You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Will Martin Scorsese’s Marvel Comments Hurt ‘The Irishman’s’ Oscar Chances?

“What a snob!”

So said an Academy member when I asked about Martin Scorsese’s recent New York Times opinion piece in which he doubled down on his criticism of Marvel movies. The Oscar winner became director non grata among superhero fans last month for telling Empire magazine that Marvel Cinematic Universe films are “not cinema.” 

In the Empire piece, Scorsese said: “Honestly, the closest I can think of them, as well made as they are, with actors doing the best they can under the circumstances, is theme parks. It isn’t the cinema of human beings trying to convey emotional, psychological experiences to another human being.”

After being scorched on social media, he could have let it go by simply explaining the MCU isn’t his celluloid cup of tea.

Instead, he wrote a nearly 1,500-word op-ed defending his beliefs while continuing to bash the MCU.

And with that, Mr. Scorsese may have tarnished “The Irishman’s” chances for Oscar gold.

Here’s the deal: The MCU’s mega-franchise of 23 films has made more than $22 billion. It goes without saying that a portion of that box office was generated by Academy members. And then there was the official Academy screening of “Avengers: Endgame” in Los Angeles in May.  “I have been to a lot of Academy screenings this year, and I have never seen anything as crowded as ‘Endgame,’” recalls one audience member.

Popular on Variety

While the Academy doesn’t release the age breakdown of its membership, recent rosters of new members show an increasing diversity and a younger makeup. It’s those new voters who likely had a hand in helping “Black Panther” become the first film of its kind to snag a best picture nom.

At the same time, Scorsese is trying to have it both ways. As the director waxes poetic in The New York Times about the art of film and going to the theater to see movies, his latest movie is a $180 million production — for Netflix. 

“Would I like the picture to play on more big screens for longer periods of time?” the director asked in his piece. “Of course I would. But no matter whom you make your movie with, the fact is that the screens in most multiplexes are crowded with franchise pictures.”

In other words, Scorsese could be antagonizing voters who feel the MCU isn’t the grim reaper of cinema, but rather an art form that is attracting audiences to theaters like no other franchise has. 

Those multiplexes could feature “The Irishman,” but Netflix prefers short theatrical windows and earlier streaming premiere dates over filling a multiplex with its films — something Scorsese was well aware of when he made his deal with the streamer.

Yet by championing Netflix, he could be alienating voters who cherish the theatergoing experience and feel streamers are the real nail in the filmmaking coffin.

When “The Irishman” premiered at the New York Film Festival, it was marked as a sure bet for multiple Oscar noms, including best picture and director, as well as acting nods for Robert De Niro and Al Pacino. There was some grumbling at the time that it could lose favor among voters because of the Netflix of it all, but most observers I spoke with believed Scorsese could easily rise above the fray. One just has to look at “Roma.” Alfonso Cuarón’s black-and-white Spanish-language film about his childhood in Mexico City helped make Netflix a true Oscar player by earning statuettes for director, cinematography and foreign language film. 

One awards consultant thinks “The Irishman” is still on track for Oscar recognition: “Marty and Francis Ford Coppola have been trashing popcorn cinema for decades, including their friends’ stuff from the ’70s like ‘Star Wars.’ And there are many who agree with them that the end of life as we know it is approaching because of the dumbing down of cinema. It isn’t true, of course, but it is getting pretty stupid.”

From the get-go, “The Irishman” had everything going for it — it was an epic mobster movie directed by Scorsese and starring De Niro, Pacino and even Joe Pesci, who came out of retirement for the project. 

Now, its future at the Oscars is complicated.

If only Scorsese had a superhero to save the day. 

More Film


    'The Favourite' Wins Big At The 32nd European Film Awards

    Yorgos Lanthimos’s “The Favourite” scooped the 32nd European Film Awards, winning best film, best comedy and best actress for Olivia Colman who previously won an Academy Award for her portrayal of Queen Anne in the film. “The Favourite” was leading the nominations along with Pedro Almodóvar’s “Pain and Glory,” Marco Bellocchio’s “The Traitor” and Roman [...]

  • Ed-Skrein-Erica-Rivas-Fernando-Trueba-Lucia-Puenzo

    Ventana Sur 2019: Big New Titles, Argentina-Mexico, Deals, Trends

    BUENOS AIRES   —  The last few years have caught Ventana Sur – Cannes Festival and Market’s biggest initiative outside France – taking place as the industry debated radical change. This year saw the Latin American industries in a state of  transformation themselves, wracked by headwinds – Jair Bolsonaro’s government in Brazil – or looking [...]

  • 'Free Guy' Trailer: Ryan Reynolds, Jodie

    'Free Guy': Ryan Reynolds, Taika Waititi, Jodie Comer Star in First Trailer

    The first trailer for Ryan Reynolds’ “Free Guy” premiered Saturday at the CCXP convention in Brazil. Reynolds stars as Guy, a bank teller and NPC (non-playable character) who discovers he’s living in a video game. In the trailer, hostage situations, buildings being blown up and people shooting guns off in the street is depicted as [...]


    Asier Altuna Preps Basque Historical Drama ‘Karmele the Hour of Waking Together’

    Basque cinema is booming, and director Asier Altuna is part of the vanguard leading it forward. The Spanish filmmaker, behind 2005 Youth Award winner “Aupa Etxebeste!” and 2015 Best Basque Film “Amama” at the San Sebastián Intl. Film Festival, attended this year’s Ventana Sur Proyecta sidebar with his next project, “Karmele, the Hour of Waking [...]

  • The Day is Long and Dark

    Francisco Barreiro Cast in Upcoming Julio Hernández Cordón Project (EXCLUSIVE)

    Julio Hernández Cordón, one of Mexico’s most-awarded independent filmmakers over the last decade, has found the leading man for his next feature “The Day is Long and Dark (My Friends are Vampires),” in Fantastic Fest best actor winner Francisco Barreiro, star of Adrián García Bogliano’s “Here Comes the Devil.”. Barreiro’s casting was shared with Variety from Buenos [...]

  • Macabre

    Rio Fest’s Compact Edition Opens Amidst Sectorial Crisis

    RIO DE JANEIRO  — The 21st Rio Intl. Film Fest opens Monday Dec. 9t with the screening of Greta Gerwig’s “Little Women” in the Odeon landmark theater. The smaller than usual edition, which was almost cancelled due to the lack of municipal backing, reflects the crisis of Brazil’s film sector, involved in a battle with the administration [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content