Antitrust Experts Decry DOJ’s ‘Outrageous’ Stance in Writers Guild Case

Several experts on antitrust law have expressed concern at the stance taken by the Department of Justice in the ongoing legal feud between Hollywood writers and their agents.

Three agencies have sued the Writers Guild of America for alleged violations of antitrust law. A key hearing will be held in federal court on Friday, as a judge weighs whether to grant the union’s motion to dismiss the suit. Last week, the DOJ’s Antitrust Division filed a brief siding with the agencies, and arguing that the union may have violated the Sherman Act.

“It’s outrageous,” said Sanjukta Paul, a professor at Wayne State University Law School who studies the intersection of labor and antitrust law. “This is not a neutral reading of the law.”

The Antitrust Division, led by Makan Delrahim, has filed similar briefs in other cases around the country. In 2017, the division opposed a Seattle ordinance that would allow Uber and Lyft drivers to unionize. Earlier this year, the division sided against fast-food workers who accused restaurant chains of engaging in illegal no-poaching agreements.

Rep. David Cicilline, the Democrat who chairs the House Judiciary subcommittee on antitrust, sent a letter to Delrahim in May castigating him for siding against the rights of workers. He accused Delrahim of running the division like an “industry-funded think tank,” while neglecting the enforcement of antitrust laws.

“They’re operating on the side of capital,” said Matt Stoller, author of “Goliath: The 100-Year War Between Monopoly Power and Democracy.” “They’re saying, ‘We want capital to do whatever capital wants,’ and they’re opposed to any prohibitions on that.”

In the Writers Guild case, the agencies — CAA, UTA and WME — allege that the union has engaged in an illegal group boycott. More than 7,000 writers fired their agents in April, after the agencies refused to accept the guild’s new code of conduct. The new code forbids agencies from acting as producers or accepting packaging fees from producers, saying that poses a conflict of interest.

The WGA has countered that its actions fall under the labor exemption to the Sherman Act, which gives unions broad latitude to act in their members’ interest without facing an antitrust claim. The key Supreme Court precedent in the case, H.A. Artists & Associates v. Actors Equity Association (1981), granted entertainment guilds broad power to set the terms of agent representation. But the agencies argue that power is not unlimited, and that by taking the drastic actions it has in its campaign against packaging fees, the guild has stepped outside the protection of the labor exemption.

In its brief, the Antitrust Division concurred, arguing that the guild may have combined with “non-labor parties,” such as showrunners, which is not allowed under the labor exemption. Showrunners are members of the WGA, but the agencies argue that they often have their own production companies and can act as employers.

“This is a stretch,” Paul said. “This is coordination that the union is doing within its own membership. That’s what they’re challenging.”

The DOJ also suggested that the WGA may be “abusing its monopsony power over agents” in its efforts to enforce its conflict of interest rules.

Marshall Steinbaum, an economics professor at the University of Utah, has written about how employers can enjoy monopsony power in labor markets, giving them leverage to keep wages low. He said it was ironic to see such an argument deployed to curtail the power of a union.

“They’re cynically using this hot scholarly topic to give weight to a position that it directly at odds with it,” he said. “The application of the antitrust laws to prevent collective action by workers in a labor dispute is the exact opposite of what recent research says antitrust law should be doing to rectify disproportionate employer power in labor markets.”

Paul said the brief in the WGA case goes farther than the arguments the DOJ has made in other cases.

“I don’t think this is about the Writers Guild,” she said. “It’s not that they care fundamentally about how the talent agency ecosystem works in Hollywood. It’s a signal that labor coordination should be disfavored in favor of corporate power.”

More Biz

  • peacock-ads-NBCU

    NBCU's Peacock Marks Media's Latest Try to Connect Consumers, Commercials

    In an era when consumers feel more empowered to avoid TV commercials, NBCUniversal is the latest media company to try to get them to bring ads back into their TV lives. One of the key selling points of big streaming-video services like Netflix and Disney Plus is that subscribers don’t have to endure the commercial [...]

  • Our Planet BTS BBC

    U.K. Entertainment Industry Moves Beyond London

    When Channel 4 launches its daytime current-affairs program “The Steph Show” this spring, it will mark a milestone in the U.K. broadcaster’s output.  Like most of the British film and TV industries, Channel 4 has been heavily London-centric. By contrast, “The Steph Show,” starring journalist and presenter Steph McGovern, was commissioned by the network’s new [...]

  • Lucian Grainge

    Universal Music Chief Lucian Grainge to Receive Star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

    Lucian Grainge — chairman/CEO of Universal Music Group, the world’s largest music company — will receive a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame next Thursday (Jan. 23). Fittingly, the ceremony will take place in front of the historic Capitol Records building; Capitol is one of the several Universal-owned labels under Grainge’s domain. Universal, recently [...]

  • John Ross Promoted to Vice President,

    John Ross Promoted to Vice President, Features and Events, at Variety

    Variety’s three-time Emmy Award-winning producer and managing director of features and events John Ross has been upped to VP, features and events. Ross, who exec produces Variety’s Actors on Actors series, has been instrumental to the development of Variety’s features business, including the Young Hollywood issue, the Pride issue, Showman of the Year, the Billion [...]

  • Deborah Dugan Recording Academy Head

    Deborah Dugan’s Attorney Slams Grammys With Fiery Statement After Ouster

    Less than 12 hours after news broke that Deborah Dugan had been placed on administrative leave from her post as president/CEO of the Recording Academy, her attorney fired back with a statement. “What has been reported is not nearly the story that needs to be told. When our ability to speak is not restrained by [...]

  • Nick Cannon Drew Barrymore Lauren Lake

    NATPE 2020: Industryites Hope Marquee Names Help Drive Daytime Turnaround

    A little momentum goes a long way in daytime. After a long slump, the first-run syndication market has come back to life this year with several high-profile new talk shows headed for this year’s NATPE conference in Miami, which runs Jan. 21-23. Nick Cannon is extending his multimedia endeavors into daytime. So is actor-entrepreneur Drew [...]

  • Mandatory Credit: Photo by Richard Sowersby/REX/Shutterstock

    Joint Sky & NBC News Channel Confirmed, Set To Rival CNN & Bloomberg

    Comcast confirmed plans to launch a global news platform with Sky News at the launch of its highly anticipated streaming offering Peacock. Variety understands that the channel will be a brand new service that exists independent of Sky News and NBC News, with bases likely to be set up in London and New York and a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content