You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Toronto Film Review: ‘Dirt Music’

Western Australia gets a stunning showcase in Gregor Jordan’s romance, but the story never finds the right key.

Kelly Macdonald, Garrett Hedlund, David Wenham, Julia Sarah Stone, George Mason, Aaron Pedersen, Ava Caryoffylis.

1 hour 44 minutes

Tim Winton’s 2001 novel “Dirt Music” told the story of two haunted loners drawn into a bizarre love triangle in a remote fishing village on the coast of Western Australia. But the novel’s setting was always its most vibrant character, with Winton dissecting and eulogizing the gorgeous, harsh, mythical wildernesses of Australia’s largest state in expansive passages. In that sense, director Gregor Jordan’s adaptation is faithful to Winton’s novel to a fault, working hard to provide postcard-perfect views of Western Australia, while never seeming as engaged with the film’s characters, and here that proves a far bigger obstacle. Centered on characters who act without much in the way of logic, with much of its dialogue confined to clipped bursts of unsatisfying Hemingwayisms, “Dirt Music” is a fine-looking romance that never finds the right key.

The film largely focuses on Georgie (Kelly Macdonald), a former nurse trapped in a passionless marriage with Jim (David Wenham), an older, recently widowed fisherman who lords over the fictional town of White Point, worshiped by the salt-of-the-earth locals who barely deign to speak to his city-slicker wife. While skinny-dipping near their seaside mansion one evening, Georgie happens upon a fisherman scavenging for lobsters in a small motorboat, his dog left tied up on the beach. This is Lu Fox (Garrett Hedlund), a taciturn local outcast who once played in a family folk music band, driven by an unspecified tragedy to renounce music – “I don’t play anymore, I don’t even listen” – and eke out a meager living as an illegal poacher.

On her way to Perth a short time later, Georgie’s car breaks down, and she hardly seems surprised when Lu comes puttering up the road behind her. No sooner has she badgered him into giving her a lift into the city than she lays out her intentions: “I’m not a very faithful fishwife.” Lu barely registers the come-on, but allows himself to be drawn into a tryst with her anyway. It isn’t long before Jim discovers both the affair and Lu’s encroachment on his fishing territory.

As far as love triangles go, this one is initially low on acute angles. Jim barely seems surprised to learn that his wife has gone astray; Georgie appears to have very little tying her to her marriage or to the town; and Lu is too busy being haunted by his past to notice any of the trouble he’s causing, spending most of his scenes staring catatonically into the middle distance and holding imaginary conversations with his dead niece, Bird (Ava Caryoffylis).

After the local fisherman deal Lu some shockingly sadistic payback for poaching in their waters, Lu heads north for a particularly remote island off Australia’s northwestern coast, and Georgie decides to follow. It’s here that the film arrives at what should be its crescendo – with Lu hitchhiking toward his doom, Christopher McCandless-style, and Georgie racing to find him – and Jordan locks into a previously elusive rhythm. But these characters have been so hazily defined that the pulse-pounding finale, as well-executed as it is, never cuts as deep as it should. Though ably played by Macdonald, Georgie’s character loses the most in the transition from page to screen. We’re told she has a drinking problem, even though we’ve seen her get tipsy maybe once. And one scene in which she’s forced to visit her estranged wealthy family (scarcely mentioned before or after) is so bizarrely out of sync with the tone of the rest of the film that one wonders why the subplot wasn’t cut entirely.

Considering the abundance of marquee-name Aussie actors, it’s curious that such a quintessentially Australian film features an American (Hedlund) and a Scotswoman (Macdonald) in its two largest roles, but both do as well as they can with difficult characters. Yet the real stars here are the location scouts, who unearth such gorgeous vistas – from the emerald waters of Esperance to the almost extraterrestrial landscapes of the Dampier Peninsula – that one wouldn’t be surprised to see more film productions make the trek to Australia’s west coast, hopefully with more satisfying scripts in tow.

Popular on Variety

Toronto Film Review: 'Dirt Music'

Reviewed at Wilshire Screening Room, Los Angeles, August 27, 2019. (In Toronto Film Festival – Special Presentations)

Production: A Wildgaze Films, Aquarius Film production. Produced by Finola Dwyer, Amanda Posey, Angie Fielder, Polly Staniford. Executive producers: Daniel Battsek, Sue Bruce-Smith, Lauren Dark, Peter Touche, Stephen Dailey.

Crew: Directed by Gregor Jordan. Screenplay: Jack Thorne, from the novel by Tim Winton. Camera (color): Sam Chiplin. Editor: Pia Di Ciaula. Music: Craig Armstrong.

With: Kelly Macdonald, Garrett Hedlund, David Wenham, Julia Sarah Stone, George Mason, Aaron Pedersen, Ava Caryoffylis.

More Film

  • They Shall Not Grow Old restoration

    Peter Jackson Documentary 'They Shall Not Grow Old' Nabs Limited China Release

    The Peter Jackson produced and directed World War I documentary “They Shall Not Grow Old” will hit Chinese theaters on November 11. Though it will roll out nationwide, it will do so via the China’s National Arthouse Alliance, which has limited screens. The 2018 documentary puts together interviews with WWI veterans and more than 100-year-old [...]

  • Zombieland Double Tap

    'Zombieland: Double Tap' Hopes to Recapture Raunchy Zombie Magic, 10 Years Later

    Audiences may have a few questions about the sequel to 2009’s hit “Zombieland,” which opens Friday. Why did it take 10 years to make a second one, after the first grossed $102.4 million worldwide on a $23 million budget, making it the third-biggest zombie movie of all time (second-biggest if you don’t count “Hotel Transylvania,” [...]

  • AMC TheatresShop signs, Los Angeles, America

    AMC Theatres Accused of Firing VP Who Complained of Gender Pay Gap

    A former vice president at AMC Theatres filed a federal lawsuit on Wednesday, accusing the company of firing her after she complained that she was paid far less than her male peers. Tonya Mangels, who was vice president of product marketing, said that in March 2018 her supervisor inadvertently sent her a spreadsheet that included [...]

  • Sir Elton John poses for photographers

    Elton John Calls 'Lion King' Remake a 'Huge Disappointment'

    Elton John isn’t feeling the love for Disney’s latest live-action remake. In an interview with GQ U.K., the legendary musician criticized Disney’s remake of “The Lion King,” citing the film’s music as a “huge disappointment.” “The new version of The Lion King was a huge disappointment to me, because I believe they messed the music [...]

  • Fiddlin'

    Film Review: 'Fiddlin''

    Not many forms of music have “old-” actually built into their name as a prefix. So it’s a given that the practitioners of the 200-year-old genre known as “old-time music” will wear their antiquity proudly in “Fiddlin’,” a documentary set in and around the 80th annual Old Fiddler’s Convention in Galax, Va. What may not [...]

  • Jonah Hill attends the press conference

    Jonah Hill Passes on Role in 'The Batman'

    After being offered a role in “The Batman,” Jonah Hill has moved on from the project. Why exactly Hill is passing is currently unknown, and insiders tell Variety that when the news was initially reported, it was very early in the negotiations and that a deal was far from closing. The news comes after Zoe [...]

  • Daniel Kaluuya Elizabeth Moss

    SCAD Savannah Film Festival Honorees Include Daniel Kaluuya, Elisabeth Moss

    Daniel Kaluuya, Elisabeth Moss, Danielle Macdonald, Aldis Hodge, Valerie Pachner, Samantha Morton, Sienna Miller, Alan Silvestri and Olivia Wilde are set to be honored at the 22nd Annual SCAD Savannah Film Festival. Breakout Award honorees include Beanie Feldstein, Kaitlyn Dever, Jharrel Jerome, Mena Massoud and Camila Morrone. Macdonald, who appears on Netflix in “Unbelievable” and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content