It’s Time for Documentaries to Be Seriously Considered for Oscar’s Best Picture Category

In 2009, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences expanded Oscar’s best pic contenders from five to 10. Then-president Sid Ganis hoped this would open the category to animation, foreign-language films and documentaries.

Animation and international have scored a few best-picture noms, but docus remain the final frontier. Maybe 2019 is the year when they make it. There are certainly films this year worth consideration. Exhibit A: “Tell Me Who I Am,” directed by Ed Perkins and produced by Simon Chinn.

The story centers on identical twins, Alex and Marcus Lewis. After an accident, 18-year-old Alex went into a coma. When he awoke, he had no memory and recognized no one, except his brother. So Marcus began filling him in, in essence creating a lifetime of memories. It’s a gripping, emotional story, enhanced by expert filmmaking and its virtues stand as a good example of the unique beauty of documentaries.

Back on Feb. 10, 1942, Variety reported AMPAS was inaugurating awards for doc features and shorts, “stressing the growing importance of this class of production.” The importance has grown. In the early days, many docus were in the broccoli-is-good-for-you category: Worthwhile, but a little boring, such as “Journey Into Medicine” and “I Was a Communist for the FBI.”

Popular on Variety

Docus blossomed in the 1960s and ’70s, with such titles as “In the Year of the Pig,” “Woodstock” and “Harlan County U.S.A.” Now, thanks to savvy storytelling and affordable equipment, voters are faced with a flood of great docus.

Conventional wisdom says the Academy’s doc branch (with 320 members last year) frowns at any movie that’s too successful or deals with the entertainment industry. That’s possible, but then how to explain the nominations for 2002’s “Bowling for Columbine” ($58 million at the box office) and 2005’s “March of the Penguins” ($127 million)? As for showbiz, there have been such recent Oscar winners as “Searching for Sugar Man” (2012), “20 Feet From Stardom” (2013) and “Amy” (2015).

For best pic this year, aside from “Tell Me,” consider “One Child Nation,” a personal look at a community’s reaction to China’s one-child-only policy, and also “63 Up,” from the extraordinary Michael Apted. It’s the latest in his docu series that started with “7 Up.” and in December it will mark an auspicious theatrical debut for the newish BritBox.

Ava DuVernay’s “13th” (2016) and Peter Jackson’s “They Shall Not Grow Old” (2018) are not just excellent documentaries; they’re two of the decade’s best films, period.And a reminder: Documentaries are also eligible in other categories, such as editing, sound, music score, cinematography, etc.

In that regard, 2015 is notable, with two of the five nominated songs coming from docs, “Racing Extinction” and “The Hunting Ground.” Last year, Diane Warren was nominated for “I’ll Fight” from “RBG.”

Next stop for docus: a best picture nomination.

More Film

  • Film Review: 'Never Rarely Sometimes Always'

    'Never Rarely Sometimes Always': Film Review

    The basic plot of “Never Rarely Sometimes Always” is easy enough to describe. A 17-year-old girl named Autumn (Sidney Flanigan) winds up pregnant in a small Pennsylvania town. Prevented from seeking an abortion by the state’s parental consent laws, she takes off for New York City with her cousin Skylar (Talia Ryder), where what they’d [...]

  • Kathy Valentine, Belinda Carlisle, Jane Wiedlin,

    The Go-Go's on Sundance Doc: Neither 'America's Sweethearts' Nor 'Drug-Crazed Demons'

    Some people might come to a Go-Go’s documentary wanting a purely fun, bubbly experience, based on the effervescence the group projected at its breakthrough peak in the early ’80s. Others might want a sex, drugs and rock ‘n’ roll tell-all, if they’re aware of the tensions and bad habits that led the all-female band to [...]

  • 'The Dissident' Review: Powerful Look at

    'The Dissident': Film Review

    It’s become common, if not cliché, for a critic reviewing a documentary about a turbulent real-world event to write something like, “It exerts the power of a true-life thriller!” Well, make no mistake: “The Dissident” does. Directed by Bryan Fogel, who in 2017 made the Oscar-winning “Icarus” (about the Russian doping of Olympic athletes), the [...]

  • Cathy Yan, Chris Messina, Mary Elizabeth

    Margot Robbie, 'Birds of Prey' Co-Stars Justify the Movie’s R-Rating, Violence and Cussing

    Following the success of “Joker” last year, DC Films is continuing its gritty streak with “Birds of Prey,” a slam-bang adventure about Harley Quinn. Though DC Film’s 2016 tentpole “Suicide Squad” took a critical bashing at the time, filmgoers quickly took a liking to Margot Robbie’s portrayal of Harley Quinn. “Birds of Prey” gives the [...]

  • Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) has

    Film News Roundup: 'The Irishman,' 'Marriage Story' Added to Criterion Collection

    In today’s film news roundup, four Netflix titles have been added to the Criterion Collection, Slamdance and ArcLight are partnering, Steven Grayhm is starring in and directing a paranormal drama, and The Mammoth Film Festival sets its lineup. CRITERION COLLECTION Four Netflix titles will be released on Blu-ray through the Criterion Collection — Martin Scorsese’s [...]

  • Bong Joon Ho 'Parasite' Director

    Listen: Who Will Take Home the Oscars for Best Director and Picture?

    The Oscars are just two weeks away, so it’s time to start making final predictions about who is going to win. On this week’s episode of “The Big Ticket,” Variety and iHeart’s movie podcast, I invited the magazine’s deputy awards and features editor (and my “Pick of the Week” co-host) Jenelle Riley onto the show [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content