×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Judge Overturns $128 Million ‘Bones’ Judgment in Huge Win for Fox

A judge has overturned a $128 million punitive damages award to the producers and stars of the Fox series “Bones,” handing a major victory to the studio in what was one of the largest profit participation cases in Hollywood history.

Judge Richard Rico issued a minute order on Thursday overturning the award from arbitrator Peter Lichtman. A full decision was expected to be issued later. The ruling leaves in place a $50 million award for compensatory damages, interest and attorneys fees.

Nevertheless, it is a huge win for Daniel Petrocelli, the attorney who was hired to contest the arbitrator’s award, which was issued in February. In Rico’s court on Monday, Petrocelli argued that Lichtman had exceeded his authority and ignored a clear provision of the arbitration agreement that barred the profit participants from obtaining punitive damages.

“This court must be the ultimate judge of whether an arbitrator exceeded his powers,” Petrocelli argued, saying the arbitrator was barred from “distributing their own brand of industrial justice.”

The stars of the TV series “Bones,” Emily Deschanel and David Boreanaz, joined with two producers in filing suit in 2015 that accused Fox of shortchanging them on millions of dollars residual payments. They alleged that 20th Century Fox Television, which produced the show, charged absurdly low licensing fees to its affiliates, Fox Broadcasting and Hulu, thereby lowballing the payments to participants.

The case followed a well-worn path of litigation involving alleged self-dealing by vertically integrated media companies. The inclusion of Hulu added a new wrinkle for the streaming era. Lichtman found that Fox shorted the “Bones” producers and stars out of $10.1 million when it handed streaming rights to Hulu, of which Fox owned 30%, in exchange for a cut of advertising revenue.

Lichtman found that the arrangement was excessively generous to Hulu, and noted that a single Fox executive — Dan Fawcett — signed the licensing contract for both Fox and Hulu. That award, which still stands, suggests that companies may face further challenges if they attempt to prop up their own streaming platforms by offering content on terms that would not be available to rivals like Netflix and Amazon.

“There will be a lot of additional litigation in this area,” said Stanton “Larry” Stein, an attorney who pioneered the field of self-dealing suits at vertically integrated companies. “The fundamental issue is, if a product is successful, how should the parties be sharing in the success? You need to build into the contracts ways of resolving these disputes.”

Lichtman issued a blistering ruling in February, accusing top Fox executives of lying under oath to cover the fraud against the plaintiffs. Lichtman awarded a total of $179 million, including the $128 million punitive damage award, which he said was needed punish Fox’s “reprehensible conduct” and deter it from similar behavior in the future.

Fox did not contest the arbitrator’s award of $50 million in compensatory damages, attorneys’ fees, and interest, finding that it was beyond the scope of what Rico could review. But the studio — now owned by Disney — hired Petrocelli to challenge the punitive damages award. Petrocelli argued in his motion to overturn the award that Lichtman’s ruling was riddled with errors and betrayed animus against Fox executives.

Lichtman held that the clause in the arbitration agreement that bars punitive damages does not apply to the claims in this case, and that the clause was invalid anyway as it is against public policy.

Speaking for the plaintiffs, attorney Daniel Saunders argued that the arbitrator’s ruling cannot be reviewed or overturned.

“It was entirely the arbitrator’s right to interpret the contract,” he said. “It’s not for this court to review.”

Saunders said in a statement, “Today’s decision in no way impacts the arbitrator’s findings that our clients are owed more than $50 million for Fox’s fraudulent and deceitful accounting. It deals only with the technical issue of whether our clients waived their right to receive punitive damages. As the arbitrator concluded, they did not – and we look forward to showing the Court of Appeal why it should reverse today’s ruling.”

The plaintiffs plan to appeal the decision.

Fox issued a statement, saying “We are pleased with the Court’s decision to strike punitive damages from the award and vindicating our position.  We look forward to concluding the litigation.”

Dale Kinsella, the attorney for the show’s executive producer Barry Josephson said in a statement, “We respectfully and profoundly disagree with the trial court’s order eliminating the punitive damages award against Fox. While the ruling contains no reasoning, we are confident that when the appellate court reviews the Award with the required deference, without regard to the trial court’s finding, the original award will be reinstated. The balance of the award for compensatory damages, attorneys’ fees and prejudgment interest in excess of $50 million dollars remains intact, and today’s ruling does not disturb the Arbitrator’s findings in any way.”

Lichtman blasted Fox executives Peter Rice, Gary Newman and Dana Walden, among others, accusing them of giving false testimony during the arbitration. Rice and Walden have since taken high-level positions at Disney, and Disney CEO Bob Iger was compelled to issue a statement defending their character and integrity.

Update May 7: The judge’s full ruling is posted below. Rico found that the arbitrator exceeded his powers by ignoring an express provision of the arbitration agreement which forbade punitive damages.

Popular on Variety

More Biz

  • Patrick Whitesell and Ari Emanuel WME

    Endeavor Targets Sept. 27 for Stock Debut, IPO Video Tells Company's Origin Story

    After years of preparation, Endeavor is set to make its formal Wall Street debut on Sept. 27, when its stock will begin trading on the New York Stock Exchange. Endeavor has targeted Sept. 26 for the final pricing of its shares. The stock will trade publicly the following day. Earlier this week, Endeavor said its [...]

  • Netflix - Apple TV

    Netflix Stock Drops After CEO Acknowledges 'Tough Competition' Coming From Disney, Apple

    Netflix shares fell as much as 7% Friday to a nine-month low, coming after CEO Reed Hastings commented that the November launches of Disney Plus and Apple TV Plus will introduce a “whole new world” of competition. Hastings, speaking at the Royal Television Society conference Friday in Cambridge, England, said, “While we’ve been competing with [...]

  • Charlie Rose Sexual Harassment

    Charlie Rose Sued for Sexual Harassment by Longtime Makeup Artist

    A makeup artist who worked for Charlie Rose for 22 years has filed a sexual harassment lawsuit, accusing the former CBS and PBS host of years of unlawful behavior toward female employees. Gina Riggi alleges that Rose was verbally abusive with her and would often make derogatory comments about her weight. She also alleges that [...]

  • Rob Stringer

    Sony Music Chief Rob Stringer on Sustaining Growth and Recovering From the 'Dark Times'

    The Goldman Sachs Communacopia conference, now in its 28th year, gives top executives at major companies the opportunity to make their case to investors — and the Goldman analysts the opportunity to keep things on the up and up. While the analysts don’t necessarily grill the executives, they don’t lob softball questions either. That was [...]

  • Frank Grillo'Avengers: Endgame' Film Premiere, Arrivals,

    Matt Phelps Tapped as President of Joe Carnahan, Frank Grillo's Warparty

    Frank Grillo and Joe Carnahan’s Warparty productikon banner has appointed Matt Phelps president of the company. Phelps will head the Los Angeles office and be responsible for overseeing all film and television projects. “We searched long and hard to find the right fit for Warparty and felt that Matt embodied everything that we were looking [...]

  • Jack Gilardi, Longtime ICM Partners Agent,

    Jack Gilardi, Longtime ICM Partners Agent, Dies at 88

    Jack Gilardi, a longtime ICM Partners agent who represented such stars as Burt Reynolds, Sylvester Stallone, Jerry Lewis, Charlton Heston and Shirley MacLaine, died Thursday at his home in Los Angeles. He was 88. Gilardi was known for his gentlemanly style, love of the Los Angeles Dodgers and his skill at representing top actors. He [...]

  • Nexstar Completes Tribune Acquisition, Sean Compton

    Nexstar Completes Tribune Acquisition, Sean Compton to Head Programming

    Nexstar Media Group has become the nation’s largest owner of TV stations after completing its $4.1 billion acquisition of Tribune Media. The deal creates a broadcasting colossus with more than 200 stations serving more than 100 markets, although a number of stations will be divested to keep Nexstar in compliance with FCC ownership limits. Nexstar, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content