's Accusers Planning to Sue? Gloria Allred Says 'This Is All Speculation'

    Gloria Allred is representing three of the six women who have testified in Harvey Weinstein’s criminal trial. The high-profile attorney has been accused by Weinstein’s legal team of having plans to sue the former Hollywood honcho after his rape trial concludes. During closing arguments, Weinstein’s lead attorney Donna Rotunno said Allred sits in court every [...]

  • Friends TV Series

    'Friends' DVD, Digital Sales Soar as It Takes a Break From Streaming

    They’re on a streaming break — but “Friends” will still be there for you. WarnerMedia’s home entertainment division is aiming to capitalize on the brief disappearance of the hit sitcom from streaming video on demand, as fans look for other ways to get their “Friends” fix. Repeats of the wildly popular laffer, which ran for [...]

  • Berlin Film Festival

    Berlin Film Festival to Hold Minute of Silence for Victims in German Shooting

    The Berlin Film Festival has announced it will hold a minute of silence at its opening gala on Thursday for the victims of the shooting that took place in the German city of Hanau. “With great dismay and sorrow, the Berlinale learned of the fatal attack yesterday in Hanau,” the festival said in a statement. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content