‘Pokemon Sword and Shield’ Could be a Stepping Stone to a Better Console Pokemon RPG

It’s been more than 20 years since the original Pokémon games graced Game Boys all over the world, thrilling fans with grand adventures alongside creatures with mystical powers. Ever since that original release players have dreamed of bigger and grander stories within the Pokémon universe that go beyond eight gyms and the Elite Four.

While Game Freak and The Pokémon Company have taken strides to see those dreams realized, Pokémon has remained fairly stagnate. Some games have featured multiple regions and twice as many gyms and others have had darker and more engaging storylines, but it’s been a fairly standard process for each release all-in-all. Each new entry has had trickles of new features, but nothing has changed the standard way Pokémon has worked.

“Pokémon Sword and Shield” is a crucial step in realizing a change that the series desperately needs. It brings new features, like the ability to see wild Pokémon roaming freely in some areas, the simplification of Pokémon stats, and the enhancement of the gym experience, into the fold from other Pokémon games.

Unfortunately, “Sword and Shield” only goes so far in trying to push the series further. It still sticks to archaic design choices, like tedious random battles in tall grass and the eight gym structure of the story, for the sake of tradition. I played through one of the Galar regions, (Pokémon’s take on the United Kingdom) gyms during a short session at E3 and while I came away happy I knew the series could do so much more.

I tried out all three of the new starters, solved a simple puzzle, watched Pokémon grow to towering heights with the new dynamaxing feature, and battled my way to victory with a handful of new pocket creatures. There was nothing wrong with “Sword and Shield,” but it was just more of the same. I didn’t get to try out the open areas, which was sad since they are the most ambitious parts of the new game.

Let’s face it, Nintendo has been under fire for not listening to fans for a long time. Their online service is incredibly lackluster and some of their design choices, like the inability to play certain modes whenever you want in Splatoon 2, are behind the times. They’ve started to change though as the Japanese company has listened to feedback and agreed to add online multiplayer to “Super Mario Maker 2” after limiting its availability at first. Young minds at the company have started to prevail, bringing fresh ideas to the forefront in the form of “Breath of the Wild,” “ARMS,” and “Mario Odyssey.” It’s time to bring that same change to Pokémon.

It’s not like Pokémon hasn’t seen new and innovative twists to its design. “Pokémon Colosseum” and “Pokémon XD” featured darker stories, although they didn’t have the full list of features that the series usually boasts due to Game Freak not wanting to have a full-fledged Pokémon game on consoles. Now that Nintendo’s main platform is a console and handheld, they have no reason not to.

Since many critics of Nintendo don’t have hands-on experience developing for portable systems like the DS or 3DS, we’ve never known what was possible in terms of a larger Pokémon RPG. Now that we’re seeing Game Freak develop for the Nintendo Switch we know that they have the processing power and memory to make something bigger and better—this is the system that ran “Xenoblade Chronicles 2” with somewhat ease.

Nintendo has all the tools in place: a powerful console, mechanics championed by the “Pokémon Coliseum Games” and “Let’s Go,” and all the time in the world once “Sword and Shield” is fully released. These new games gave Game Freak a chance to experiment with the new console and see what they could do with a new game. With any luck, we could see something more ambitious next time Pokémon shows up in a Nintendo Direct.

Popular on Variety

More Gaming

  • Apple Arcade

    Apple Officially Launches Apple Arcade Game Subscription Service

    Apple officially cut the ribbon for its new game subscription service Thursday: Priced $4.99 per month, Apple Arcade offers unlimited access to over 100 exclusive games. Apple Arcade was released alongside iOS 13, the latest version of Apple’s mobile operating system. Some of the titles available through the subscription package include “Lego Brawls” from Lego [...]

  • Venn co-founders

    VENN Raises $17 Million to Launch a Cheddar-like TV Network for Gaming

    Video game industry veterans Ariel Horn and Ben Kusin have raised a massive $17 million seed funding round to launch a new gaming-focused TV network called VENN. Short for Video Game Entertainment and News Network, VENN wants to mix esports with Twitch-style video game streaming and other gaming-related entertainment content when it launches in 2020. [...]

  • JoJo Siwa'The Angry Birds Movie 2'

    Nickelodeon Star JoJo Siwa Gets Her Own Dance-Tour Mobile Game (EXCLUSIVE)

    Fans of JoJo Siwa will be able to join the teen influencer’s dance squad on stage — virtually — in a new mobile game. In “JoJo Siwa — Live to Dance,” players will become part of the Nickelodon and YouTube star’s worldwide tour on her professional dance team and experience what it’s like to be [...]

  • Game Awards OrchestraThe Game Awards, Show,

    The Game Awards 2019 Sets December Date, Will Live-Stream Across 45 Platforms

    The Game Awards 2019, the fifth annual video game industry kudosfest, will be held Dec. 12 in Los Angeles and will be live-streamed for free again on more than 45 different platforms worldwide. The Game Awards is an annual celebration of video games and the people who make them, created and executive produced by Geoff [...]

  • HTC Vive Cosmos

    HTC Replaces HTC Vive With New $699 Vive Comos VR Headset

    HTC is getting ready to retire the headset that was central to its expansion into the virtual reality market 3 years ago: The company announced on Thursday that its new Vive Comos headset will effectively replace the original HTC Vive, which was first released in April of 2016. “It was time to upgrade our consumer [...]

  • Sohu logo

    China's Sohu Seeks Games Consolidation With $500 Million Bid for Changyou

    Sohu, one of China’s Internet pioneers, is offering to buy out its games subsidiary Changyou in a deal that values Changyou at $532 million. Both companies currently have their shares listed on NASDAQ, but if the deal goes ahead Changyou would lose its separate stock listing. Sohu, which has interests covering search, digital advertising and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content