×

Writers Guild Expands Suit Against Agencies With New Fraud Allegations

The Writers Guild of America has bulked up its lawsuit with additional fraud allegations against Hollywood’s four biggest talent agencies.

The WGA amended its suit Monday in Los Angeles Superior Court with the claim that CAA, WME, UTA and ICM partners have engaged “constructive fraud” by allegedly placing their own interests ahead of their clients and by concealing facts about how packaging works.

The amended complaint alleges “failure of a fiduciary to disclose a material fact to his principal that might affect the fiduciary’s motives or the principal’s decision constitutes constructive fraud, regardless of whether the fiduciary acted with fraudulent intent.”

The amended complaint also alleged that agencies are operating in a conflicted position because their interests in negotiating packaging fees for themselves are at odds with the interests of writer clients.

The Association of Talent Agents, which serves as the negotiating arm for the agencies, brushed off the amended complaint. The ATA failed to negotiate a deal with the WGA after more than two months of formal talks over efforts to revamp the 43-year-old rules governing how agents represent WGA members.

The WGA’s campaign to ban packaging fees and affiliate ownership led to a April 12 directive from the guild to its nearly 15,000 members to terminate relations with agents that refused to sign the guild’s new Code of Conduct. In response, the ATA alleged that the WGA never had any intention of making a deal and predicted that the suit will be tossed out.

“This is a desperate attempt by the WGA to keep their utterly meritless legal battle alive,” the ATA said in its statement. “Today’s action by the WGA is further evidence that Guild leadership had no intent to pursue a negotiated solution with the ATA, instead opting for a long and costly legal process that was completely avoidable.”

“It is ironic that the Guild is accusing these agencies of fraud when in reality, it is Guild leadership who have misled their members into believing they are trying to make a deal,” the ATA also said. “Unfortunately, it’s those members who will be footing this bill with their own membership dues, and who will have to continue without agent representation.”

The original suit, filed April 17, alleged that the practice of agencies collecting packaging fees violates state and federal law. Those fees are typically calculated as 3% of the program’s budget and another 10% of backend profits. In TV, writers and other agency clients who work on a packaged show do not have to pay the standard 10% commission on their salaries, a benefit seen as the trade-off for allowing the agency to take the upfront and backend fees.

The plaintiffs are the guild’s West and East branches and eight individual writers — Patti Carr, Ashley Gable, Barbara Hall, Deric Hughes, Chip Johannessen, Deirdre Mangan, David Simon and Meredith Stiehm.

The allegations added in the amended complaint include concealment packaging fees are paid directly by production companies from a program’s budget or revenues to the agency; that agencies allegedly sought to prevent their clients from working with talent represented by other agencies in order to avoid having to split packaging fees with other agencies; and that agencies allegedly intentionally failed to maximize their clients’ compensation in order to maximize their own packaging fees.

The amended complaint also alleges that agencies intentionally failed to pitch clients’ to production companies that would pay the most and instead pitched to companies that the agencies believed would pay the largest packaging fee.

Nearly 70 agencies have signed the WGA’s new Code of Conduct, which was overwhelming approved by a member vote in March and went into effect on April 13. The most prominent is Verve, which signed on May 16. No new negotiations are scheduled.

The WGA has been providing its members with extensive guidance as to making deals during the TV staffing season. It’s also told members that labor law permits the WGA to assign the power to perform the agenting task of procuring employment to managers and lawyers.

The ATA said in its statement Monday that attorneys for the agencies met with the last week to inform them they would file motions to dismiss the lawsuit — alleging that doing so prompted the WGA to go back to the drawing board and amend their original complaint.

“Knowing that it could take months or even years for this litigation to be resolved, WGA leaders are unnecessarily forcing their members and our industry into long-term uncertainty,” the statement added, “While the legal process runs its course, ATA strongly believes that in the interim it remains in the best interests of writers to be represented by licensed talent agencies.”

 

 

 

More Film

  • Box Office: 'Annabelle Comes Home' Kicks

    Box Office: 'Annabelle Comes Home' Kicks Off Tuesday With Solid $3.5 Million

    Warner Bros. and New Line’s “Annabelle Comes Home” collected a strong $3.5 million in Tuesday night previews. The supernatural thriller is expected to earn $30 million over its first five days in theaters. “Annabelle Comes Home” is the third “Annabelle” movie and seventh entry in the Conjuring franchise. Preview ticket sales are in line with [...]

  • Naomi Watts Thriller 'The Wolf Hour'

    Naomi Watts Thriller 'The Wolf Hour' Picked Up for U.S. by Brainstorm Media

    “The Wolf Hour,” a psychological thriller starring Naomi Watts and Jennifer Ehle, has been picked up for North America by Brainstorm Media. HanWay Films has also closed sales for a host of European and Asian territories. Directed by Alistair Banks Griffin, “The Wolf Hour” features Oscar-nominated Watts as June, a former countercultural celebrity who lives [...]

  • A Star Is Born

    'A Star Is Born' Soundtrack Surpasses Global Sales of 6 Million

    Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper’s onscreen chemistry continues to be felt on the official soundtrack to “A Star is Born,” which just surpassed 6 million albums sold globally and has been certified double platinum in the U.S. Released by Interscope Records in 2018, the album debuted atop the charts and remains the highest-selling album of [...]

  • monty-python-are-fifty-in-2019

    Previously Unreleased Monty Python Audio to Get Airing for Troupe's 50th Anniversary

    Michael Palin will exec-produce series of radio specials containing never-before-released audio from Monty Python as part of the 50th anniversary celebrations for the iconic comedy troupe. They will play on the BBC in the U.K. and then go out in the U.S. Palin and his fellow Pythons – John Cleese, Terry Gilliam, Eric Idle, Terry [...]

  • The Eight Hundred (The 800)

    Huayi Brothers' Stock Falls 8% After 'The Eight Hundred' Cancellation

    Huayi Brothers’ stock fell by more than 8% on Wednesday, the day after the veteran Chinese studio announced that its new war epic, “The Eight Hundred,” will not hit Chinese theaters as scheduled next week. Shares dropped from RMB5.48 to RMB5.02 overnight after Huayi said Tuesday that its summer blockbuster’s theatrical debut would be indefinitely [...]

  • Chinese actor Xu Zheng holds his

    Golden Horse Organizers Set Clashing Date With China's Golden Rooster Awards

    The prestigious Golden Horse Awards announced Wednesday that it will hold its annual ceremony in Taiwan on the same day this year as China’s Communist-backed Golden Rooster Awards – which virtually assures that no major mainland Chinese talent will attend the event known as Asia’s Oscars on November 23. Hong Kong director Johnnie To will [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content