×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘Troy: Fall of a City’ Team Talk Casting and Diversity in the BBC and Netflix Epic

Casting of black actors has raised hackles in some quarters

“Black Panther” may be storming the global box office, but casting actors of color in the Netflix and BBC epic “Troy: Fall of a City” has stirred up controversy in some quarters. A debate over whether having black actors play Greek gods and heroes is true to Homer’s “Iliad,” which recounts the decade-long siege of Troy, has played out in parts of the press and on social media.

David Gyasi (“Interstellar”) plays Achilles in the series, which, unusually, takes the perspective of the Trojans. Hakeem Kae-Kazim (“Black Sails”) stars as the god Zeus and Lemogang Tsipa as Patroklus. They appear alongside the likes of Louis Hunter and Bella Dayne, who play Paris and Helen, and actor David Threlfall in a deep ensemble cast.

But the choice of non-white actors for key roles has outraged some. “Why does BBC’s new drama ‘Troy: Fall of a City,’ set in 1200 B.C., feel the need to Hector us about race and gender?” a headline in the right-wing Sun tabloid harrumphed. “Controversy looms as mythical Achilles is played by black actor in new BBC epic,” read another on an English-language site about Greek Hollywood.

The debate was also picked up on Twitter, with many debating the casting of Gyasi as Achilles and noting that Homer described the character as blond.

But David Farr, who wrote “Troy” and the BBC and AMC series “The Night Manager,” told Variety that the team went into the casting process with a completely open mind because of the nature of the project. “As you enter the world of myth you have immediately a wonderful freedom,” he said. “I understand that for certain people, probably mainly in Greece, there is a national idea of Achilles. I personally think that they just have to accept that we are looking at this myth, and we had the freedom to cast it as we have.”

Classical historian Bettany Hughes was an adviser on the series, and Farr noted that genuine historical accuracy was not a viable option. “No one knows if Homer’s version of [around 1200 B.C.], which was written 500 years later, is truthful to anything specific, anything particular, or whether it wasn’t an entirely mythic thing.

“You can’t cast Hittites as Trojans; I’d love to do it but sadly there are none available!” said Farr, adding: “We are not claiming that Achilles was actually Ethiopian any more than if a black actor played [King] Arthur. It is simply a casting decision. Whoever came and inhabited the spirit of the characters best we decided to cast.”

The eight-part series is the first for Derek Wax’s Wild Mercury, which produced “Troy” in association with Endemol Shine’s U.K.-based drama specialist Kudos. Wax, a former executive producer at Kudos, set up his own shingle last year, having first had the idea for “Troy” seven years ago. The BBC came on board in 2015 and Netflix the following year.

The “Troy” team was initially keen to have a black Andromache. “We thought that that could be really interesting, but Chloe Pirrie came along and was so fantastic that we decided to cast a white actress.” Wax said: “Diversity is at the heart of our casting and at the heart of what the BBC and Netflix wants. It’s only a controversy if people try to manufacture a controversy out of it.”

Netflix will launch the series in the U.S. and globally once the BBC run has ended. In the U.K., the opening episode won its BBC One Saturday night slot on 17 Feb. with an audience of 3.2 million and a share of 18.2%. Wax and Farr have scoped out a possible follow-up.

“We do have ideas for a second season,” Wax said. “Without giving any spoilers, Homer did write ‘The Odyssey.'”

Popular on Variety

More TV

  • Taylor SwiftMTV Video Music Awards, Arrivals,

    Taylor Swift Joins 'The Voice' Season 17 as a Mentor

    Taylor Swift is returning to “The Voice” as a mega mentor in the upcoming 17th season of the NBC singing competition series. The “Blank Space” singer will offer advice to each team of artists as they prepare for the knockout rounds in the show. Coaches John Legend and Blake Shelton took to Instagram to share [...]

  • Netflix Lands Streaming Rights to 'Seinfeld'

    Netflix Lands Streaming Rights to 'Seinfeld'

    Netflix yada yada yada “Seinfeld.” Variety has confirmed that the streaming giant has landed the global streaming rights to all 180 episodes the genre-defining sitcom. The deal was struck with Sony Pictures Television, which controls the distribution rights to the NBC series. It is a five-year deal which is set to begin in 2021. “’Seinfeld’ [...]

  • Lin-Manuel Miranda

    'Kingkiller Chronicle' Series Not Moving Forward at Showtime, Lionsgate TV to Shop

    The series adaptation of “The Kingkiller Chronicle” is not moving forward at Showtime as planned. Variety has confirmed with sources that Showtime will no longer develop the series, which has been in the works at the premium cabler since October 2017, for financial reasons. Lionsgate Television, which is producing the show, will now shop the [...]

  • Charlie HunnamBleecker Street 'Papillon' Los Angeles

    Charlie Hunnam to Star in ‘Shantaram’ Series at Apple

    Charlie Hunnam has been cast as the lead in the forthcoming Apple series “Shantaram,” based on Gregory David Robert’s novel, Variety has confirmed. Apple has greenlit the show, which will represent the first international production for Apple TV Plus, after acquiring the rights to the novel back in June 2018. The 2003 novel tells the story of [...]

  • Wendy Williams

    ‘The Wendy Williams Show’ Renewed Through 2021-22 Season on Fox Stations

    “The Wendy Williams Show” is set to remain on the air through the 2021-22 season. Fox Television Stations has handed Williams’ eponymous talk show a two-year renewal, extending the live, nationally syndicated show’s decade-long run to 13 seasons. “I’m so excited to launch our 11th year by letting the world know I will continue to [...]

  • Canal Plus

    Netflix, France's Canal Plus Sign Distribution Deal

    France’s Canal Plus Group has sealed a deal to offer Netflix on its platform, joining other pay- and cable-TV providers across Europe in recognizing the demand for access to the U.S. streaming giant. Beginning Oct. 15, subscribers to Canal Plus’ Cine/Series package will gain access to Netflix through Canal Plus’ set-top boxes. The exclusive bundle [...]

  • TV Ratings: Eagles-Falcons Down 18% on

    TV Ratings: Eagles-Falcons Down 18% on 'Sunday Night Football' Opener

    Last night, Matt Ryan and the Atlanta Flacons held off Carson Wentz and the Philadelphia Eagles in an interception-filled affair on “Sunday Night Football.” Perhaps unsurprisingly given the stop-start nature of the game, it didn’t perform quite as strongly in the early Nielsen ratings as last week’s “SNF” opener between the New England Patriots and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content