UPDATED: Former executive editor of the New York Times Jill Abramson has admitted to errors in sourcing in her new book, “Merchants of Truth,” after she was accused of plagiarism.
“The notes don’t match up with the right pages in a few cases, and this was unintentional and will be promptly corrected,” Abramson wrote in a statement to the Associated Press. “The language is too close in some cases and should have been cited as quotations in the text. This, too, will be fixed.”
Previously, she took to Twitter to acknowledge the accusations of plagiarism that emerged on Wednesday.
“I take seriously the issues raised,” she continued in a follow-up tweet, “and will review the passages in question.”
Abramson also addressed the alleged inaccuracies regarding Vice News that some have posed: “The attacks on my book from some @vicenews reflect their unhappiness with what I consider a balanced portrayal.”
I take seriously the issues raised and will review the passages in question
— Jill Abramson (@JillAbramson) February 7, 2019
I endeavored to accurately and properly give attribution to the hundreds of sources that were part of my research
— Jill Abramson (@JillAbramson) February 7, 2019
The attacks on my book from some @vicenews reflect their unhappiness with what I consider a balanced portrayal.
— Jill Abramson (@JillAbramson) February 7, 2019
The tweets came shortly after Abramson defended herself in an interview with Fox News’ Martha MacCallum just an hour after the accusations came to light.
“All I can tell you is I certainly didn’t plagiarize in my book,” Abramson said, though she admitted she had not read through the details of the allegations. She added that there are almost 70 pages of footnotes explaining where she got her information. MacCallum asked Abramson if it was a “footnote issue,” but Abramson replied, “No. I don’t think it’s an issue at all.”
In a Twitter thread Wednesday, Vice News correspondent Michael C. Moynihan posted images comparing passages from Abramson’s book to numerous other publications and even a master’s thesis. “Masters of Truth: The Business of News and the Fight for Facts” charts the changes that have occurred in journalistic standards and media technology in the 21st century through the lenses of four news organizations — Vice News, the New York Times, the Washington Post, and BuzzFeed. It hit shelves in February.
Moynihan stated that his six examples came only from “Merchants of Truth’s” chapters on Vice. Many of the passages show Abramson’s book lifting identical sentences from sources, while others show slightly rearranged phrasing or substituted words.
The following examples from the final book—not the galley—are only from the Vice chapters (I didn’t check the others). So let’s begin…Here is Abramson on Gavin McInnes (whom she interviewed) and the Ryerson Review of Journalism https://t.co/hx0XcyZ89k pic.twitter.com/qroN59gyVk
— Michael C Moynihan (@mcmoynihan) February 6, 2019
This passage, on former Vice News editor Jason Mojica, is lifted from a 2010 Time Out magazine piece, with small modifications: https://t.co/csNoONZQhX pic.twitter.com/aiQzwKEStl
— Michael C Moynihan (@mcmoynihan) February 6, 2019
There’s plenty more–enormous factual errors, other cribbed passages, single or unsourced claims–but this should give a sense.
— Michael C Moynihan (@mcmoynihan) February 6, 2019
Moynihan also added that the passages on Vice were “clotted with mistakes”; Abramson acknowledged in the Fox News interview that some Vice employees were upset by the book.
Writer Ian Frisch posted a thread to Twitter stating that Abramson also plagiarized him “at least seven times” — later amended to six — in “Merchants of Truth,” using a 2014 profile on Thomas Morton he wrote for his own venture, Relapse Magazine.
“I’m just…I don’t know. Devastated?” he wrote. “This is just crazy. I’m just showing these screenshots so people know. I have articles to write and a book coming out in three weeks, so I have bigger s— to worry about. But shame on you, Jill. Shame on you.”
He added that the plagiarized profile was only available on his personal website.
THREAD: Jill Abramson plagiarized me at least seven times in her new book, Merchants of Truth.
— Ian Frisch (@IanFrisch) February 7, 2019
Reporters and journalists expressed disappointment at the accusations.
“The evidence compiled by Michael is overwhelming,” wrote the Washington Post’s Amy Brittain, “and he only fact-checked three chapters. There is absolutely no excuse for this.”
https://twitter.com/AmyJBrittain/status/1093336407874129921
Abramson has also attracted attention in recent days for stating in The Cut that she doesn’t record interviews.
“I do not record,” she explained in a How I Get It Done profile. “I’ve never recorded. I’m a very fast note-taker. When someone kind of says the ‘it’ thing that I have really wanted, I don’t start scribbling right away. I have an almost photographic memory and so I wait a beat or two while they’re onto something else, and then I write down the previous thing they said. Because you don’t want your subject to get nervous about what they just said.”
https://twitter.com/SopanDeb/status/1092861372948496385
Yikes. This is from an interview with former NYT executive editor Jill Abramson. It is *breathtakingly* bad journalistic advice. https://t.co/6uNb34GRCQ
— Anthony Breznican (@Breznican) February 6, 2019
Perhaps if Jill Abramson took notes she'd be more likely to avoid…
*checks notes*
repeated instances of plagiarism…
*checks notes*
in a book titled "Merchants of Truth" https://t.co/4GB5Bdhx5x— Anthony L. Fisher (@anthonyLfisher) February 6, 2019
Abramson assumed the role of executive editor of the Times in September 2011 after starting at the paper in 1997. She was fired in May 2014.
