Supreme Court to Review Byron Allen’s Discrimination Suit Against Comcast

The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear a case in which Byron Allen’s Entertainment Studios alleges that Comcast refused to carry its channels due to racial discrimination.

Comcast appealed a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling from November, which held that Allen’s accusations were plausible, and merited a hearing in district court. Allen’s suit had been dismissed three times at the district court level, but the Ninth Circuit reversed the lower court and revived the complaint.

In granting a petition for certiorari on Monday, the Supreme Court agreed to hear Comcast’s argument that the Ninth Circuit applied the wrong standard. The Ninth Circuit ruled that racial discrimination needed only to be a factor in Comcast’s decision, rather than the determining factor, in order for his claim to proceed.

In their petition, Comcast’s attorneys called Allen’s suit “facially absurd.” Comcast argued that Supreme Court precedent, and the rulings of other appellate districts, held that racial discrimination had to the “but-for” factor in causing a harm in order to be barred by federal law.

Allen filed the $20 billion claim in 2015, alleging that Comcast had worked with the NAACP and Al Sharpton’s National Action Network to “whitewash” the company’s discriminatory practices. Allen’s suit alleged that Comcast had only granted carriage to a single 100% black-owned company. Comcast did carry networks partially owned by Earvin “Magic” Johnson and Sean “Diddy” Combs.

Allen filed similar suits against AT&T, which ended in a settlement, and Charter Communications. The district court denied Charter’s motion to dismiss the case, and the Ninth Circuit in November upheld the denial, rejecting Charter’s argument that it had a First Amendment right not to carry Allen’s channels. Charter also appealed to the Supreme Court. Charter sought a hearing on whether its business decisions were protected by the First Amendment, in addition to the raising the arguments in Comcast’s brief about the appropriate standard.

The Supreme Court did not take on the broader First Amendment issue, agreeing only to hear the narrower question presented in Comcast’s appeal.

Comcast put out a statement on the court’s decision:

“Comcast has an outstanding record of supporting and fostering diverse programming, including programming from African-American owned channels, two more of which we launched earlier this year. There has been no finding of discriminatory conduct by Comcast against this plaintiff because there has been none. We carry more than 100 networks geared toward diverse audiences. In light of this record, much of which plaintiffs’ complaint itself acknowledged, it is not surprising that the trial court dismissed the plaintiffs’ claims of race discrimination three times, finding them utterly without merit. We believe the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision was incorrectly decided. At this stage, the case is about a technical point of law that was decided in a novel way by the Ninth Circuit. We hope the Supreme Court will reverse the Ninth Circuit’s unusual interpretation of the law and bring this case to an end.”

Allen issued his own statement:

“We have already prevailed in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and we are highly confident we will also prevail in the U.S. Supreme Court. Today’s announcement from the U.S. Supreme Court is historic, and we are on the right side of history. Unfortunately, Comcast continues to mislead the American people and its subscribers. This case is NOT about African American-themed programming, but IS about African American OWNERSHIP of networks. Unfortunately, the networks Comcast refers to as ‘African American-owned’ are not WHOLLY-owned by African Americans, and did not get ANY carriage until I stood up and spoke out about this discrimination and economic exclusion. Comcast — one of the biggest lobbyists in Washington, DC — will continue to lose this case, and the American people who stand against racial discrimination will win.”

More Biz

  • Coronavirus Hollywood Jobs

    An Exhaustive Guide to Coronavirus-Relief Resources for the Music Community, Compiled by A2IM

    As the coronavirus pandemic has brought much of the music industry — and most industries — to a standstill, MusiCares has emerged as the leading relief resource for the untold thousands of music professionals impacted by the crisis. However, obviously it can’t handle everyone, and a large number of resources are available for music professionals [...]

  • Wimbledon Canceled Due to Coronavirus

    Wimbledon Tennis Tournament Canceled Due to Coronavirus

    Wimbledon tennis tournament has been canceled because of the coronavirus pandemic – the first time this has happened since World War II. The tournament was due to be played between June 29 and July 12. The 134th championships will instead be staged from June 28 to July 11, 2021. The decision follows the postponement of [...]

  • THE MASKED SINGER: The Bear in

    Comcast and Fox Corp. Set Broad New Carriage Agreement

    Comcast and Fox Corp. have come to terms on a broad carriage agreement covering all of Fox’s cable channels, including Fox News, and its O&O local TV stations. The long-term deal is significant for Fox Corp. given the importance of Comcast’s distribution footprint to core earnings. The pact covers authenticated streaming rights to Fox properties [...]

  • Bob Backish ViacomCBS

    ViacomCBS' Path Ahead Grows Steeper Amid the Coronavirus Pandemic

    ViacomCBS has come to a crossroads, again. The company that has endured more drama in the C-suite in recent years than any of its larger rivals was already under pressure this year to prove it could muster a comeback in a big way. Now, with the black swan named coronavirus roiling the waters, leaders of [...]

  • Brian Roberts comcast

    Top Comcast, NBCUniversal and Sky Executives to Donate Salary Amid Coronavirus Crisis

    Comcast chief Brian Roberts, NBCUniversal CEO Jeff Shell and other division leaders at Comcast will donate their salaries to coronavirus-related relief efforts as the world grapples with the devastating pandemic. In a memo sent to Comcast’s 190,000 employees worldwide on Wednesday. Roberts said the salary donations would also be made by Comcast CFO Mike Cavanagh, [...]

  • T-Mobile

    T-Mobile Completes Sprint Takeover, Repeats Vow to Not Raise Prices for 3 Years

    T-Mobile said it officially closed its merger with rival Sprint — creating a wireless carrier with over 100 million customers nationwide — and reiterated its pledge to not increase customers’ fees for the next three years. The deal, worth more than $31 billion based on T-Mobile’s closing stock price Tuesday, ends the nearly two-year effort [...]

  • Talent Agencies in Turmoil Placeholder

    Can Talent Agencies Adapt in the Wake of the Coronavirus Pandemic?

    Two words have been bouncing around the email inboxes and Slack channels that now comprise the virtual workplaces of Hollywood’s talent agencies, and they aren’t “social” and “distancing.” The buzz terms that have sprung from more than a dozen conversations Variety has held with top dealmakers and the companies they work with are “fragmentation” and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content