TV Review: ‘Mixed-ish’

The 'Black-ish' spinoff, anchored by Tracee Ellis Ross' character as a teen, has some complex issues to untangle.

With:
Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Tika Sumpter, Christina Anthony, Arica Himmel, Ethan William Childress, Mykal-Michelle Harris, Gary Cole.

The latest entry in Kenya Barris’ televisual “-ish” universe is “Mixed-ish,” ABC’s new sitcom that follows in the footsteps of “Black-ish” as a heartwarming family comedy with built-in lessons about race and the perception thereof. “Mixed-ish,” unlike the 2018 collegiate spinoff “Grown-ish,” travels back to 1985 to tell a story of family members grappling with their identities at a very specific crossroads in history. On “Black-ish,” Rainbow (Tracee Ellis Ross) has often worked to orient her own experience as a biracial woman with those of her husband, Dre (Anthony Anderson), and their kids, bristling when people don’t consider her “black enough” to understand true struggle. On “Mixed-ish,” she narrates the story of her childhood and the difficulty of growing up in a world in which being biracial was far from the norm. Where Dre’s “Black-ish” voiceover marks the show as snarky and sporadically solemn, Bow’s defines the tone of “Mixed-ish” as heartfelt, hopeful and more than occasionally saccharine.

Over five seasons, we’ve seen Bow work through complicated feelings about being biracial. And yet despite visits from her parents (played on “Black-ish” by Anna Deveare Smith and Beau Bridges) and vague references to her nomadic upbringing, we’ve never quite gotten as clear a picture of her early life on “the commune” as we have Dre’s — until now. Bow waxes poetic about the commune’s open-minded values and determination to treat everyone equally before sighing about the sudden FBI raid that sent her family to the suburbs. Her optimistic father, Paul (here played by Mark-Paul Gosselaar), and more pragmatic mother, Alicia (Tika Sumpter), assured them that not much would change, which the kids quickly discovered was a well-intentioned lie. Bow (Arica Himmel), her excitable little brother, Johan (Ethan William Childress), and annoyed baby sister Santamonica (Mykal-Michelle Harris) are immediately treated differently than anyone else at their school, behavior that throws them for a loop after their having grown up in an environment in which, Bow insists, race didn’t matter. (Himmel, Childress and Harris as younger versions of Ross, Daveed Diggs and Rashida Jones continue ABC’s streak of casting uncannily good child actors.)

Here, “Mixed-ish” pulls a classic “Black-ish” and dives deep into the history of what it means to be biracial in America, including a rapid-fire breakdown of miscegenation laws and a list of today’s most prominent biracial pop culture figures. (“Today’s mixed kids can look up to rappers, ballerinas, athletes, a president, a princess,” Bow says. “The only heroes we had were DeBarge.”) For all the ground it covers, there’s not nearly enough time, but in fairness, just about every pilot has the same problem. The more interesting test for “Mixed-ish” will be how it pushes the conversation about the challenges and privileges of being biracial beyond any single episode that’s been devoted to Bow and her background thus far.

It’ll also be telling to see how “Mixed-ish” deals with how it dovetails with and diverges from the stories “Black-ish” has told about Bow and her family. The casting alone is at turns confusing and intriguing. Gosselaar is playing the epitome of whiteness, but in real life he’s multiracial. On “Black-ish,” Bow’s mother is played by Smith, an actor with a lighter skin tone more similar to Ross’ than to that of Sumpter, who plays the younger version of Bow’s mother on “Mixed-ish.” This discrepancy feels especially relevant after “Black Like Us,” a Season 5 “Black-ish” episode (scripted by “Mixed-ish” co-writer Peter Saji) in which Bow and her mother-in-law, Ruby (Jenifer Lewis), clash over colorism. Bow talks about how her lighter skin has made her feel unwanted by both black and white people; Ruby reveals that her darker skin has made her a pariah even in her own community throughout her life. If Bow had grown up with a mother whose skin was markedly darker than hers, the conflict Ruby describes may not have come as such a huge surprise. So it’s fascinating that “Mixed-ish” cast Sumpter as Alicia — especially given that Ruby cites the actor herself as an example of a dark-skinned woman who rarely gets her due.

How “Mixed-ish” chooses to engage with this revised aspect of Bow’s family remains to be seen, but it could certainly make for some deeper discussions of the nuanced differences between black realities. It would help, too, if “Mixed-ish” gives Sumpter more to work with in future episodes than it does in the pilot, in which she largely serves to balance the goofier energies of Gosselaar and Gary Cole as Bow’s Reagan-worshipping grandfather. Then again, Sumpter’s best moment by a long shot comes when Alicia firmly tells Paul that they can’t pretend their children’s race doesn’t matter. “You don’t have to change. You can be how you are anywhere in the world,” she tells her husband. “It’s different for me, and it’s different for our kids.” This distinction between their experiences doubles as a sharp shot of common sense, defining the thorny, complex issue that may, and should, take “Mixed-ish” some time to untangle. 

“Mixed-ish” premieres Tuesday, September 24 at 9 pm on ABC. 

30 minutes; pilot episode watched for review.

Related:

TV Review: 'Mixed-ish'

Production: Executive producers: Kenya Barris, Karin Gist, Peter Saji, Randall Winston, Anthony Anderson, Laurence Fishburne, Helen Sugland, E. Brian Dobbins.

Cast: Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Tika Sumpter, Christina Anthony, Arica Himmel, Ethan William Childress, Mykal-Michelle Harris, Gary Cole.

More TV

  • What to Watch on TV This

    What to Watch on TV This Week: ‘Picard' Premieres and 'Shrill' Returns

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “Star Trek: Picard” beams into existence on CBS All Access and “Shrill” returns [...]

  • SAG Awards 2020: What You Didn't

    SAG Awards 2020: From Charlize Theron to 'Parasite,' What You Didn't See on TV

    Brad Pitt made a crack about his marriages. Robert De Niro got political. And Jennifer Aniston talked about appearing in a commercial for Bob’s Big Boy. Those were just some of thing that happened on stage at the SAG Awards that were broadcast on TNT/TBS on Sunday night. However, Variety was inside the Shrine Auditorium [...]

  • Edges Unknown

    TCB, Cineflix, All3Media Announce Sales Ahead of NATPE Miami

    Miami’s NATPE market kicks off on Tuesday, but deal announcements are already landing. London-based TCB Media Rights has sold 130 hours of content to Latin America, Cineflix and National Geographic Latin America closed a deal for four titles, and Discovery Latin America picked up popular makeover format “10 Years Younger” from All3Media. TCB’s 130 Hours [...]

  • U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas

    U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas Markle Documentary

    ViacomCBS-backed U.K. broadcaster Channel 5 will air a 90-minute documentary on Meghan Markle’s father Thomas Markle. Markle and her husband Prince Harry sparked a global media frenzy earlier this month with their decision not to continue as senior members of the British Royal Family. Buckingham Palace announced that the couple are to lose their royal [...]

  • Tony Hall BBC Director General

    BBC Boss Tony Hall Lands at U.K.'s National Gallery

    BBC director general Tony Hall has been appointed chair of the board of trustees of the National Gallery. The executive, who has served on the Gallery’s board since November, takes over as chair from Sir John Kingman, who has been interim chair since Hannah Rothschild stood down from the role in September. Hall said: “The [...]

  • Fox TV Stations Greenlight 'Central Ave'

    Fox TV Stations Greenlight 'Central Ave' From Will Packer, Debmar-Mercury

    Fox Television Stations has ordered the weekly entertainment news magazine “Central Ave,” which hails from prolific film and TV producer Will Packer and Lionsgate’s Debmar-Mercury. Debmar-Mercury and Will Packer Media will produce two half-hour shows per week of “Central Ave,” which tackles pop culture and other topics from a “socially conscious and diverse lens,” per [...]

  • Frontrunners Emerge As BBC's Tony Hall

    Frontrunners Emerge as BBC Boss Tony Hall Set to Leave Broadcasting Behind

    As the U.K. industry reacts to news of Tony Hall’s intention to depart the BBC this July, top-level executives including Charlotte Moore and Tim Davie as well as external contenders such as Channel 4’s Alex Mahon are beginning to emerge. Variety understands that Lord Hall, who has headed the BBC for seven years as director [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content