Movies, TV Shows Fall Short in Depicting Mental Health Issues (Study)

Millions of people struggle with depression, anxiety, and other mental health issues — just not on the big screen or on television.

Historically, films such as “Ordinary People” or “Good Will Hunting” and shows such as “In Treatment” have dramatized these types of issues, but they remain the exception to the rule. Less than 2% of all film characters and roughly 7% of TV characters experience mental health conditions on screen, according to a new report by the USC Annenberg Inclusion Initiative. That doesn’t reflect the experiences of a significant portion of the moviegoing and television-watching audiences. Close to 20% of the U.S. population reports some form of mental health condition or illness per year. And Hollywood often does more harm than good in its depictions. When mental health issues are portrayed on screen, the characters are often treated disparagingly or are shown being violent.

“It perpetuates negative attitudes and prejudices about mental health issues,” said Dr. Stacy L. Smith, the report’s author. “There is vast room for improvement.”

To get their results, Smith and her team looked at the 100 top-grossing movies of 2016, as well as the first episode of the highest rated TV series from the 2016 to 2017 season. They also used a broad definition of mental health conditions — one that encompassed mood disorders, anxiety, addiction, PTSD, suicide, and autism spectrum disorders.

The study found that 46% percent of film characters and 25% of TV characters with a mental health condition exhibited violent or aggressive behavior, something that experts say is divorced from reality. The report looked at how shows and movies depict suicidal characters, finding that there were 13 instances of suicide or suicidal attempts in the films they examined and six on television. These portraits of suicide often lacked sufficient depiction of the character’s larger mental health issues and did not deeply examine treatment options, the study claims. Many of the characters on screen were treated in a demeaning fashion. Nearly half of film (47%) and 38% of TV characters shown with a mental health condition were insulted and were called insults such as “crazy” or “freak,” or they suffered from other forms of rejection.

USC and Smith have devoted time and resources to looking at Hollywood’s lack of representation when it comes to depicting people of color, women, and members of the LGBTQ communities. This report is slightly different in its focus. The school conducted the latest study in partnership with the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (AFSP) and received funding from the David and Lura Lovell Foundation, a fund that often supports initiatives dealing with mental health, integrative health and wellness.

In keeping with their earlier work, Smith and her team also looked at the populations that are depicted in movies and shows grappling with these health issues. They found that most characters with mental health conditions were straight, white, adult males, and few figures were from different racial or ethnic backgrounds. No film characters with mental health conditions were Latino or Hispanic, nor were any Middle Eastern, North African, Native American, or Pacific Islander. Four characters were Asian and 11 were African-American or black.

Moreover, no LGBT film characters had mental health condition across the 100 top films of 2016 and only 8 TV characters across 50 popular shows grappled with such issues. This omission occurred despite the fact that the National Association of Mental Illness reports that mental health conditions are three times more likely to occur among members of the LGBTQ community.

The study’s authors say they hope that movies and shows will be more sensitive in their depiction of mental health conditions, which could remove stigmas and encourage people to seek help. They also believe that Hollywood needs to do more to reflect a broader shift in the culture.

“When you look at prevailing attitudes towards mental health in our country, there’s been a tremendous turn for the positive in the past five to seven years,” said Dr. Christine Moutier,chief medical officer at AFSP. “Mental illness was once viewed as a moral or spiritual shortcoming — as a character flaw. But we’ve seen that change in recent years.”

“There’s a role for popular storytelling to play in deepening our understanding of these issues and removing negative attitudes,” she added.

More Film

  • Fernando Szew and Tomas Yankelevich

    Particular Crowd, MarVista Set 10-Plus Movies a Year Partnership (EXCLUSIVE)

    MIAMI — Particular Crowd, the big new film banner of Warner Media’s Turner Latin America, and MarVista Entertainment, one of the world’s biggest and ambitious of independent entertainment studios, have announced a multi-year production slate deal. As part of the deal, Particular Crowd and MarVista will target production of 10-plus films per year, focusing on elevated [...]

  • Andy Serkis

    BAFTA to Honor Andy Serkis

    The British Academy of Film and Television Arts (BAFTA) is presenting Andy Serkis with its Outstanding British Contribution to Cinema Award at the 73rd EE British Academy Film Awards ceremony on Feb. 2 in London. The organization said Thursday that it was honoring the British actor, producer and director for his pioneering work on performance [...]

  • The Olympic Rings adorn an event

    Tokyo Olympics Brings Upheaval to Japan's Summer Events Schedule

    The Tokyo Olympics, to be held from July 24 to Aug. 9, and Paralympics, scheduled for Aug. 25 to Sept. 9, are affecting Japan’s big summer events. Everything from fireworks displays to music festivals have chosen to shift dates or even cancel altogether. The only film festival so far to announce a change in dates [...]

  • The Rescue

    Overseas Releases of Chinese Films to be Cancelled Following Virus Outbreak

    The overseas release of Chinese films in the next weeks is certain to be affected by the cancellation of theatrical outings in mainland China as a response to the rampant spread of the coronavirus. On Thursday, movie companies in China announced they would not go ahead with the release of seven major films at Chinese [...]

  • Boris JohnsonConservative Party rally on eve

    U.K. Parliament Passes Brexit Law, Leaving Film, TV Incentives Unaffected

    The U.K. Parliament on Wednesday evening passed legislation paving the way for the country to leave the European Union on Jan. 31, 2020. British Prime Minister Boris Johnson said the U.K. had “crossed the Brexit finish line” following passage of the Withdrawal Agreement, which will officially become law when it receives royal assent from Queen [...]

  • A security guard wears a mask

    Chinese New Year Film Releases Cancelled in Response to Coronavirus

    The deadly coronavirus outbreak has dealt a fatal blow to China’s biggest movie-going weekend of the year, as all new releases were cancelled to prevent further spread of the disease. Seven major films were expected to have been released over the coming weekend, with the likelihood that together they would have earned more than $1 [...]

  • The Turning

    Film Review: ‘The Turning’

    Director Floria Sigismondi’s “The Turning” is like the alt-rock cousin of author Henry James’ novella “The Turn of the Screw.” From its grunge-infused soundtrack and period setting to its fiery feminist overtones, this is an ambitious contemporary take on the iconic, claustrophobic thriller. Concerning two young orphans who psychologically torment their caretaker in a spooky, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content