You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV Review: ‘City on a Hill’

That admonition credited to Coco Chanel about taking one thing off before leaving the house came to mind in the first minutes of “City on a Hill.” Sure, the line is a cliché, but it’s somehow less well-worn than the Boston-cop aesthetic that pervades Showtime’s new drama. This is a show that resists no opportunity, even a glancing one, to remind viewers precisely where it’s set. At a funeral, Kevin Bacon’s FBI-agent character comforts a widow that her husband was “like Jack Kennedy”; moments later, confronted by mourners he’d promised to pay if they showed up, he notes, “Did you forget what state you’re living in, pal? This is Massachusetts — tax is a bitch.” Elsewhere, a friend monologues that Bacon’s Jackie Rohr is “a classic Boston asshole — from a time in this city when things were so f–ked up that if you went to church on Sunday you were considered legitimate.” It’s a statement that, awkwardly preceded as it is by one resident of a city saying to another the name of the place they both live, is actually trying to make a point about the city of Boston besides the fact that it exists. By that time, however, viewers might be forgiven for tuning out.

There are plenty of reasons that a relatively small U.S. city has become the staging-ground for crime stories onscreen from “Mystic River” to “The Departed.” Some are worthwhile (the city’s history of segregation makes it a dramatically interesting laboratory for ideas of justice), some less compelling (Boston accents sound funny to non-locals; a lot of creative people have roots there and are still hung up on it). Both sides of this equation come into play in “City on a Hill.” The series starts from a relatively rich premise — the arrival of a black A.D.A. (Aldis Hodge) whose moral absolutism on crime places him at odds with an early-1990s local law enforcement community more accustomed to graft, and makes him, a black man breaking into a white power structure, doubly an outsider. (Boston is the self-proclaimed “city on a hill” in part because its white residents are so uniquely obsessed with their own virtue even as they sin, making it closed-off to newcomers of color — an arresting starting point, at least.) And then it falters, more insistent on delivering local color, perhaps as remembered by executive producers and Boston natives Ben Affleck and Matt Damon, than insight or earned character detail. Bacon is trying his best — and plunging into accent work that feels at times shaky — as an FBI agent as willing to step beyond ethical lines as Hodge’s character is upright, but Rohr, consistently, feels drawn only as a sort of Bostonian amalgam. Rohr should, given his compromised ethics, have the capacity to act unpredictably while still in character. His plot function, as an uneasy ally to the A.D.A. in a joint mission to clean up the city using different methods, begins in a novel place. But leaning quite as heavily as this series does on a very fixed idea of character type sacrifices many pathways to surprise, and much potential interest.

Even as the aperture expands, little gets better: the show’s broad view of a city of wrongdoers and accomplices features many familiar types (from sad-eyed Irish brothers in crime to Rohr’s long-suffering wife, played by a poorly-used Jill Hennessy) and little sense of what life in this particular place is really like. Hodge is, by far, the best thing about the show, blending rectitude with real sorrow and moral confusion; little surprise that he is, by his nature as an outsider, the only character who doesn’t have untold numbers of referents in Boston lore. He is necessarily surprising because we haven’t seen his like many times before — a rare thing in “City on a Hill,” and a quality the show should embrace as it goes on telling the story of a city whose points of reference are widely known throughout pop culture but may still have things to teach us.

“City on a Hill.” Showtime. June 16. Ten episodes (three screened for review).

Cast: Kevin Bacon, Aldis Hodge, Jonathan Tucker, Mark O’Brien, Lauren E. Banks, Amanda Clayton, Jere Shea, Kevin Chapman, Jill Hennessy.

Executive Producers: Chuck MacLean, Tom Fontana, Jennifer Todd, Ben Affleck, Matt Damon, Michael Cuesta, Barry Levinson, James Mangold.

Popular on Variety

TV Review: 'City on a Hill'

More TV

  • Hailee SteinfeldTribeca TV Festival 2019 Presents

    Hailee Steinfeld Announces New Single Tied to Apple TV Plus' 'Dickinson'

    Actress, singer and producer Hailee Steinfeld is set to release a new single entitled “Afterlife” on Sept. 19, a track she created for her upcoming Apple TV Plus series,”Dickinson.” More Reviews Concert Review: Deadmau5 Captivates Opening Night Crowd by Going Cube-ist TV Review: 'Evil' “This is a song I’m incredibly proud of, and I feel [...]

  • Rachel Bloom

    Rachel Bloom Announces Pregnancy After Emmy Win

    “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend” star Rachel Bloom made a special announcement after winning her Emmy for best original music and lyrics — she is pregnant. More Reviews Concert Review: Deadmau5 Captivates Opening Night Crowd by Going Cube-ist TV Review: 'Evil' Bloom announced the news backstage on Saturday at the Creative Arts Emmy Awards. She joked she had planned [...]

  • EVIL is a psychological mystery that

    TV Review: 'Evil'

    In its pilot installment, CBS’s new drama “Evil” delves into that which may lie beyond the rationally explicable. And the show itself represents something almost supernatural by 2019 standards, too: A well-made hour fueled by chemistry between its leads and a strong idea of itself. On the basis of its debut outing, which screened at [...]

  • Emmy Awards Placeholder

    Creative Arts Emmys: 'Free Solo,' 'Queer Eye' Among Big Winners on Night 1 (Full List)

    “Free Solo,” “Queer Eye,” “RuPaul’s Drag Race” and “Saturday Night Live” were among the big winners Saturday after the first night of the Creative Arts Emmy Awards at the Microsoft Theater in downtown Los Angeles. More Reviews Concert Review: Deadmau5 Captivates Opening Night Crowd by Going Cube-ist TV Review: 'Evil' “Free Solo,” the National Geographic [...]

  • Gary Cole, Christina Anthony, Tika Sumpter,

    'Mixed-ish' Team on Why 'All Stories About "Others" Are Necessary'

    The producers and cast of “Mixed-ish” are not out to tell a singular black and white story — but one that showcases and celebrates all shades in between. More Reviews Concert Review: Deadmau5 Captivates Opening Night Crowd by Going Cube-ist TV Review: 'Evil' “It’s important for me across the board in all of my work [...]

  • Shane Gillis

    Comedians Condemn Shane Gillis Over Slurs

    “Saturday Night Live” showrunner Lorne Michaels has yet to comment on the racist and homophobic remarks made by newly hired cast member Shane Gillis, but comedians and actors are expressing their condemnation on social media, some even asking that he be fired from the show.  More Reviews Concert Review: Deadmau5 Captivates Opening Night Crowd by [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content