×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘Game of Thrones’ Review: A Spectacle of Fire and Ice

The so-called Battle of Winterfell was, perhaps, the culmination of the path “Game of Thrones” has trod over its past several seasons; a show that has grown relentlessly in scope, dazzle, and cruelty reached its apotheosis in some eighty-plus minutes of slaughter and dragon-flight that forced characters through a gauntlet whose punishing nature was the point. (We in the audience marvel practically as much at the actors, clearly enduring a challenge unlike any other in the TV industry, as we do at the valiant characters.) In its exuberantly nihilistic willingness to push past the point of viewer discomfort — building from a starting point of extreme intensity to an exhausted, burnt-out stagger towards the finish line — the episode stands in as the ultimate representative of one of the ways “Game of Thrones” has seen itself, as the staging-ground for ultra-violent action whose stakes are the fate of the world.

But that’s not the only “Thrones” that exists. And, indeed, there are to be three more episodes of some other series, one in which the series’s most existentially pressing question, the fate of the world in the face of the encroaching Night King, has been settled. In a moment of catharsis at episode’s end, Arya — the mortal character on the series most particularly obsessed with violence — killed the avatar of Death, seeming to settle a question that’s stalked the show’s characters since the show’s earliest days. This would also seem to foreclose future action on quite such an apocalyptic scale: It’s hard to imagine Cersei’s armies, fearsome as they are, representing as photogenically gruesome an opponent as a squad of zombies who can reanimate at will.

That’s why what may be the passing of one “Thrones” era is as exciting as it is — more exciting, certainly, than much of an episode that tended to spare any top-billed character, preserving the ensemble but reducing the stakes as the viewer got wise to what was going on. The show promises to return to the entity it had been at its best: A story of palace intrigue and political and military grappling with an aroma of magic, rather than a story in which politics and military strategy are blotted out by the most powerful magic imaginable. (But for a hail-Mary by Arya, there was to have been no defeating the Night King, and thus everything Daenerys, Jon, and company tried was very well-shot wheel-spinning.) An avenue of the story seems to have been closed off, with the overwhelming presence of apocalyptic magic having been so well and truly eliminated as to have obviated the need for Melisandre in the story, resulting in her strangely moving walk away from Winterfell and towards her own death. And we can return to a core narrative about the battle for control of Westeros, both before Cersei’s presumed defeat and after, as onetime allies divvy up the spoils.

Game-of-thrones

That’s what can be assumed, anyhow, based on the notion that the Night King is definitively dead (an assumption that runs up against the frustrating fact that within the story, his powers were effectively limitless — but we did watch him crumble and his zombies collapse). And it rhymes with the historical oddities of structure of “Thrones,” a show that has tended to drop its big narrative bombs before season finales and to spend the final hour or so cleaning up and tying a bow on the narrative. Three more episodes seems like an appropriate about of post-Night King time to close out the narrative, and it represents an exciting opportunity to resolve what have always been the most satisfying aspects of the story. To wit: Cersei’s absence from the series for two consecutive episodes has been keenly felt, and the degree to which dialogue fell off between the balefully verbose episode 2 and this one presented a contrast. There was, first, a show at its very best-written and, this week, a show relying on spectacle to carry the day.

But what spectacle! The deus ex machina of Arya’s attack satisfied in both its culmination of a seasons-long build (her development into a master killer) and its tension-exploding suddenness. The drop-off of dialogue, if we stipulate that it must have happened to convey all the action the show insists on delivering, was underscored with painfully sad piano music, broken and soft where much of the show’s action scoring has been triumphant and bold. And fire and fog lit and darkened the sky in dazzling measure. One talking point about the show as it aired that didn’t resonate with this viewer: The darkness of the cinematography. The degree to which it was at times hard to make out images seemed rather the point, as we experienced along with characters the (very literal) fog of war, so smothering as to confuse the flight paths of Daenerys’s dragons and to convert dead and living alike into faceless masses battling for survival. This show originates from source material deeply interested in point-of-view — the novel is told through close narration depicting characters’ vantage points, with all the flaws in understanding that entails. The muddle of war struck me as deeply within that tradition.

But cinematography alone shouldn’t have to carry that burden. Characters’ realities also emanate through their words and through their stated political positions. “Game of Thrones” has delivered a major action set-piece, but the real action to come is a war of minds, to be waged among all the show’s remaining players, not just the ones with swords. For all that the visual grandeur and expense of “Thrones” have changed TV, that upcoming show, the political drama that hinges on, well, gamesmanship, is the one that has defined a TV decade.

More TV

  • Crazy Rich Asians

    Singapore Sees Rise in Co-productions, Competes for Foreign Projects

    As Singapore’s stature continues to grow in the entertainment world, and with international producers forever on the lookout for exotic but affordable locations, the Asian country is once again in global sights as a major production hub. Singapore’s distinctive topography of cityscapes and countryside, coupled with its unique cultural blend of East and West, has [...]

  • Charlie Corwin and John Penotti SK

    S.K. Global Makes Mipcom Debut With 'Crazy Rich Asians' Under Its Belt

    “To me, it wasn’t like, ‘Oh, maybe we should wake up one morning and try something different. How about we try television?’” John Penotti, producer-financier and co-founder of GreeneStreet, one of New York City’s more long-lived independent film companies — it was acquired in 2013 after 16 years — is explaining just how he ended [...]

  • singapore Skyline

    Netflix, HBO, Other Global Content Creators Set Up Asian Bases in Media-Friendly Singapore

    Netflix runs its Asian operations from the swanky Marina One mixed-use development in Singapore, an architectural masterpiece that fits in with the streaming giant’s dedication to Instagrammable real estate. Netflix’s presence in Singapore follows other major media names over the years, including HBO Asia, Vice Media and HOOQ, all of whom have Asian headquarters in [...]

  • Sidney Kimmel film financier

    Television — Sidney Kimmel's Next Act Bows at Mipcom

    During the course of his 91 years, Sidney Kimmel has accomplished a lot. That includes making a few videos for web series “Old Jews Telling Jokes.” “John’s fault,” he says. “He dragged me over there and said, ‘You’ll get a free drink and a dinner out of it.’” John is independent movie producer-financier John Penotti, [...]

  • The Outpost -- "One is the

    Electric Entertainment Launching OTT Channel Electric Now (EXCLUSIVE)

    U.S.-based producer and distributor Electric Entertainment is launching Electric Now, a linear OTT channel that will feature its top series and library content. The channel will have episodes of “The Outpost,” the fantasy-adventure series that has just had its third season greenlit by U.S. network The CW. The new season will head into production in [...]

  • American dollars bills and coinsAmerican cash,

    Entertainment Biz Comes Under Fire for Assistants' Low Wages, Working Conditions

    It’s no secret that many assistants in Hollywood bear heavy workloads for low pay. But the entertainment industry’s labor practices when it comes to those workers have now become the subject of intense social-media scrutiny. TV writer and WGA board member Liz Alper shone a light on the issue Monday with the creation of the [...]

  • Megyn Kelly

    Tucker Carlson Plans Megyn Kelly Interview on Fox News Channel

    Megyn Kelly is returning to Fox News Channel – briefly. Tucker Carlson has scheduled an interview Wednesday with the former Fox News and NBC News anchor, who will make her first appearance on her former employer’s programming since leaving in early 2017. The “Tucker Carlson Tonight” segment would also mark Kelly’s first appearance on a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content