×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Unwieldy Upfront: TV Market Gets More Complex Thanks to Demands for Data

Any veteran of tv ad sales can regale you with a story of how he or she took a client over to a table at a party, called for a few glasses of wine and drew up an entire upfront plan on a napkin.

These days, the two would need at least a tablecloth — if not several more pieces of linen.

TV’s annual “upfront” market, when U.S. networks try to sell the bulk of their advertising inventory for the coming programming season, has never been more intricate and convoluted. Yes, advertisers continue to invest most of their dollars based on Nielsen measures of how many people are watching at any given time. But as more viewers have migrated to on-demand streaming and mobile screens, Madison Avenue is growing more interested in using data to pinpoint new niches: first-time car buyers, expectant mothers, orange-soda drinkers and much more.

The networks have to help marketers in their quest. Billions of dollars are at stake. The nation’s five English-language broadcast networks secured between $8.69 billion and $9.55 billion in advance ad commitments for their primetime schedules last year, compared with $8.41 billion to $9.25 billion in 2016 — possibly marking the most they’ve gleaned since six broadcast networks — the WB and UPN were still around, in place of CW — secured about $9.5 billion in 2004.

The views on 2018’s haggle are mixed: Magna Global, the Interpublic Group media-buying and research unit, has predicted a 1% drop in ad spending on broadcast and cable this year. Some TV sales executives are more sanguine, and feel the medium can keep even with the volume it secured last year. Executives for a number of media companies, including CBS and Walt Disney have taken pains during recent earnings calls to point out robust rates for “scatter,” or ad time bought closer to time of air. When scatter is high, that’s typically an indicator advertisers will put more money in the upfront, in hopes of locking down good rates.

To keep the money flowing, the TV folks keep changing their ways. Many advertisers are increasingly interested in “audience buying,” and that’s creating new wrinkles in the upfront, a buying process that has been around since the early 1960s, when ABC decided to launch all of its new shows in the fall, after Labor Day. The original thought behind the event was to debut programs at a time when advertisers were eager to hawk new wares; the fall let Madison Avenue target back-to-school season and seed interest in the end-of-year holidays.

Transactions then were relatively easy. TV had no video rival, and marketers didn’t have the option of using social media or mobile devices to reach their customers. If you ran an ad on TV, chances are it was going to stick. So even though audience measures were blunt, advertisers had few worries.

Now they are working furiously to use TV in smarter fashion. “Clients currently need to pull in data from multiple disparate sources to get a full view of their audiences,” says Manish Bhatia, CEO, North America, of Kantar Media, the WPP unit that measures ad spending and effectiveness. “Research providers are moving to provide more comprehensive metrics, but we are still in a transition phase as an industry. We will likely stay in transition for a while.”

Among the new ad-buying twists:

» A consortium of big media hitters — Viacom, 21st Century Fox’s Fox Networks Group, Time Warner’s Turner and NBCUniversal — are involved in OpenAP, a technology that helps advertisers define narrower groupings of audience segments across the various companies’ TV networks. The alliance gives marketers the ability to use the same consumer segments no matter which company’s networks they are studying.

» A+E Networks this year expects to do a small number of deals with advertisers that guarantee certain business outcomes as the result of running commercials. A+E Networks, says Peter Olsen, executive vice president of ad sales for the company, is comfortable backing promises of how much foot traffic in stores or how many web visits will be spurred by exposure to TV ads. NBCUniversal has made a similar offer.

» The process will be further bogged down by efforts by NBCU and Fox Broadcasting to cut back on commercials in some parts of their primetime schedule. The aim is to make linear TV more welcoming to a generation of viewers who regularly see fewer ads when they watch their favorite video offerings on venues like Netflix and Hulu. NBCU and Fox are selling new commercial formats they believe are worth more than typical ads.

Marketers know they can get granular data about the kinds of consumers their ads attract online. Now they want that same information from TV networks. TV was once a medium where advertisers would “pay and spray” the same commercial across a primetime lineup and sit back and relax, knowing full well the spots would reach their intended audience again and again. Now, with dozens of Apple, Amazon, Google and Samsung screens and other interfaces vying for the TV viewer’s attention, they want to place ads with more precision.

What’s wrong with adopting new measures in a world that yearns for more transparency? The industry has its collective hands on too many yardsticks. Many companies have begun to cobble together their own methods of measuring audience segments beyond age and gender breakdowns to track linear, digital and VOD viewing. “Right now, we’re aggregating things that are apples and oranges and bananas,” says David Cohen, president of North American operations at Magna, the Interpublic Group media-buying and research unit.

In recent upfronts, buyers and network executives have joked that they hoped all the haggling would be over by July 4. In many years, that hasn’t been the case.

But sometimes, demand spurs activity. In 2013, for example, the CW wrapped its sales by June 5. In 2005, Walt Disney’s ABC had nearly completed its upfront sales before the end of May, buoyed by hits like “Lost,” “Desperate Housewives” and “Grey’s Anatomy.” In 2017, advertisers and networks executed their last deals in mid-July.

The call for better measurement “makes upfront negotiations a little more complicated, clearly,” says Olsen. “There’s complexity, but I feel like it’s complexity moving in the direction of trying to solve a problem, versus complexity for complexity’s sake.”

More TV

  • A Man Walks Into the Cnn

    CNN Puts Former Sessions Aide in Newsroom Role

    Sarah Isgur Flores, a press aide to former US Attorney General Jeff Sessions, has been hired to help direct and plan political coverage for CNN, a move that generated some pushback on social media Tuesday. Politico previously reported the CNN hire. Flores in the past has criticized CNN coverage. A spokesperson for the AT&T-owned media [...]

  • Gerald Blum, Inspiration for 'WKRP In

    Gerald Blum, Inspiration for 'Big Guy' Carlson on 'WKRP in Cincinnati,' Dies at 86

    Gerald “Jerry” Blum, the inspiration for the character of radio station general manager Art “Big Guy” Carlson on the long-running TV sitcom “WKRP in Cincinnati,” died Saturday at 86. The Atlanta radio veteran was affectionately transformed into the fictional Carlson by veteran comic actor Gordon Jump on “WKRP,” which ran for four seasons on CBS [...]

  • Arrested Development Season 5 review

    TV News Roundup: 'Arrested Development' Sets Season 5 Return Date at Netflix

    In today’s TV news roundup, the second half of “Arrested Development” season five gets a release date and Netflix announces the voice cast for “Green Eggs and Ham.” CASTING Netflix has announced the ensemble voice cast for the upcoming “Green Eggs and Ham” series executive produced by Ellen DeGeneres and based on the Dr. Seuss book. [...]

  • LA Rams running back Todd Gurley

    Live+7 Ratings for Week of Jan. 28: Super Bowl LIII Clobbers Competition

    In a shock to no one, the 2019 Super Bowl handily defeated all of its broadcast competition in the Live+7 numbers for the week of Jan. 28. Live sports typically receive virtually no lift in delayed viewing, and Super Bowl LIII was no exception. The game did, however, rise from a 31.1 rating in adults [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Jussie Smollett Faces Prison, Career Ruin if He Lied About Attack

    Jussie Smollett is facing prison time and the implosion of his career if it turns out he lied about being the target of a hate crime, legal and public relations experts say. “The best thing that Jussie can do is pray and pray a lot,” said Ronn Torossian, founder of 5W Public Relations. “If he [...]

  • BETTER THINGS "Chicago" Episode 1 (Airs

    TV Review: 'Better Things' Season 3

    A few episodes into the new season of “Better Things,” fed-up mother Sam (creator Pamela Adlon) tries a new tactic to break up one of the countless petty fights between her daughters. Instead of forcing them apart and hoping for the best, she throws up her hands and decides to just let them go at it, [...]

  • Anna Paquin, Sophie Okonedo in Flack

    TV Review: 'Flack' Starring Anna Paquin

    There’s a familiar, acrid aftertaste to “Flack,” Pop’s new drama about the controlled chaos of the publicity industry. The grim behind-the-scenes machinations of the glossy entertainment industry have always been one of TV’s favorite subjects, as are the people tasked with pulling the strings without anyone ever realizing. Over just six episodes, the show manages [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content