Macao Industry Debate: Streaming Not Done Reshaping Indie Film Business

New viewing habits brought on by the rise of streaming have hastened the demise of the mid-budget American indie, changed the very definition of arthouse cinema, and shaken the indie distribution business. But theatrical is still here to stay, attendees of the Macao International Film Festival’s closed-door industry panels concluded Saturday.

Panelists gathered to discuss three topics: the changing face of the industry in the post #MeToo era; the fate of indies in the streaming era; and the future of the theatrical market. Variety‘s Patrick Frater moderated a public panel between session moderators, that followed three earlier sessions held in camera.  

Most attendees felt that Netflix offerings like “The Irishman” have proven less of a threat than once imagined as theatrical films, since they don’t have a theatrical windows in many overseas markets like India or France.

Such prestige films may have turned out to be more about PR, prestige awards for the platform, and affirmation for the talent than a real threat to the larger theatrical ecosystem. That’s because screen counts in emerging markets like Asia are continuing to grow considerably, summed up moderator Andy Whittaker, founder of Dogwoof.

Popular on Variety

But mid-budget U.S. indie films have largely disappeared. Instead, box office is propped up big Hollywood event movies and, overseas, local content such as Bollywood films, French comedies and Chinese blockbusters in their respective home markets.

Interestingly, the past two years have also seen the rise of unlikely breakouts such as “Capernaum” and “Free Solo,” which have become genuine hits in multiple territories, making upwards of $10 million — “which was previously unheard of,” said Whittaker.

Consequently, the definition of arthouse is changing. “Arthouse used to mean a Korean film that was award-winning. Now, an arthouse film is not a comedy, not ‘Star Wars,’ and everything else. Even mid-budget, $10 million movies are all arthouse,” Whittaker said.

Asian consumers have not prioritized the subscription mentality as much as consumers in the U.S. or the U.K., where the market is “at a real inflection point where [their] habits are having a dramatic impact on the specialized space,” according to Dori Begley, executive VP of Magnolia Pictures.

“Producers are happier and distributors are miserable,” she said, summing up in broad strokes. “There’s more production work for hire and less of an opportunity to nurture talent as there once was.”

Other than for a few exceptions such as “Parasite” and “The Farewell,” audiences these days are less interested in paying transactional fees either at the box office or on SVoD for challenging content that’s neither feel-good nor purely about the spectacle, she said. People are watching, but they prefer to engage with such fare at home for what is perceived as “for free” — via one of their existing subscription services.

Such changes in viewing habits has meant that Magnolia and others have had to drastically change their acquisition strategy. “A lot of us are leaning more towards traditional theatrical and away from premium TVoD, and collapsed windows. We’re at this point where the films that worked for us even two years ago are not working.”

Indie distributors have long played an important role for studios and big platforms in building the profile of smaller films and bringing up new talent that can then go on to do bigger things. But their role is being rethought.

In the content ecosystem, such players have been like the bees of the content ecosystem, said Begley, who warned: “If the specialized stakeholders collapse, the impact is going to be far greater than most people realize.”

More Film

  • Bong Joon Ho 'Parasite' Director

    Listen: Who Will Take Home the Oscars for Best Director and Picture?

    The Oscars are just two weeks away, so it’s time to start making final predictions about who is going to win. On this week’s episode of “The Big Ticket,” Variety and iHeart’s movie podcast, I invited the magazine’s deputy awards and features editor (and my “Pick of the Week” co-host) Jenelle Riley onto the show [...]

  • Bloody Nose, Empty Pockets

    'Bloody Nose, Empty Pockets': Film Review

    “Smile for the camera, motherf—ers,” warns the graffiti outside the Roaring Twenties, a Las Vegas dive bar where spirits are high because the end is nigh. The boozers who’ve braved this dim red cave, in Bill and Turner Ross’ bitterly funny docufiction film “Bloody Nose, Empty Pockets,” have signed on to play themselves in an [...]

  • Mucho Mucho Amor

    'Mucho Mucho Amor': Film Review

    What a fraud, you might have thought glimpsing astrologist Walter Mercado on TV in the ’90s. But you wouldn’t forget his face. The bejeweled and blonded psychic hotline pitchman looked like a sorcerer from outer space. Cristina Costantini and Kareem Tabsch’s giddily glittery documentary “Mucho Mucho Amor” traces the half-century that Mercado was a global [...]

  • Oscar OScars Placeholder

    Number of Black Oscar Nominees Hits 3-Year Low in 2020

    The Oscars’ failure to nominate any female directors has ignited a fierce backlash, as has the lack of diversity among top acting nominees. A deeper dive into the categories reveals that the number of black nominees hit a three-year low. Only five black people were nominated for Oscars in 2020. That’s down from 15 in [...]

  • Herself

    'Herself': Film Review

    In 2008, opera director Phyllida Lloyd’s pop-cornball big-screen debut, “Mamma Mia!,” more than earned its exclamation point, grossing more than $600 million worldwide. Three years later, her more serious-minded follow-up, “The Iron Lady,” earned Meryl Streep an Oscar. Most people would agree that was a not-too-shabby start for a helmer of any gender. But instead [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content