×

Why Vocal Performances in Animated Films Deserve Their Own Oscars Category

Given all the praise heaped on Billy Eichner’s performance this year as the wisecracking meerkat Timon in Jon Favreau’s remake of “The Lion King,” which grossed $1.6 billion worldwide, you’d think he would be a bigger contender in the Oscar conversation. His work was such a standout, he even upstaged Beyoncé’s much-hyped appearance in the animated film.

After seeing the movie at its Los Angeles premiere back in July, I tweeted, “@disneylionking has brought @billyeichner to another level. Gamechanger. Hollywood needs to give him everything.”

Eichner replied, “Did you hear that Hollywood??? EVERYTHING!!!!”

“Everything” should include an Oscar nomination for supporting actor.

But that’s unlikely.

Voice performances are eligible in the acting categories, but no one has ever been nominated for such work, presumably because what Oscar voter is going to not favor a live-action star?

That’s a shame. And this is why the Academy should consider adding an Oscar category for voice performance. Voice actors in animated movies deserve more love. The closest they get to any recognition is when their films are nominated for best picture (it’s happened only three times: with “Beauty and the Beast,” “Up” and “Toy Story 3”) or animated feature.

Popular on Variety

“I love the idea of adding an Oscar for voice performances,” Eichner tells me. “Looking back, there are so many iconic and beloved voice performances that didn’t get acknowledged, like Robin Williams in ‘Aladdin” and Ellen DeGeneres in ‘Finding Nemo.’” 

Josh Gad, whose voice work includes more than 25 credits across television and film and is probably best known as the voice of the lovable snowman Olaf in “Frozen” and its new follow-up, “Frozen 2,” seconds Eichner’s beliefs. Calling the lack of Oscar recognition for DeGeneres and Williams “kind of crazy,” he says, “Some of my favorite performances of all time are [voice roles].”

Oscars aside, ASIFA-Hollywood’s Annie Awards includes one voice award for film out of more than 30 categories. The Society of Voice Arts and Sciences’ Voice Arts Awards began six years ago and feature 80 awards across a multitude of media platforms. “We saw an opportunity that needed to be filled,” SOVAS chief operating officer Joan Baker says. “No one has ever focused on the voice acting.”

But things get a little tricky given that animation is essential to a voice performance.

“Despicable Me” creator Sergio Pablos, who makes his directorial debut with the Netflix animated holiday movie “Klaus,” says a voice performance Oscar should be considered collaborative. “I used to be an animator, and I always believed that animation was a joint effort of the voice actor and animator,” he tells me. “I don’t think you could reward one without the other. I think both contribute equally.”

Jonathan Groff, who voices Kristoff in the “Frozen” franchise, concurs. “I’m proud to be the voice of Kristoff, but what really blows my mind is the artistry of the animators,” he says. “Even in the song I get to do in the second movie, ‘Lost in the Woods,’ what they did with that and the animation is so unbelievably brilliant that I feel lucky to be singing it. … For me, if anyone was going to win a performance Oscar, it should be the animator.”

The last time the Academy implemented a new category was in 2001, when best animated feature was added to the roster. And the organization received scorching criticism last year when it announced that it would start handing out an Oscar for outstanding popular film in 2020, a proposal that quickly went down in flames.

It’s highly unlikely a voice performance category will be created anytime soon.

In other words, I gotta let it go — for now. 

More Film

  • Kevin Hart'Jumanji: The Next Level' film

    Kevin Hart to Star in Action-Comedy from 'Broad City' Alums (EXCLUSIVE)

    Universal Pictures is developing an untitled action-comedy based on an original idea from “Broad City’s” Lucia Aniello and Paul W. Downs with Kevin Hart attached to star. Aniello and Downs will write the script as well as executive produce. Malcolm D. Lee is on board to direct the film with Will Packer and James Lopez [...]

  • Jeremy Saulnier John Boyega

    Netflix Sets Ensemble for Jeremy Saulnier's 'Rebel Ridge' Starring John Boyega (EXCLUSIVE)

    Don Johnson, James Badge Dale, Zsane Jhe, James Cromwell and “The Crown” breakout Erin Doherty are set to join John Boyega in Netflix’s “Rebel Ridge,” a thriller from “Green Room” writer-director Jeremy Saulnier, Variety has learned. Like the 2013 crime drama “Green Room,” Saulnier’s upcoming movie is said to be a high-velocity thriller that explores [...]

  • The Indoraptor prepares to strike in

    'Jurassic World 3' Director Announces New Title

    Director Colin Trevorrow announced via Twitter on Tuesday that “Jurassic World 3” has started principal production, and he also slyly revealed that the sixth film in the “Jurassic” franchise has a new title: “Jurassic World: Dominion.” The new title — which appears on the slate for the film in Trevorrow’s tweet — evokes the biblical [...]

  • Chuat Reymond

    Stéphanie Chuat and Véronique Reymond on Berlin’s ‘My Little Sister’

    Stéphanie Chuat and Véronique Reymond’s “My Little Sister” (“Schwesterlein”) premiered at the Berlin Film Festival on Tuesday to strong critical and audience receptions, with particular praise heaped on lead actors Nina Hoss and Lars Eidinger. In his Variety review, Guy Lodge praised: “This is bright, unaffected naturalism with a fluidly roving camera, but also a [...]

  • Miriam Haley and Tarale Wulff

    Women Who Testified in Harvey Weinstein Trial Slam His Lawyers for 'Victim Blaming' 

    Six women testified during the Harvey Weinstein rape trial, and now that the former movie mogul was found guilty of two felony charges, those women are speaking out with newfound freedom. Miriam Haley, who was assaulted by Weinstein in 2006, resulting in him being convicted of a criminal sex act (which carries a maximum sentence [...]

  • E. L. James

    Movie Rights to 'Fifty Shades of Grey' Author's 'The Mister' Land at Universal (EXCLUSIVE)

    Following the massive success of the “Fifty Shades of Grey” trilogy, Universal and author E. L. James are reteaming on the scribe’s next novel as the studio has optioned the rights to “The Mister,” James’ 2019 best-selling romance. Rights for the book, which recently hit the market, sparked a heated bidding war. James, who produced [...]

  • Bad Tales

    'Bad Tales': Film Review

    At a surprise party for his daughter, a randy Italian homeowner studies a neighbor’s wife through the sliding glass door and describes all the ways he’d like to violate her. In the bathroom, his 14-year-old son sits with his best friend, studying the hardcore porn sites listed in the browsing history of Dad’s cellphone. A [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content