Ventana Sur: Producers Discuss Complexity of Fiction Remakes

BUENOS AIRES — Esteemed Argentine film producers gathered to relay their experiences with fiction remakes as part of Ventana Sur’s industry conference series held at the UCA campus in Buenos Aires on Monday.

The panelists included Juan Vera and Marcos Carnevale, directors who sold the rights to their films “Mama Se Fue De Viaje,” and “Elsa y Fred,” respectively, as well as Sebastián Aloi, who produced “Re Loca,” the remake of Chilean film “Sin Filtro.” Navigating the discussion was David Castellanos, managing director of Madrid-based Cinema Republic, who encouraged the group to detail the finesse needed to rework a script for new markets.

Vera, who also serves as artistic director for Argentine production company Patagonik, relayed that “The films that are easiest to remake are those that have universal themes.”

“In the case of ‘Mama Se Fue De Viaje,’ the concept came up by chance when I was with a friend who couldn’t even boil an egg, and his wife went on vacation. It was fun; it was a typical pattern for families around the world; it worked very well as a remake,” he added.

Even when the theme is universal, the panel cautioned that certain intricate cultural details should be understood and maintained for a successful remake, going on to discuss the importance of keeping certain films closer to the societies they’re conceived within.

Popular on Variety

“In the case of ‘Nueve Reinas,’ remade as ‘Criminal,’ in the United States, it lost all of its authenticity and humility. It was a failure,” Vera said.

“The U.S. murders remakes that aren’t their own. Unless it’s ‘Scarface.’ They make great remakes of films in their own industry, but kill remakes from other countries,” Carnevale added. “As a writer and director, it’s very hard to see your film made by someone else. You expect, and you’re looking for, the same essence, and it’s not always there,” he said.

Aloi, who worked with his company Aeroplano Cine while producing “Re Loca,” stated that he only felt it necessary to rework the ending, adding, “we had access to the creators of the original script to consult with, to add insight, so we did well. If you can capture the rhythms and structures of the original, you’re good.”

“Remakes are convenient when they pose a challenge. I like to ask myself what I could do differently here,” Carnavale remarked.

“The change you make has to be controlled though, I give free rein to the new producers, but they should reach the same quality of the original on every level, or else it’s not worth it,” Vera chimed in.

The group went on to discuss live-action remakes as Carnevale offered-up his opinion, “these live remakes like ‘The Lion King,’ it’s good business because they’re well-known titles. When it’s repeated so much, it lacks imagination. This happens a lot in Hollywood.”

Castellanos doubled down on the notion that overall success lies in choosing a familiar story that’s done well at the box office and can travel, then helping that story along by selecting the right director.

“We had a project where we hired an auteur director, and he gave us such a hard time due to his ego, the film wasn’t successful in the end with his direction.” He went on to state, “We have a new project in the works and this time we hired a director who has worked on more commercial projects, and he’s working very well, not giving us any grief, and I believe this film will do great in the end because of that.”

The evening came to a close as panelists discussed the somber state of the modern world and agreed that comedy remakes, while often dismissed by critics and awards ceremonies, were the best bet.

As Vera stated, “people can step outside and see drama all around them; they need something to raise their spirits, help them have a bit of fun.”

Carnevale agreed, adding, “we need to make people laugh in this terrible world, I’m going to repeat an old saying: Make them laugh, and you’ll get a house with a swimming pool.”

More Film

  • The Nest

    'The Nest': Film Review

    All work and no play makes Rory O’Hara a dull boy — which is to say, one can scarcely overlook the connections between Sean Durkin’s subtly unsettling second feature, “The Nest,” and Stanley Kubrick’s “The Shining.” Although the obsessive dad Law plays here doesn’t go unhinged quite so spectacularly as Jack Nicholson did after moving the [...]

  • Tiziana Soudani

    Tiziana Soudani, Prominent Swiss Producer, Dies

    Swiss producer Tiziana Soudani, who through her Amka Films shepherded prizewinning films by prominent directors from nearby Italy, such as Alice Rohrwacher and Silvio Soldini, as well as by emerging talents in Switzerland and Africa, has died after a struggle with brain cancer. She was in her mid 60s, though her exact age was not immediately verifiable. [...]

  • Time's Up U.K. Teams With British

    British Stars Carey Mulligan, Himesh Patel Compile 'Alternative BAFTA' Nominees List

    British stars including Carey Mulligan, Himesh Patel and Gemma Arterton have contributed to an ‘Alternative BAFTAs’ list of nominees that honors talent overlooked by this year’s awards. The campaign is organized by Time’s Up U.K., which is rolling out a social media blitz this week in the lead-up to Sunday’s BAFTA awards honoring the women [...]

  • Rebecca Hall appears in The Night

    'The Night House': Film Review

    A knack for creepy atmospherics and individual scares goes a long way in the horror genre, and it takes “The Night House” pretty far. Though this tale of a new widow’s apparent haunting gets progressively lost in a narrative maze that’s complicated without being particularly rewarding, . Rebecca Hall plays Beth, an upstate New York [...]

  • Herself

    Amazon Studios Buys Phyllida Lloyd's 'Herself' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Amazon Studios has nabbed North American rights to Phyllida Lloyd’s “Herself,” an Irish drama about a woman who builds her dream house after escaping an abusive marriage, Variety has learned.  The streaming service is planning a theatrical release for later this year. The film debuted at the Sundance Film Festival, where it enjoyed a warm [...]

  • Blast Beat

    'Blast Beat': Film Review

    Back home in Bogota, teen brothers Carly and Mateo — played by siblings (and Disney Channel veterans) Mateo and Moisés Arias — are metal-blasting, skateboard-riding punks, and reluctant partners in crime. Carly, the sensible one, can’t prevent Mateo from dynamiting a dollhouse. But he’ll swoop in, hair flapping like a vampire’s cape, to rescue his [...]

  • Rebecca Hall appears in The Night

    Rebecca Hall's 'The Night House' Sells to Searchlight Out of Sundance

    Searchlight Pictures is closing in on the worldwide distribution rights to “The Night House,” a supernatural thriller that premiered to strong reviews at this year’s Sundance Film Festival, insiders close to the deal said. Directed by David Bruckner and starring Rebecca Hall, the deal is reportedly valued at roughly $12 million. It marks the first [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content