You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Broadway Review: ‘The Lightning Thief,’ The Musical

Chris McCarrell, Ryan Knowles, Kristin Stokes, Jorrel Javier, Jalynn Steele, Sarah Beth Pfeifer, James Hayden Rodriguez.

2 hours 10 minutes

“It’s a lot to take in right now,” says Percy Jackson, the teen hero of “The Lightning Thief,” the kid-centric fantasy musical (based on the popular Y.A. novel) that’s now on Broadway after touring the country and playing an Off Broadway run.

You could say that’s a bit of an understatement from contemporary teen Percy (Chris McCarrell), who discovers he’s the spawn of a Greek god — literally. But he’s not exactly sure which god. And, oh, by the way, Zeus’s lightning bolt has been stolen and the gods are pissed because they think Percy took it and a battalion of monsters, minotaurs and furies are hot on his heels. But first he has to deal with some mean kids at summer camp.

The packed narrative may be child’s play for fans of Rick Riordan’s 2005 book — and there were plenty of enthusiasts in the audience on a recent night at the Longacre Theater, where the musical is having a limited run — but others will find the show and the bare-bones production simply myth-begotten.

The story is propelled by the clever premise that “the gods are real and they have kids and they have issues.” The eternal struggle between hapless youths and their all-powerful parents is given Olympian dimension here, as sung in a lyric in the campfire ditty:  “All things couldn’t be worse/when your folks run the universe.”

The show joins the fast-growing genre of youth-angst musicals (“Dear Evan Hanson,” “Be More Chill”) that tap into that early Spielbergian vein of kids tormented by absent parents, learning disabilities or general geekiness. Percy suffers from all of the above, but copes thanks to a low-key, self-deprecating, super-nonchalant “whatever” spirit that can have its charms, even as it becomes a millennial cliche.

McCarrell’s believable boyishness, sweet vulnerability, gangly posturing and off-handed humor is appealing, and he manages to keep you engaged even if you’ve long lost interest in the details of the plot. His singing is sure, and in “Good Kid,” the best number in the musical, he shows in a heartbreaking way the pain of trying to fit in before he discovers that “normal is a myth.”

The rest of the mostly rock-pop songs are tuneful — especially “Strong,” “The Last Day of Summer” and “Drive” — but there are a few misses, too, especially with the character of Mr. D. (Jorrel Javier) — as in “Dionysus” — who is unfunny and overplayed, and has a god-awful song. (Javier is better as Percy’s BFF, Grover, a satyr.)

Kristin Stokes is solid as Annabeth, another ”half-breed” teen at the summer camp for demigods. Annabeth completes the young posse on its Poseidon adventure— though this trio bears no small resemblance to the Harry Potter threesome of fledgling heroes.

Also impressive in the cast is Ryan Knowles, as Percy’s centaur mentor, Chiron. Knowles’ sonorous voice, sly comic assuredness and cool trot brighten the production and bring a welcome adult into the room. Jalynn Steele also has her moments as Percy’s mother, though the multiple roles the seven-member cast is asked to perform prove not so much wondrous as exhausting. The bare-bones look of the show and its not-so-special effects were no doubt the result of touring necessity. (The leaf blower and toilet paper bit is fun — once.) For a Broadway production, however, there’s a thin line between resourcefully inventive and cheap.

Stephen Brackett — who, with “Be More Cool” and “A Strange Loop,” has earned this year’s title for kinetic staging — is here assisted by Patrick McCollum’s choreography, and both collaborators keep things moving to a fault. Joe Tracz, who also scripted the overstuffed “Be More Chill,” inserts plentiful bits to distract from the crammed narrative. But platitudes like ”The things that make you different make you strong” only reinforce the impression that Y.A. musicals need something extraordinary to make it to the adults’ table.

Broadway Review: 'The Lightning Thief,' The Musical

Longacre Theater; 1069 seats: $159 top. Opened Oct. 16, 2019; reviewed Oct. 11. Running time: TWO HOURS, 10 MIN.

Production: A Martian Entertainment, Victoria Lang, Lisa Chanel, Jennifer Doyle & Roy Lennox, Van Dean/Meredith Lucio, O’Hara/Rae/Zurcher, Wei-Hwa Huang, Tosha Martin, Cara Talty, Fisher/Jacobs Baker/Masotti/Prince, Sjgh Productions and Theaterworks/USA presentation of a musical in two acts with book by Joe Tracz and music and lyrics by Rob Rokicki, based on the novel by Rick Riordan.

Creative: Directed by Stephen Brackett; choreography, Patrick McCollum; sets, Lee Savage; costumes, Sydney Maresca ; lighting, David Lander ; sound, Ryan Rumery; puppetry, Achesonwalsh Studios ; music director/supervisor, Wiley DeWeese; orchestrations, Wiley DeWeese and Rob Rokicki; production manager, Brian Lynch; production stage manager, Veronica Aglow.

Cast: Chris McCarrell, Ryan Knowles, Kristin Stokes, Jorrel Javier, Jalynn Steele, Sarah Beth Pfeifer, James Hayden Rodriguez.

More Legit

  • The Underlying Chris review

    Off Broadway Review: 'The Underlying Chris'

    Will Eno, the playwright behind “Thom Pain (based on nothing)” and “The Realistic Joneses,” goes full ­­existential in his ambitious new play, “The Underlying Chris,” by following an Everyperson character named Chris/Christine/Christopher, et al, from cradle to grave. Disconcertingly at first, this protean person is alternately played by both male and female performers. But before [...]

  • & Juliet review

    West End Review: '& Juliet'

    From “Wicked” to “Waitress,” female empowerment has been a boon for musical theater. But where those shows veered between sincerely earnest and earnestly sincere, “& Juliet” gleefully goes for broke putting gender on the agenda as it yokes pop milestones from the likes of Britney Spears, Katy Perry and Celine Dion to a girl-power revamp [...]

  • Ephraim Sykes participates in the 73rd

    Michael Jackson Musical Finds Its King of Pop

    Tony Award nominee Ephraim Sykes will moonwalk on Broadway, playing Michael Jackson in “MJ The Musical.” The show, which its the Great White Way after a rocky gestation. It begins previews on July 6, 2020, at the Neil Simon Theatre with an official opening set for Aug. 13. Sykes is currently appearing in another pop [...]

  • A Christmas Carol review

    Broadway Review: 'A Christmas Carol'

    Those expecting a traditional take on Charles Dickens’ classic holiday perennial may be in for a shock at the new Broadway version of “A Christmas Carol.” Or at least they might be terribly perplexed by this dour production, whose additions only subtract from the potency of the transformative tale. While there have been many adaptations [...]

  • Timothee Chalamet poses for photographers at

    Timothée Chalamet to Make London Stage Debut With Eileen Atkins in '4000 Miles'

    Timothee Chalemet is set to take to the London stage for the first time, appearing next spring in Amy Herzog’s Pulitzer Prize-nominated play “4000 Miles.” Matthew Warchus will direct the production at The Old Vic, which will also star Eileen Atkins (“The Crown,” “Gosford Park”). The play opens April 2020. It turns on the story [...]

  • Jonathan Groff

    Listen: Jonathan Groff Knows He's a Spitter

    If you’ve seen “Little Shop of Horrors” — the starry revival headlined by Jonathan Groff in a small Off Broadway theater — you probably noticed that Groff spits a lot when he speaks onstage. He’ll be the first to tell you that he’s been a spitter as long as he can remember, but “Little Shop” [...]

  • Key Largo

    L.A. Theater Review: Andy Garcia in 'Key Largo'

    Would “Casablanca” make a good play? Guess what: It was first produced on stage as “Everybody Comes to Rick’s.” How about “Key Largo,” the black-and-white Bogie-and-Bacall vehicle in which a handful of misfits find themselves trapped in a South Florida hotel while a hurricane rages outside? In fact, the 1948 John Huston film was adapted [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content