×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Instagram Will Begin Hiding Likes in the U.S.: Smart Move or Misguided Fail?

Instagram is about to launch a test of removing like counts from posts in the U.S. — and, predictably, the idea has been met with a range of reactions ranging from praise and support to concern and mockery.

The hope is that the change can reduce anxiety among Instagram users, to make social media less of a competition, especially among younger people, Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri explained in announcing the U.S. test at the Wired25 event Friday.

“I think you also have to rethink some of the fundamentals about how Instagram works, and so that’s what we’re trying to do with private like counts,” he said. “The idea is to try and depressurize Instagram, make it less of a competition, give people more space to focus on connecting with people that they love, things that inspire them.”

Mosseri added, “We will make decisions that hurt the business [in the short term] if they’re good for people’s well-being and health — because it has to be good for the business over the long-term.”

Feedback starting pouring in immediately. Some opined that removing like counts (while still making them viewable to Instagram users for their own posts) will effectively destroy a pivotal piece of the platform’s social currency.

Popular on Variety

“If Instagram gets rid of likes half of Los Angeles will be out of business,” quipped Tommy Alter, supervising producer at “Desus & Mero” on Showtime.

Instagram will still publish follower counts — arguably the platform’s biggest status symbol. But masking the number of likes on Instagram posts will hurt up-and-coming creators by removing a key way they get discovered, some suggested. “Instagram removing likes may be terrible for emerging artists online. My work got seen because larger accounts saw the popularity of my pieces and shared them to their followers. Without likes, recognition in the art world returns to ‘who you know’ or subjective elitist tastes,” artist Peter DeLuce tweeted.

On the other hand, the change could actually help influencers and other content creators by providing a more realistic reflection of their engagement, according to Karen Civil, a social media marketing strategist. “Metrics will still be available to the user so this will be great for social media influencers with real engagement when showing their media kit,” she tweeted. “This move is to make Instagram a safer place and to stop users from allowing ‘likes’ to dictate their content.”

Other commenters are also bullish on the change. “Too many folks ‘living for the ‘Gram’… If you genuinely love what you do, you’ll do it regardless of whether Instagram likes are public or not,” music journalist Sowmya Krishnamurthy wrote on Twitter.

And Wired editor-in-chief Nick Thompson weighed in, tweeting, “Personally, I think this is great. Makes Instagram less like a stressful video game, particularly for kids.”

Meanwhile, some support the feature but think it should be optional. “Instagram should give you the choice to hide your likes if you would like to,” but “the app shouldn’t force you to do it,” wrote Skai Jackson, an actress, activist and author.

Note that Instagram’s U.S. test to hide likes isn’t a brand-new concept. It began testing private likes earlier this year in Canada and has broadened it to Ireland, Italy, Japan, Brazil, Australia and New Zealand. The photo- and video-sharing platform also can tap into Facebook’s work in this area, Mosseri pointed out: In September, Facebook announced plans to test hidden like counts within its core Facebook app, starting with users in Australia.

When internet platforms introduce design changes of any scope, a certain portion of the user base inevitably rebels. That’s why Instagram is trying to soften the blow by calling the move to disable like counts a “test,” to get people accustomed to the change.

However, such modifications are frequently accepted — whether begrudgingly, enthusiastically or indifferently — as time passes. In 2016, for example, Instagram switched users’ feeds from chronological to an algorithmically sorted presentation — prompting a Change.org petition demanding that Instagram keep posts in chronological order, ultimately signed by 343,000 people. Later that same year, Instagram changed its logo, which led to “The Great Instagram Logo Freakout of 2016,” per the New York Times.

Today, how many of Instagram’s 1 billion-plus monthly active users even remember those controversies?

Chances are, any unhappiness over IG’s like-hiding will flutter into the same dustbin of history. But whether the move sticks boils down to the bottom line. If hiding public likes results in a positive reaction, as Mosseri & Co. theorize — and ultimately leads to higher engagement on the platform — then it will become a standard part of the Instagram experience.

More Digital

  • A LITLLE LATE WITH LILLY SINGH

    Lilly Singh Mocks Disney Plus 'Outdated Cultural Depictions' Warnings for Racist Movies

    Lilly Singh lampooned Disney Plus’ disclaimer that certain older movies include “outdated cultural depictions” on her NBC show. The YouTube and late-night TV comedian took issue with Disney’s euphemistic phrasing — pointing out that the warning is really about the “racist” tropes in decades-old movies that were made for kids. Disney Plus includes “a bunch [...]

  • Sacha Baron Cohen

    Sacha Baron Cohen Rips Into Facebook, YouTube and Twitter for Spreading Lies and Hate

    Calling social media “the greatest propaganda machine in history,” and the CEOs of Facebook, Twitter and YouTube “high-tech robber barons,” comedian Sacha Baron Cohen used a speech given to the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) this week to call for much more stringent regulation of internet companies. “By now, it’s pretty clear they cannot be trusted to [...]

  • Liza Koshy

    Liza Koshy to Host Dance-Competition Series — With a Moving Dance Floor — for Quibi

    YouTube star and comedian Liza Koshy will preside over a dance-competition reality series coming to Quibi — a kind of mashup of “So You Think You Can Dance” and “Wipeout.” In “Floored,” two opposing teams of skilled dancers will try their best to perform a routine while the dance floor itself actually lifts, tilts, drops, [...]

  • Instagram tests hiding likes

    Instagram Hiding Likes: U.S. Users Have Mixed Emotions About the Move, Survey Finds

    Instagram this month began a test to hide “likes” for U.S. users, and last week the social platform announced that it will be rolling out the change everywhere in the world. The move ticked off some big influencers, including Nicki Minaj, who said on Twitter that she’s going to stop posting to Instagram because of [...]

  • Neal Kirsch

    Former OWN COO Neal Kirsch Joins Gaming TV Network VENN (EXCLUSIVE)

    The Video Game Entertainment and News Network (VENN) is staffing up ahead of its 2020 launch: VENN has hired former Oprah Winfrey Network (OWN) and Discovery Networks executive Neal Kirsch as its new COO & CFO, the company is scheduled to announce Thursday. Kirsch served until late 2016 as the COO & CFO of Oprah’s [...]

  • Spotify Awards

    Spotify Is Launching Its Own Music Awards, Based on Streaming Data

    Spotify has set plans for its first-ever music awards — with the winners based entirely on user-generated data. “Your plays, patterns, and habits will help determine the award categories, finalists, and winners for the Spotify Awards by providing a true reflection of what fans are listening to,” the company said in announcing the program Friday. [...]

  • YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki

    YouTube CEO to Burned-Out Creators: Data Shows It's OK to Take a Break From Posting

    Stressed-out YouTube creators anxious that their channels will take a traffic hit if they take a mental-health break shouldn’t worry, according to YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki: She says a data analysis showed that, on average, YouTubers get even more views when they return after a hiatus. In a Nov. 21 open letter to creators, Wojcicki [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content