×

TV Review: ‘Paterno’ With Al Pacino on HBO

Watching HBO Films’ latest snatched-from-the-headlines project, “Paterno,” one can’t help but wonder how different it might have been had Brian De Palma directed it.

He’s had an advantageous working relationship with star Al Pacino on both “Scarface” and “Carlito’s Way.” In his hands, the film could have been a “King Lear”-level tragedy about a sports legend whose singular focus led to his downfall.

Instead what viewers get is director Barry Levinson’s well-intended but paroxysmal journey into legendary college football coach Joe Paterno’s fall from grace, fired by Penn State for his role in the Jerry Sandusky abuse scandal.

Unsure if he wants to focus more on Paterno or newspaper journalist Sara Ganim — the reporter who broke the Sandusky story — Levinson constantly switches his gaze from one to the other. Ganim’s role as a consultant on the film may have mucked up the process even more. The end result is a film that clumsily tries to sympathize with Paterno instead of the young boys he chose to ignore until it was too late.

This is the third time Levinson and Pacino have teamed up for HBO to spin real-life antihero tales. The first time earned Pacino an Emmy and a Golden Globe for his performance as well-known euthanasia practitioner Jack Kevorkian in “You Don’t Know Jack” (2010).

Pumped by all the buzz that small-screen flick received, Levinson and Pacino reconnected for “Phil Spector” (2013). The latter focused on the odd relationship between the music producer and his lawyer Jennifer Lee Barringer (Helen Mirren) while he was on trial for murder.

But where Pacino slipped into both portrayals with the help of wigs and wacky accents, he is less at ease with his take on Joe Pa, delivering a performance of a man just as uneven as the film it is named after.

In a few inspired scenes, Pacino is stunningly convincing as a shuffling Paterno roaming around the house in pajamas trying unsuccessfully to control his fate. He barks at his family and advisors to stop talking about him like he’s not there, and in a rare moment of humor shouts “put me in the ground.” In a game against Nebraska, the first match up that occurred after the university pink-slipped Paterno, he is masterfully shown grappling with the rage of his exclusion and his guilt and shame all without dialogue.

In spite of these flashes of brilliance, or maybe because of them, Pacino can’t help being Pacino, and there are times when he is indistinguishable from the character. Unfortunately, no amount of makeup or prosthetic noses can hold Pacino back for long, and his growl is so loud sometimes that it overpowers the vision of the wounded god Paterno became.

Riley Keough, Kathy Baker and Annie Parisse deliver strong performances as Ganim, Joe’s wife, Sue, and his daughter Mary Kay respectively. Not so coincidentally, all three women also serve as rare voices of reason in a testosterone-induced world of college sports and perfect records.

But in the end, it’s all about Pacino’s Paterno. Did Joe Pa know about the sins of his former defensive coordinator but turn a blind eye because it was more convenient? Levinson and his screenwriters certainly imply as much in both subtle and not so subtle ways. They also make it clear that a frightening majority of Penn State students and fans cared more about the football team and Paterno’s legacy than the victims themselves.

Regardless, the creative partnership between Pacino and Levinson may well have run its course. The third time is only the charm if it scores a touchdown, but this one ultimately fumbles.

TV Review: 'Paterno' With Al Pacino on HBO

Made for TV movie; HBO, 8 p.m. Saturday April 7. 1 hour and 45 minutes

Crew: Executive producers Barry Levinson, Tom Fontana, Rick Nicita, Edward R. Pressman. CAST: Al Pacino, Kathy Baker, Riley Keough, Greg Grunberg, Annie Parisse, Jim Johnson, Darren Goldstein, Steve Coulter, Benjamin Cook, Larry Mitchell, Tom Kemp.

More TV

  • William Bogert Dead: 'Small Wonder' Actor

    William Bogert, Who Appeared in 'War Games,' 'Small Wonder,' Dies at 83

    TV, film and theater actor William Bogert, who appeared in a recurring role on 1980s sitcom “Small Wonder” and in films such as “War Games,” died Jan. 12 in New York. He was 83. On “Small Wonder,” which ran from 1985 to 1989, Bogert played Brandon Brindle, the Lawsons’ neighbor and Harriet’s father who became [...]

  • Editorial Use OnlyMandatory Credit: Photo by

    TV Ratings: NFL's AFC, NFC Championship Games Down From 2019

    The NFL’s AFC and NFC championship games made for a blockbuster Sunday of football for CBS and Fox, but viewership of the games that determine the contenders for the Super Bowl was down from 2019 levels. CBS’ AFC championship in the 3 p.m. ET afternoon slot delivered 41.1 million viewers as the Kansas City Chiefs [...]

  • Medici TV Show

    Vuulr Online Rights Market Makes Global Expansion at NATPE

    Singapore-based Vuulr, an online content marketplace for film and TV rights, is expanding from regional to global operations. The move was announced ahead of NATPE, one of the oldest face-to-face TV rights markets, this week launching its tenth edition in Miami, Florida (Jan 21-23). The Vuulr platform is free to use for buyers and for [...]

  • What to Watch on TV This

    What to Watch on TV This Week: ‘Picard' Premieres and 'Shrill' Returns

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “Star Trek: Picard” beams into existence on CBS All Access and “Shrill” returns [...]

  • SAG Awards 2020: What You Didn't

    SAG Awards 2020: From Charlize Theron to 'Parasite,' What You Didn't See on TV

    Brad Pitt made a crack about his marriages. Robert De Niro got political. And Jennifer Aniston talked about appearing in a commercial for Bob’s Big Boy. Those were just some of thing that happened on stage at the SAG Awards that were broadcast on TNT/TBS on Sunday night. However, Variety was inside the Shrine Auditorium [...]

  • Edges Unknown

    TCB, Cineflix, All3Media Announce Sales Ahead of NATPE Miami

    Miami’s NATPE market kicks off on Tuesday, but deal announcements are already landing. London-based TCB Media Rights has sold 130 hours of content to Latin America, Cineflix and National Geographic Latin America closed a deal for four titles, and Discovery Latin America picked up popular makeover format “10 Years Younger” from All3Media. TCB’s 130 Hours [...]

  • U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas

    U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas Markle Documentary

    ViacomCBS-backed U.K. broadcaster Channel 5 will air a 90-minute documentary on Meghan Markle’s father Thomas Markle. Markle and her husband Prince Harry sparked a global media frenzy earlier this month with their decision not to continue as senior members of the British Royal Family. Buckingham Palace announced that the couple are to lose their royal [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content