You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Off Broadway Review: ‘Superhero’

Superhero or superbore?

Julia Abueva, Kate Baldwin, Jake Levy, Kyle McArthur, Bryce Pinkham, Salena Qureshi, Thom Sesma, Nathaniel Stampley.

2 hours 10 minutes

A 15-year-old misfit, sitting alone on the fire escape and drawing cartoon dreams of a larger-than-life hero to rescue him from the perils of being a teenager. Haven’t we seen this one before? You betcha — and it doesn’t get any more lovable with repetition.

The kid-on-the-fire-escape trope is such a cliché that it almost seems like a sendup. But no, book writer John Logan (“Red”) is quite serious when he positions young Simon (Kyle McArthur) on said fire escape. So is Tom Kitt (“Next to Normal”), whose music and lyrics state the obvious from the first song, “The Adventures of the Amazing Sea-Mariner,” in which the teen sketches his fantasies of a manly superhero who rescues the heroine from a dastardly villain and saves the world from destruction. “He can heal the world’s suffering and pain,” goes one lyric. And at the end of the song, order is restored and “the world is safe.”

There’s nothing egregiously awful about the song and its sentiments, but there’s nothing original in them or the delivery. Only the orchestrations meet the composer’s hopeful directive of “a glorious fanfare” with “orchestral sweep.”

Kate Baldwin, a marvelous Irene Molloy in the revival of “Hello, Dolly!,” is the true hero here. As Simon’s mother Charlotte, she does a heroic job of making a pedestrian character seem like a loving, hurting human being. Her husband died two years ago and she’s still taking it on the chin, but is determined to be brave for Simon, who won’t even visit his father’s grave.

Popular on Variety

In her solo, “What’s Happening to My Boy?,” Baldwin presents a particularly moving study of a mother struggling to repair the broken bond with her son. Here, the lyrics not only work but are all the stronger for being so simply stated and so deeply felt. “Where are you, boy? / What are you hiding? / When will you trust me with all that you’ve seen? / And when will we be a fam’ly once again? / When?”

Hint: By the end of the show, Simon will come to appreciate that his mother is one of the world’s true, if unacknowledged, superheroes.

Vic, the family’s grouchy landlord played by Thom Sesma, has a nice moment when he educates Simon in one of the basic tenets of comic-book narratives — that the superhero always dies and then comes back. Simon is so blown away that he writes a new, equally banal chapter for “The Adventures of the Amazing Sea-Mariner.” But honestly, what rock has this kid been living under, not to know the tropes of his own favorite genre?

The ever-dependable Bryce Pinkham (such a livewire in “A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder”) opens a new and interesting narrative door as a mysterious neighbor. But the number that introduces and defines him, “The Man in 4-B,” falls flat.

And so it goes, one predictable moment after another. Superheroes are all very well and good, but it’s those nerds on the ground — the ones who write the words and the music — who do all the hard work for them. And if you can’t count on them, what good are superheroes?

Off Broadway Review: 'Superhero'

Second Stage / Tony Kiser Theater; 296 seats; $109 top. Opened Feb. 28, 2017. Reviewed Feb. 23. Running time: TWO HOURS, TEN MIN.

Production: A Second Stage production of a musical in two acts with book by John Logan & music and lyrics by Tom Kitt.

Creative: Directed by Jason Moore. Musical Staging by Lorin Latarro. Sets, Beowulf Boritt; costumes, Sarah Laux; lighting, Jen Schriever; sound, Brian Ronan; projections, Tal Yarden; illusions, Chris Fisher; orchestrations, Michael Starobin & Tom Kitt; music director, Bryan Perri; music coordinator, Michael Aarons; production stage manager, Diane DiVita.

Cast: Julia Abueva, Kate Baldwin, Jake Levy, Kyle McArthur, Bryce Pinkham, Salena Qureshi, Thom Sesma, Nathaniel Stampley.

More Legit

  • The Thin Place review

    'The Thin Place': Theater Review

    I can’t resist: “The Thin Place” is a thin play. But before it drifts away into the eternal empyrean, this slender drama by Lucas Hnath (“A Doll’s House, Part 2,” “Hillary and Clinton”) tells a beguiling ghost story. Well, not exactly a ghost story, but the story of a beguiling haunting that may or may [...]

  • The Ocean at the End of

    'The Ocean at the End of the Lane': Theater Review

    Is Neil Gaiman’s “The Ocean at the End of the Lane” a story of childhood for adults or an adult view of the world for children? As director Katy Rudd’s astonishingly theatrical production of Joel Horwood’s adaptation resoundingly proves, the answer is: Both. Although wisely recommended for audiences above the age of twelve – the [...]

  • Warner Bros. Pictures trailer launch event

    Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jon M. Chu Tease 'In the Heights' Movie

    Lin-Manuel Miranda, director Jon M. Chu and star Anthony Ramos took the train to the top of the world to offer a sneak peek of “In the Heights,” Warner Bros.’ big-screen adaptation of Miranda’s (other) hit musical. “I’m thrilled we’re here, and I’m thrilled we’re uptown,” Miranda rhapsodized to a packed crowd at a cozy [...]

  • Lucas Hnath

    Listen: Lucas Hnath's Own Play Gives Him Nightmares

    Tony-nominated playwright Lucas Hnath (“A Doll’s House, Part 2”) has two shows in New York this season: a monologue based on the real-life experiences of his mother, and a ghost story. One of them gave him nightmares — but it wasn’t the ghost story. Listen to this week’s podcast below: He explained why on the [...]

  • Greater Clements review

    'Greater Clements': Theater Review

    The American Dream and all of its values have taken quite a beating lately. Director and screenwriter Noah Baumbach’s “Marriage Story,” Bruce Springsteen’s recent “Western Stars” album, even Ralph Lauren in the documentary “Very Ralph” show us how this country and all of its totems and merits have gone asunder. No dreams are more crushed, [...]

  • Harry Connick Jr Walk of Fame

    Harry Connick Jr. on Returning to Broadway

    Harry Connick Jr. is headed back to Broadway with a three-week limited engagement celebration of legendary songwriter Cole Porter. The actor and musician came up with the concept for the show and is also directing. “I love Broadway and if I had two careers one of them would be only Broadway just because I love [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content