×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Fox Scores Big Win in Netflix Poaching Suit

A judge on Wednesday handed a major win to Fox in its long-running poaching suit against its rival Netflix.

Fox sued Netflix in 2016, after two employees left to join the streaming giant. Fox alleged that Netflix had interfered with its contracts with Tara Flynn and Marcos Waltenberg, both of whom left Fox before their contracts had expired. Netflix countered that Fox’s contracts are unlawful because they force employees to stay against their will. Netflix also charged that Fox was selectively enforcing its contracts, and that other employees were allowed to leave for other employers without consequence.

The case has been closely watched, as it could affect whether any employer can hold its employees to a fixed-term agreement. In a tentative ruling on Wednesday, Judge Marc Gross sided with Fox on the major question in the litigation, finding that Netflix’s arguments against Fox’s practices don’t stand up.

“The undisputed facts show Netflix intentionally interfered with Fox’s contracts with Waltenberg and Flynn,” Gross wrote. “In doing so, Netflix arguably sought to further its own economic interest at Fox’s expense and such conduct is not justified.”

Gross held, however, that Fox had failed to show that it was damaged by Netflix’s actions. That issue will left up for a jury to decide. The case is scheduled to go to trial in January.

Daniel Petrocelli, who represented Fox, argued that Netflix has been “audacious” in its disregard for Fox’s contracts, and said that since the case was filed, another 15 Fox employees have left for Netflix.

“Employees are being poached as we speak,” he said.

Karen Johnson-McKewan, arguing for Netflix, noted that Fox has engaged in substantial layoffs since the merger with Disney this spring.

“To suggest there’s some pillaging going on here is a bit overwrought,” she said. In light of the layoffs, “It feels like crocodile tears to be complaining about a handful of employees who have left to go to Netflix.”

Gross allowed Netflix to amend its cross-complaint to make additional arguments that Fox’s contracts ought to be invalidated.

Johnson-McKewan and Petrocelli declined to comment outside court.

More Biz

  • Young ThugBillboard Hot 100, Day 2,

    Travis Scott Remix Drives Young Thug’s ‘Hot’ to No. 1 on Rolling Stone Top 100

    Driven by a remix featuring Travis Scott, Young Thug’s single “Hot” has roared to the top of the Rolling Stone Top 100 this week. The song racked up more than 20 million audio streams and 3,700 downloads. Also getting a big boost is buzzing artist Arizona Zervas, whose “Roxanne” soared to No. 6 after debuting at [...]

  • Kevin LilesUJA-Federation of New York's Music

    300’s Kevin Liles Joins NY:LON Summit Keynote Roster

    The Music Business Association (Music Biz) and Music Ally today announce that 300 Entertainment cofounder and CEO Kevin Liles will deliver a keynote interview at the fourth annual NY:LON Connect music business summit. The conference takes place January 16 – 17, 2020 at the Dream Downtown Hotel in New York. According to the announcement, Liles [...]

  • Warner Bros. HQ LA

    Small Brush Fire Breaks Out Above Warner Bros. Lot in Burbank

    UPDATED: A small brush fire broke out in the Hollywood Hills above the Warner Bros. studio lot in Burbank, Calif., causing the Warner Bros. lot to evacuate as a precaution, before its forward progress was stopped at around 5 p.m. Saturday. According to the LAFD, fire crews are working on putting out the “still active [...]

  • Woody Allen

    Woody Allen Settles $68 Million Suit Against Amazon

    Woody Allen has settled his breach of contract lawsuit against Amazon, which canceled a four-picture deal with the filmmaker amid the #MeToo movement. Allen’s attorneys and lawyers for Amazon filed a joint notice dismissing the case on Friday night. Terms of the settlement were not disclosed. Allen filed suit in February, alleging that Amazon had [...]

  • Scott Stuber, Ron Howard are seen

    Netflix's Scott Stuber: Film Biz Needs to 'Be Calm and Talk Through' Exhibition Disputes

    Netflix film chief Scott Stuber urged film producers and exhibitors to come together to reach a consensus on exhibition window disputes as Netflix and other streaming giants move forcefully into feature production. Stuber, Netflix’s VP of film, spoke Saturday morning at the Producers Guild of America’s Produced By NY conference in a wide-ranging Q&A with [...]

  • Donald Trump Hollywood Racism

    President Trump Bashes Report of Talks With Mark Burnett for New 'Apprentice' Series

    President Donald Trump took to Twitter on Saturday morning to blast as “fake news” a report earlier this week that he is planning to develop a TV series with “The Apprentice” creator Mark Burnett following his time in the White House. On Thursday, the Daily Beast reported that Trump has been talking to Burnett, a [...]

  • BMG Music

    BMG Announces Move to Bigger Digs in L.A., Following Nashville and NYC Relocations

    Less than two months after announcing a planned move to a bigger and better facility in Nashville, BMG has declared plans to do the same in Los Angeles, with a deal in place to develop a two-story, 30,000-square-foot facility in the Miracle Mile district. It won’t be a long move: the location for the “proposed” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content