TV Review: ‘For All Mankind’ on Apple TV Plus

"Battlestar Galactica" executive producer Ronald D. Moore explores a rich alternate history of America in space.

Joel Kinnaman, Michael Dorman, Wrenn Schmidt, Sarah Jones
Release Date:
Nov 1, 2019

The first moon landing looms large in American history as a vital landmark of innovation national pride, and even the evolution of news as entertainment. The country, and likely the world, simply wouldn’t be the same without it — which is exactly what “For All Mankind” is banking on.

As imagined by Ben Nedivi, Matt Wolpert, and “Battlestar Galactica” executive produer Ronald D. Moore, Apple’s new period drama opens with NASA and the world staring on in shock as a Soviet mission beats the United States to the moon. That single twist unspools a complicated alternate history of U.S. astronauts and politicians alike scrambling to keep up as the Soviet Union laps them on space exploration. Of the original series launching Apple’s streaming TV service Monday, “For All Mankind” is by far the strongest, especially because it makes the most of its budget and subsequent capacity to dream a bit bigger than most. Its production and costume design evolve to fit the changing times, and its handsome direction shines brightest in space. The writing has some shaggy tendencies, as could probably be expected of a show this ambitious. It occasionally entertains a few wry winks to the strange new historical possibilities on this hypothetical timeline, and even indulges in some distracting fictional Nixon tapes revealing the depths to which he might have gone to save face. For the most part, though, it makes the smarter choice to keep the drama as grounded in character choices as possible, with some key overarching “what if?” scenarios that keep the season moving toward a bold new future.

The ostensible anchor of the series is Ed Baldwin (Joel Kinnaman), a Navy pilot turned astronaut haunted by the fact that his Apollo 10 mission was mere feet away from beating the Soviets to the moon and changing his timeline in what he believes would’ve been a more daring direction. The first couple episodes closely follow him, his doting wife Karen (Shantel VanSanten), and assorted ground control employees like stalwart boss Deke (reliable secret weapon Chris Bauer) and laser-focused Margo (Wrenn Schmidt) working overtime to speed up their operations and dissolve the debilitating new chips on their shoulders. Several chapters in, “For All Mankind” does start to feel caught in a loop: the Soviet Union keeps beating NASA to milestones, the White House keeps forcing NASA to respond, NASA keeps redoubling its efforts. The series’ overall trajectory for its characters ultimately comes down to Neil Armstrong’s first words on the moon, which “For All Mankind” revises in a particularly pointed way. “We had a rough start,” he says with a laugh, “but we decided to pick ourselves up and get back to work.” As so they all do — over, and over, and over again.

Soon enough, however, the show reveals itself to be a workplace drama above all else, and a fairly sharp one at that. In the world of “For All Mankind,” female astronauts become a presence at NASA far earlier than in the real world, causing ongoing ripples of change. These characters, each distinct in their own ways, jolt the series with a necessary shock of narrative energy. Standouts include Sarah Jones as Tracy, the restless wife of Ed’s partner in space (a very good Michael Dorman), Krys Marshall as Danielle, a consummate professional and NASA’s first black woman astronaut, and Sonya Walger as an ornery facsimile of Geraldyn Cobb, a very real pilot whose chance to become one of the United States’ first female astronauts was dashed when NASA unceremoniously ditched her program. All experience workplace sexism in different and equally infuriating ways, though it’s a shame that “For All Mankind” seems less equipped to deal in depth with how Danielle would have to withstand the unique and perpetually difficult intersection of both sexism and racism as a black woman. (It makes some attempts, and an occasional subplot about a Mexican teenager immigrating to Texas with stars in her eyes for the cosmos implies that the show isn’t actively shying away from race — but at least in the first season, the show moreso sticks to sexism in the workplace, period.)

That’s part of why some of the best moments in “For All Mankind” come as the characters’ definitions of “patriotism” become more nuanced, complicated, and sometimes downright cynical. The toxic weight of American exceptionalism hangs heavy in the air throughout the season, and the show’s own stance on it is murky until deeper in the season as the costs of taking huge risks — both personally and politically — erode some characters’ once unshakeable faith in their mission and country. And yet, per the show’s own conjecture, the forced hyper-competition of staying in the space race does, in fact, inspire progress and advanced innovation in a way our reality still hasn’t quite reflected. Do those ends justify the often ruthless means? “For All Mankind” isn’t always sure — but it’s undeniably compelling to watch it try to figure it out.

“For All Mankind” premieres November 1 on Apple TV Plus.

TV Review: 'For All Mankind' on Apple TV Plus

Cast: Joel Kinnaman, Michael Dorman, Wrenn Schmidt, Sarah Jones

More TV


    Fox, iHeart Execs Reveal Secrets Behind 'Living Room Concert' Performances (EXCLUSIVE)

    As recently as last Tuesday, just three artists had signed on to “Fox Presents the iHeart Living Room Concert for America.” But after a week of scrambling and all-night editing sessions, the producers and executives behind the special managed to put together a one-hour event on Sunday night that attracted at least 5.5 million viewers, [...]

  • Steve Carell John Krasinski

    John Krasinski and Steve Carell Hold Mini 'Office' Reunion

    John Krasinski and Steve Carell virtually reunited for an “Office” reunion as part of the first episode of Krasinski’s new YouTube series, “Some Good News.” In an effort to brighten up spirits during the Covid-19 pandemic, Krasinski launched his new YouTube series on Sunday — and there was no better inaugural guest than his former [...]


    'How To Get Away With Murder's' Death Cover-ups, Ranked

    The road to “How to Get Away with Murder” is lined with dead bodies. Twenty-eight to be exact. Over the years, the series showed that there’s no shortage of ways to die. Suicide, poison, overdose, suffocation — you name it. The most shocking deaths, of course, are the “anchors”: In the season’s first half, each [...]

  • 'Curb Your Enthusiasm,' 'A Discovery of

    'Curb Your Enthusiasm,' 'A Discovery of Witches' Writers Set Projects at Quibi (EXCLUSIVE)

    With exactly one week left until its launch, Quibi has put four new shows in development, Variety has learned exclusively. Among the additions to to the platform’s swelling slate are an animated comedy from “Curb Your Enthusiasm” writer Steve Leff, and a thriller from “A Discovery of Witches” showrunner Kate Brooke. The Leff-created comedy is called “God’s [...]

  • Lisa RinnaChristian Cowan X The Powerpuff

    Lisa Rinna Teases 'Shocking' New 'Real Housewives' Season

    Even amid a pandemic, “The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” star Lisa Rinna is continuing to hustle while she’s hunkered down at home with her husband, Harry Hamlin, and daughters, Delilah Belle and Amelia. In an interview on “Variety Live” via Instagram, the 56-year-old reality TV guru and home shopping maven said that although she’s taking [...]


    SAG-AFTRA Announces Dues Extension Program for Members During Coronavirus Pandemic

    SAG-AFTRA has developed a program to provide dues relief for SAG-AFTRA members during the Covid-19 pandemic with an extension of the May 1 deadline. “Members experiencing financial hardship resulting from work stoppages related to Covid-19 will be granted a due date extension and an installment plan for those payments,” the union said. “As part of [...]

  • David Spade is Working Hard to

    David Spade Is Working Hard to Keep Lights On at 'Lights Out'

    David Spade was already working furiously on his Comedy Central late-night program, “Lights Out.” But nothing like this. Since the spread of coronavirus has shut down traditional production of the nation’s late night shows, Spade is toiling harder than ever to keep the program in the public eye with a series of “Live From The [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content