You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

YouTube Says It’s Reviewing Harassment Policies, After It Condoned Sustained Attacks on Gay Latino Journalist

YouTube, under fire for initially taking no action against a right-wing vlogger who has chronically bullied a gay Hispanic video journalist, said it will take “a hard look at our harassment policies with an aim to update them.”

Here’s the backstory: Carlos Maza, a Vox video producer, said in Twitter posts May 30 that since he began working at Vox in early 2017, videos by conservative YouTuber Steven Crowder responding to Maza’s video series “Strikethrough” have consistently included “repeated, overt attacks on my sexual orientation and ethnicity.”

In his videos, Crowder has called Maza a “lispy queer,” the “token Vox gay atheist sprit” and a “gay Mexican.” He sells a line of merchandise including T-shirts and onesies with a picture of Che Guevara and the slogan “Socialism Is for F*gs.”

Responding to Maza on June 4, YouTube (via its TeamYouTube account) said it would not remove Crowder’s videos or otherwise penalize him. “Opinions can be deeply offensive, but if they don’t violate our policies, they’ll remain on our site,” the video giant said Tuesday. Maza was in disbelief, tweeting: “I don’t know what to say. YouTube has decided not to punish Crowder, after he spent two years harassing me for being gay and Latino… That’s an absolutely bat-shit policy that gives bigots free license.”

Then, on Wednesday, YouTube announced that it had decided to punish Crowder after all: His channel has been demonetized — suspended from the YouTube Partner Program — and in order to be considered for reinstatement, Crowder must remove any videos that violate YouTube policies and links to “offensive merchandise.” In response, Crowder tweeted, “YouTube and Vox have launched an all out WAR on ALL independent creators. Thousands of channels under review!” and asked for stories from other demonetized creators.

In a blog post late Wednesday, YouTube head of communications Chris Dale, tried to clear the air about the Maza-Crowder imbroglio.

“In the case of Crowder’s channel, a thorough review over the weekend found that individually, the flagged videos did not violate our Community Guidelines,” Dale wrote. “However, in the subsequent days, we saw the widespread harm to the YouTube community resulting from the ongoing pattern of egregious behavior, took a deeper look, and made the decision to suspend monetization.”

In response to Dale’s post, Maza tweeted, “Imagine if you just enforced the plain language of your original policies instead of endlessly creating loopholes to exempt high-profile abusers.” Maza also has accused YouTube of hypocrisy, given its promotion of a slate of LGBTQ originals timed for 2019 Pride Month.

For YouTube, it’s yet another controversy in a long series of problems it has faced in trying to balance its stated goal of providing an open platform with the need to curb malicious content, misinformation and other abuse of the world’s biggest video service.

Also Wednesday — after years of criticism — YouTube said it will specifically ban supremacist videos including neo-Nazi content; previously, it claimed it has tried to clamp down on such videos by reducing their inclusion in its recommendations engine and disabling certain features. That came two days after YouTube announced it is banning young kids from live-streaming with adult supervision and limiting recommendations of videos that depict “minors in risky situations.”

The Maza-Crowder uproar has prompted YouTube to review its harassment policies. YouTube over the next few months will work with “experts, creators, journalists and those who have, themselves, been victims of harassment” to update the policies, Dale wrote. “We are determined to evolve our policies, and continue to hold our creators and ourselves to a higher standard.”

YouTube’s existing harassment and cyberbullying policy bans content that, among other things, “is deliberately posted in order to humiliate someone” or “makes hurtful and negative personal comments/videos about another person.”

In enforcing this policy, according to Dale, context matters. “To be clear, using racial, homophobic, or sexist epithets on their own would not necessarily violate” either its hate-speech or harassment policies, noting that “lewd or offensive language is often used in songs and comedic routines.”

YouTube, Dale claimed, enforces its harassment policies “rigorously and regardless of the creator in question.” In the first quarter of 2019, the service deleted tens of thousands of videos and accounts for violation of policies on cyberbullying and harassment — as well as hundreds of millions of comments.

That said, he added, “If we were to take all potentially offensive content down, we’d be losing valuable speech — speech that allows people everywhere to raise their voices, tell their stories, question those in power, and participate in the critical cultural and political conversations of our day.”

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • Instagram

    Instagram Testing Hidden Like Counts Globally

    Like counts will be disappearing from Instagram all over the world starting this week: The Facebook-owned photo sharing service is extending its test of hiding like counts to all of its territories, Techcrunch was first to report Thursday morning. Instagram began hiding like counts for a subset of its users in Canada this spring, and [...]

  • Ted Sarandos - Netflix

    Ted Sarandos Says Disney Plus Launch Changes 'Nothing' for Netflix

    Netflix chief content officer Ted Sarandos claims he’s not getting distracted by huge competitors — like Disney — rumbling into the company’s streaming turf. The exec was asked what has changed for Netflix with the Nov. 12 launch of Disney Plus, which the Mouse House boasted as having signed up over 10 million users so [...]

  • Game Awards OrchestraThe Game Awards, Show,

    Game Awards 2019 to Play on 53 Cinemark Screens Alongside 'Jumanji: The Next Level'

    This year’s Game Awards, recognizing the top video games, creators and esports of 2019, is coming to the silver screen. In a three-way partnership, the Game Awards, Cinemark Theatres and Sony Pictures are teaming on a superticket program pairing the Dec. 12 live simulcast of the 2019 Game Awards in 53 Cinemark locations with a [...]

  • Lilly Burns Tony Hernandez

    Jax Media Soars by Amplifying Unique Voices of Auteur TV

    Jax Media has emerged during the past few years as one of television’s busiest and buzziest production companies. The New York-based company headed by four partners — Tony Hernandez, Lilly Burns, John Skidmore and Brooke Posch — has an enviable track record of scouting new voices and executing stylish shows on a less-than-stratospheric budgets. The [...]

  • Variety Digital New Leaders

    Execs From Endeavor Audio, Group Nine Among Those Leading the Way in Digital

    Every year, Variety seeks to identify the next generation of leaders in the entertainment business, looking for representatives in the creative community, film, TV, music and digital. This year’s group has a heavy New York focus: We selected executives from forward thinking companies such as Spotify, Group Nine and Endeavor Audio, as well as writers [...]

  • John Carmack John Carmack, Chief Technical

    Oculus CTO John Carmack to Step Down

    One of the driving forces behind Facebook’s virtual reality efforts is leaving his post: Oculus CTO John Carmack announced Wednesday afternoon that he was transitioning to a “consulting CTO” role this week, and devote most of his time to new challenges outside of the company. “I will still have a voice in the development work, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content