×

Toronto Film Review: ‘The Cave’

A standout among Syrian war docs, Feras Fayyad’s powerful portrait audaciously puts women’s imperative contribution to survival front and center.

Director:
Feras Fayyad
With:
(Arabic, English dialogue)

Running time: 95 MIN.

Even with a steady supply of eye-opening documentaries coming out of Syria, we’re just beginning to scratch the surface of the human stories emerging from the country’s ongoing crisis. Two years after his multi-award-winning “Last Men In Aleppo” — co-directed by Steen Johannessen and following a trio from the selfless volunteer rescue collective “The White Helmets” — writer-director Feras Fayyad plunges inside another astonishing account of bravery with the female-driven “The Cave.” Beneath the surface of the besieged Eastern Ghouta, a region where some 400,000 people remain trapped, he takes us through the dimly lit hallways and limited means of a miraculously operational subterranean hospital, the Cave, managed by a patriarchy-defying female pediatrician.

Unsurprisingly, this is both an immensely humanist film, and a tough, heartbreaking watch — “The Cave” doesn’t pull its punches when it comes to graphic images, many of them involving severely wounded children. In one scene, “Please be honest with me, am I dying?” asks a fearful kid, injured (thankfully uncritically) during a Russian attack. In another, a mother’s helpless cry next to her dead son tears through the air. But then we also get lighter segments; like a surprise birthday party a group of staff throws for one of their own and witty conversations that scoop unexpected humor out of topics small and big, from rice cooking to air strikes. It’s a dizzying, disquieting film that overflows with such extreme examples of desperation and a defiantly countering sense of hope. Throughout, it honors the brave underground caregivers (many of them, students) and personnel who stayed behind on the outskirts of Damascus to help others out while risking their own lives.

Through a vérité-style “how on earth did they manage to film this and live to tell the tale?” intrigue and a character-driven structure, “The Cave” places Dr. Amani Ballor at the core of its story, which Fayyad co-wrote with Alisar Hasan. With her other female counterparts — the reserved and focused Dr. Alaa and the sweetly maternal, humorous nurse Samaher — Dr. Amani, elected as a hospital manager by her colleagues at only 29 years of age, runs the Cave with unparalleled compassion and leadership. Fending off routine sexism from those who strongly believe a woman of her age should take up other interests or ideally get married and raise a family, Dr. Amani infectiously spreads her liberal feminist beliefs to everyone willing to listen.

In the end, it is the feminine camaraderie and understanding that stands tall as the backbone of the film and perhaps even the entire operation. Despite having their physical safety incessantly threatened — above the ground, there is nothing but a wasteland of a city nearly flattened by bombs — and capability repeatedly questioned by male patients, the trio of women somehow manages to carve out an alternative space for themselves. In that, they criticize religion as an enabler of falsely perceived male superiority and work side-by-side with male colleagues as equals, even if their parity comes as a consequence of the desperate aboveground circumstances. Thematically in conversation with Waad al-Kateab and Edward Watts’ (tighter and harder-hitting) Aleppo documentary “For Sama” in the way it prioritizes wartime children and the female experience, “The Cave” lucidly assesses the physical and psychological cost of a regime that sinks as low as bombing hospitals to break people’s endurance.

Meanwhile, Fayyad introduces us to other notable characters of the ecosystem, like Dr. Salim Namour, the oldest physician at the facility. A calm and kindly professional, Dr. Salim always tends to his patients with the accompaniment of peaceful classical music he blasts out of his phone to boost the morale of both the injured civilians and the staff under his care. There is also Dr. Amani’s father — while we don’t see him, we get to witness the proud words of a doting, supportive dad via other means as he encourages his hardworking daughter. “People will forget the war at some point. But they will never forget you,” he says. “I am proud of you.”

Shot by a team of three Damascus-born cinematographers (Muhammed Khair Al Shami, Ammar Sulaiman and Mohammad Eyad) with remote direction from Fayyad when he himself couldn’t go to Al Ghouta due to the siege, “The Cave” smartly avoids talking-head interviews, favoring a you-are-there approach in unveiling the emotions of the staff and observing the inner workings of their hospital. While the lack of state-of-the-art equipment shows, it also infuses “The Cave” with an earned sense of realism: The rooms feel impersonal and dingy while the indoor light looks punishingly artificial. Though this truthfulness in visuals is supported by neither the metaphoric underwater image in the end, nor Matthew Herbert’s slightly heavy-handed score or other labored musical choices (including “Lacrimosa” from Mozart’s “Requiem”). The subjects and visuals prove tragic enough without any help from these prescriptive cues.

Still, Fayyad pulls off something miraculous with “The Cave,” which concludes with a devastating final act in flames. He transmits a unique environment of audacity onto the screen, where collective dare and wit becomes synonymous with endurance. He also proves, one character at a time, that there would be no societal survival without the smarts and equal contribution of women.

Popular on Variety

Toronto Film Review: 'The Cave'

Reviewed online, New York, Aug. 28, 2019. (In Toronto Film Festival — TIFF Docs.) Running time: 95 MIN.

Production: (Documentary – Syria-Denmark-Germany-U.S.-Qatar) A National Geographic Documentary Films release and presentation of a Danish Documentary production.

Crew: Director: Feras Fayyad. Writers: Fayyad, Alisar Hasan. Camera (color, HD): Mohammad Kheir, Ammar Suleiman, Mohammad Eyad. Editors: Per K. Kirkegaard, Denniz Göl Bertelsen. Music: Matthew Herbert.

With: (Arabic, English dialogue)

More Film

  • There's Something in the Water

    Toronto Film Review: 'There’s Something in the Water'

    Since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, the unpleasant sights, smells and pollutants of industry have typically been located where the poor folk dwell, and police society needn’t notice. With the dawn of popular environmental consciousness about a half-century ago, it became clear that toxic byproducts with a dismayingly long shelf life and unknown (or, [...]

  • 'David Foster: Off the Record' Review:

    Toronto Film Review: 'David Foster: Off the Record'

    By the early 1970s, as the counterculture was dissolving and reconfiguring, there were new pop-star archetypes on the horizon that we still tend to think of — the glam rocker, the sensitive singer-songwriter, the hair-band metal strutter, the prog-rock wizard, the belting pop chanteuse, the punk rocker. But there was another figure of the era [...]

  • Bob IgerSimon Weisenthal Gala honoring Bob

    Bob Iger Would Have Combined Disney With Apple if Steve Jobs Were Still Alive

    Disney and Apple are both launching their own streaming services come November, but Disney CEO Bob Iger says the two companies weren’t always on competing paths. In an excerpt from his autobiography published Wednesday in “Vanity Fair,” Iger revealed that Disney and Apple likely would have merged if Steve Jobs hadn’t died in 2011. “I [...]

  • Aaron Janus Lionsgate

    Lionsgate Hires 'A Quiet Place' Producer Aaron Janus as Senior VP of Production

    Lionsgate has hired Aaron Janus as its new senior vice president of production and promoted Meredith Wieck to the post of vice president of production.  Prior to Lionsgate, Janus served as Platinum Dunes’ head of development, where he oversaw filmmakers Brad Fuller, Andrew Form and Michael Bane. There, he brought in “A Quiet Place,” on [...]

  • Ang Lee Reveals First Look at

    Ang Lee on 'Gemini Man' and De-Aging Will Smith

    On paper, Ang Lee’s “Gemini Man” is a standard-issue, shoot ’em up with Will Smith playing a deadly assassin who must battle a younger clone of himself. The explosions and gun battles aren’t what drew Lee to the project, even if they’re the reason that most people will show up at theaters when it opens [...]

  • Hopper Reserve

    Dennis Hopper's Dying Wish: His Own Strain of Marijuana

    Even as celebrity brands are starting to flood the emerging Cannabis market, Hopper Reserve stands out. The brand was launched by Marin Hopper, Dennis Hopper’s daughter from his marriage to Brooke Hayward. Hopper Reserve is a gram of California indoor-grown flower, two packs of rolling papers, a pair of matches and a trading card either [...]

  • Sean Clarke Aardman Staff Photography Bristol.Pic

    Aardman Appoints Sean Clarke as New Managing Director

    Aardman, the Oscar-winning animation studio behind “Chicken Run” and “Early Man,” has appointed Sean Clarke as its new managing director, replacing co-founder David Sproxton, who is stepping down after 43 years. Clarke has worked at the British studio for more than 20 years, including heading the international rights and marketing department for over a decade. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content