You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘What We Left Unfinished’

Abandoned features found in the Afghan Film archives shed light on the nation's short, rocky Communist era.

Miriam Ghani
Latif Ahmadi, Said Miran Farhad, Juwansher Haidary, Wali Latifi, Faqir Nasi, Yasamin Yarmal, Shirindad Dakkoi, Sarwardin Haidabi, Khalek Halil, Sultan Istalefi. (Dari, English dialogue.)

1 hour 11 minutes

Assembling a few found shards from the recent history of endlessly broken Afghanistan, “What We Left Unfinished” is cultural archaeology of special interest to cineastes. Miriam Ghani’s film spotlights five features that were abandoned during that nation’s Communist era (1978-1991), their fate decreed by regime changes or the vagaries of censorship. Excerpts from surviving footage plus latter-day interviews with the filmmakers highlight the fragility of artistic creation under even less turbulent circumstances, and provide insight into a hitherto largely inaccessible period in which strict political messaging nonetheless permitted a great deal of intriguing celluloid expression.

Six years in the making, the U.S.-based Ghani’s first feature (she’s done a number of prior shorts and installations on post-war Afghani issues) is basically a collaboration with the state film institute Afghan Films, which has safeguarded a large if haphazard body of homegrown movies though seemingly never-ending national upheaval. She discovered that among its treasures were several near-complete, unreleased narrative features from throughout the Communist years: “The April Revolution” (1978), “Downfall” (1987), “The Black Diamond” (1989), “Wrong Way” (1990) and “Agent” (1990).

The many clips scattered throughout “What We Left Unfinished” are often without sound (having never gotten to the postproduction stage), but otherwise are in excellent condition, running a gamut from rather basic-looking dramas to fairly glossy, widescreen action-adventures. Nearly all appear to encase their moral or political lessons in high melodrama, often as thrillers — the stories ranging from “village lovers separated by ethic feud” to literally explosive tangles between spies and international drug runners. If the acting often appears rather crude, one must keep in mind that such work was considered inherently sinful by many in the country’s Muslim majority, so the talent pool wasn’t deep.

Some of these films never saw the light of day because their particular political slant had already expired (“April” offered a version of the 1978 coup that was no longer officially sanctioned by the end of its shooting schedule), or because the entire regime had changed during production. But the filmmakers interviewed here agree that despite ever-shifting propaganda stipulations, they were given a fair amount of freedom otherwise, and funding flowed from Soviet minders accustomed to using cinema as a political tool. More problematic was the fact that appointed Soviet “advisers” often exercised their censorship powers in sweeping and arbitrary ways.

When the embattled Communist regime finally fell, many of these filmmakers fled the country. Most assumed the unfinished features were lost forever — likely destroyed amid subsequent civil wars, invasions, or Taliban campaigns against offending material. Their joy at seeing their work decades later is infectious. They also share some hilarious and hair-raising stories that recall those of the cinema’s earliest days — for instance, dangerous stunts undertaken by insufficiently trained personnel and use of real bullets in shootout sequences because blanks were hard to come by.

Ghani adds another texture to the mix of archival footage and talking heads by including elegant tracking shots through the decrepit (but still gorgeous) interior of what was once the headquarters of the nation’s film industry. Ian Olds’ editing merits special credit in a package that feels amiably unhurried despite its short running time. This fascinating footnote to screen history is further polished by Qasim Naqvi’s attractive electronic score.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'What We Left Unfinished'

Reviewed at SFFilm, April 11, 2019. (Also in Berlin Film Festival.) Running time: 71 MIN.

Production: (Documentary — U.S.-Afghanistan-Qatar) An Indexical Films production in association with Ajna Films. (International sales: Wide House, Paris.) Producer: Miriam Ghani. Executive producer: Alysa Nahmias.

Crew: Director: Miriam Ghani. Camera (color, HD): Adam Hogan. Editor: Ian Olds. Music: Qasim Naqvi.

With: Latif Ahmadi, Said Miran Farhad, Juwansher Haidary, Wali Latifi, Faqir Nasi, Yasamin Yarmal, Shirindad Dakkoi, Sarwardin Haidabi, Khalek Halil, Sultan Istalefi. (Dari, English dialogue.)

More Film

  • Collective for Webstory

    Venice: Cinephil Takes World Sales on HBO-produced Doc 'Collective,' also in Toronto (EXCLUSIVE)

    Tel Aviv-based sales agent Cinephil has taken world sales on Emmy Award-winning director Alexander Nanau’s “Collective,” an investigation into the tragic 2015 fire in a Bucharest night club, fallout from which toppled Romania’s government. The high-profile doc is screening in Venice and Toronto. Co-produced by Nanau with HBO Europe and Romania’s Samsa Film — and [...]

  • Donald Sutherland Honorary Oscar

    Donald Sutherland to Receive San Sebastian Donostia Award

    MADRID — The San Sebastian Festival has announced the third and final recipient of this year’s Donostia career achievement awards, Canadian actor Donald Sutherland. He will accept his award before the screening of his latest film, Guiseppe Capotondi’s “The Burnt Orange Heresy.” With more than 200 credited performances over the past half-century, Sutherland stands tall, [...]

  • "Weathering With You" directed by Makoto

    'Weathering With You' Hit Anime Selected as Japan’s Oscars Contender

    “Weathering with You,” the hit animation by Makoto Shinkai, has been selected as Japan’s contender for a the International Feature Film Awards at the Oscars, the Japan Motion Picture Producers Association(Eiren) announced on Monday. As of Wednesday last week, “Weathering” had grossed more than $94 million in Japanese theaters. More Reviews Album Review: Tanya Tucker's [...]

  • (from left) Luke Hobbs (Dwayne Johnson)

    China Box Office: 'Hobbs & Shaw' Roars to Top With $101 Million Debut

    Revving up against a line-up completely devoid of serious competitors, “Fast & Furious Presents: Hobbs & Shaw” roared to the top of China’s box office with a $101 million debut, figures from consultancy Artisan Gateway show — more than four times the haul of the weekend’s second highest grossing title. China is one of the [...]

  • El Principe

    First Look: Trailer for Venice Critics' Week Prison Drama 'El Principe' (EXCLUSIVE)

    “How did you end up in here?” an older inmate asks Jaime, a young man who unexpectedly finds himself in prison. The answer: He killed his best friend. “El Principe” is Chilean director Sebastián Muñoz’s debut feature and has its world premiere in the Critics’ Week section at the Venice Film Festival. Set in Chile [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content