Box Office: Why ‘Hustlers’ Soared While ‘The Goldfinch’ Flopped

Though STX’s “Hustlers” and Warner Bros.’ “The Goldfinch” couldn’t be more different in terms of genre or style, the two new releases prove the divergent paths that mid-budget movies can take at the box office.

Both films arrived last weekend in an environment that has been increasingly hostile to anything that’s not of the superhero ilk or the umpteenth iteration of a longstanding franchise. “Hustlers” beat expectations with a solid $33.2 million debut, while “The Goldfinch” bombed with just $2.68 million. Those results are a sobering lesson as studios continue to scout for material that appeals to moviegoers interested in more than just blockbuster fare. “Hustlers” cost a moderate $20 million to produce, meaning the movie only needed to do modest business to turn a profit. “The Goldfinch” carried double that budget with a price tag above $40 million. Amazon co-financed the movie, which will help mitigate damages, but it still stands to lose money for the studio. The outcome shouldn’t dissuade Hollywood companies from dabbling in original ideas, but rather encourage them to reevaluate how much they are investing into such properties.

“Hustlers” provides a master class in crafting reasonably priced counter-programming. Directed by Lorene Scafaria, “Hustlers” is based on Jessica Pressler’s 2015 New York magazine article about professional New York strippers who double-cross their wealthy Wall Street clientele after the 2008 recession. That tagline could have easily lumped “Hustlers” in with Demi Moore’s “Striptease,” “Showgirls” or “Burlesque” in the company of stripper dramas that were seen as exploitative. Instead, “Hustlers,” which arrived on the big screen with stellar reviews (and even awards buzz for star Jennifer Lopez), was an exciting reversal of expectations, providing a feminist spin to a story that had been rooted in the male gaze. Variety’s Peter Debruge lauded the movie, saying “‘Hustlers’ humanizes the women at its center, giving them boyfriends, backstories and, most importantly, agency.” That allowed “Hustlers” to tap into the zeitgeist in a way that made people feel like they had to venture out to theaters so they could participate in a wider conversation taking place online and in their own social circles.

“‘Hustlers’ had all the things that make something a must-see film, “says Paul Dergarabedian, a senior media analyst with Comscore. “Reviews played a huge part. People who might have dismissed this film for using an exploitative hook then read reviews and saw it was a great movie.”

“Hustlers” was also an instance in which star power payed off. The female-driven ensemble — led  Lopez, Constance Wu, Lili Reinhart and Keke Palmer — cast its leading ladies in roles they were seemingly born to play. Lopez embodies Ramona, the fearless ringleader who, by all accounts, invented the art of pole dancing. Reinhart, best-known to audiences by her signature preppy ponytail on the CW hit “Riverdale,” showed she can be a comedic force while Wu aptly positioned herself as the film’s moral center. And cameos from Cardi B and Lizzo couldn’t have been more fitting. “The Goldfinch” also boasted a high-profile marquee with Ansel Elgort, Nicole Kidman and Sarah Paulson, but none were able to capture the same kind of sentiment.

And what might have helped “Hustlers” break through could have also been a nail in the coffin for “The Goldfinch.” Despite strong source material, “The Goldfinch” wasn’t able to create a compelling on-screen narrative. Reviews don’t necessarily correlate with box office performance (just ask critical favorites like “Booksmart” and “Late Night”), but in the case of “The Goldfinch,” tepid feedback and a 25% on Rotten Tomatoes didn’t incentivize anyone to get off their couch and go to the multiplex.

“It’s not enough to make a decent film anymore,” says Jeff Bock, a senior media analyst with Exhibitor Relations. “It has to be one of the best films anyone has seen to really make a dent in the box office if you’re an adult drama.”

At one time, fiction such as “The Girl on the Train” and “The Great Gatsby” or even “Brooklyn” were robust mines for silver-screen material. But there’s a reason why television has become a haven for literary favorites like Margaret Atwood’s “The Handmaid’s Tale,” Liane Moriarty’s “Big Little Lies,” “Gillian Flynn’s “Sharp Objects” and Caroline Kepnes’ “You.” Unlike movies, which are driven by bold concepts, television allows the opportunity to delve deep into character development in a way that’s not possible in a story that unfolds over the course of two hours. Adding to its challenges, “The Goldfinch” had a sprawling narrative unfolding across several time periods. The Pulitzer Prize-winning novel owed much of its success to Donna Tartt distinctive voice, which can be a notoriously difficult quality to capture on film.

“You get a salt and pepper on the movie screen, you get the entire cabinet of spices on TV or streaming,” Bock said. “Something like ‘The Goldfinch’ seems perfect for three seasons of TV. That’s right now what adult dramas that are trying to be adapted into theater-length features are finding out.”

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Film Republic Adds Further Sales for

    Film Republic Inks Further Deals for 'God of the Piano' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Sales agent Film Republic has closed further territory sales on “God of the Piano.” Film Movement previously picked up North American rights to the film, as reported exclusively by Variety. Mont Blanc Cinema has taken the rights for Argentina, Chile, Uruguay and Paraguay. Limelight Distribution is looking after the Australian and New Zealand releases, Hualu [...]

  • ‘Bears Famous Invasion’s Lorenzo Mattotti Brings

    Lorenzo Mattotti on MIA Title ‘Bears Famous Invasion of Sicily’

    Illustrator Lorenzo Mattotti is no stranger to film festivals. The artist – a long-time New Yorker cover artist and onetime Lou Reed and Michelangelo Antonioni collaborator – has designed posters for past editions of Venice and Cannes, and has contributed to films that played in Toronto and Rome. This year, however, he experienced the festival [...]

  • Dreamworks Abominable

    'Abominable' Release in Malaysia Abandoned

    Plans to release the increasingly controversial Chinese-U.S. co-produced animation film “Abominable” in Malaysia have been dropped after the distributor said that it would not be cut to cater to political sensitivities. The film includes a scene which depicts a map showing the South China Sea and the so called “nine-dash line” that China uses to [...]

  • Hui He

    RAI Com Takes World Sales on Italy/China Doc About Star Soprano Hui He (EXCLUSIVE)

    Italy’s RAI Com has taken world sales on high-profile documentary “Hui He, the Soprano From the Silk Road,” which is about the personal and artistic journey of one of the world’s leading sopranos and also marks a milestone Italian-Chinese co-production. Hui He was born and trained as a singer in the Chinese city of Xi’an, [...]

  • Bruce Springsteen arrives for the New

    Bruce Springsteen Returns to NJ Hometown for Surprise 'Western Stars' Introduction

    Bruce Springsteen returned to his hometown of Freehold, New Jersey to offer a surprise introduction to the first public multiplex viewing of his concert/documentary film, “Western Stars.” Dressed simply in a brown jacket, Springsteen took a moment to say a few words at the AMC Freehold 14 movie theater on Saturday night. “We knew we [...]

  • Backstage in Puglia del film SPACCAPIETRE:

    'Gomorrah' Star Salvatore Esposito Set For De Serio Twins' 'The Stonebreaker'

    Salvatore Esposito, the Italian star who plays young mob boss Genny Savastano in Italy’s hit TV series “Gomorrah,” will soon be hitting the big screen toplining upcoming drama “The Stonebreaker” by twin directorial duo Gianluca and Massimiliano De Serio, who are known internationally for “Seven Acts of Mercy.” The De Serio twins are now in post on “Stonebreaker” [...]

  • Angelina Jolie is Maleficent in Disney’s

    Box Office: 'Maleficent: Mistress of Evil' Tops 'Joker,' 'Zombieland'

    “Maleficent: Mistress of Evil” is on track to give Disney another first place finish after scoring $12.5 million in Friday’s domestic ticket sales. If estimates hold, the Angelina Jolie-led film should finish the weekend with about $38 million — well below earlier forecasts but enough to top holdover “Joker” and fellow newcomer “Zombieland: Double Tap.” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content