Late-Night TV Has a Growing Problem: Maybe There’s Too Much of It

Analysis: There's nothing humorous about new wee-hours entrants being axed, but the format is crowded with shows that lack broader appeal

Something funny is going on with late-night TV, but it’s not the sort of development that’s going to make anyone laugh.

Netflix’s decision on Friday to cancel programs led by comics Michelle Wolf and Joel McHale, both of which emulated traditional late-night series, marks just the most recent move in a scaling back of the genre. BET in July declined to launch a second season of Robin Thede’s “The Rundown.” And Comedy Central in June axed Jordan Klepper’s “The Opposition,” its latest bid to find a natural follow to its flagship “The Daily Show” (nor has the Viacom network sought to keep the well-received “President Show,” starring Anthony Atamanuik,” in circulation).

The new entrants aren’t the only ones grappling with the place of late-night programming in an era when viewers watch video at their own choosing. Conan O’Brien, TV’s longest-serving late-night personality, is poised to take his hour-long “Conan” on TBS to 30 minutes next year.

And NBC’s “Tonight Show” has this summer been experimenting with “hybrid” Friday broadcasts that meld fresh opening material with repeat interviews from guest celebrities. A similar effort was tested last summer by CBS’s “Late Show,”  highlighting how difficult it has become for wee-hours aficionados to find fresh material on Friday nights. Seth Meyers and James Corden don’t do original Friday broadcasts, and an original Friday is an exception for Jimmy Kimmel rather than the norm. “Daily Show” has long been a four-days-a week effort. Bill Maher continues to hold forth on most Friday evenings via HBO.

Note to Busy Philipps, who is set to launch a new late-night format on E! in late October: The future of experiments in the category may rest on your shoulders. At a time of  “Peak TV,” we may be seeing “Peak Late Night” too.

Perhaps the current state of late night should come as no surprise. After all, the format has been enjoying something of a boom – and not all of it has come from the surge experienced by many of the shows as they tilt at the Donald Trump-dominated news cycle.

HBO carved out more attention for late-night comedy on Sundays when it launched John Oliver’s “Last Week Tonight” in April 2014 (as did Bravo’s “Watch What Happens Live” when Andy Cohen debuted a Sunday night show in 2009). Samantha Bee did something even more radical in February 2016 when she kicked off “Full Frontal” on TBS. (Her show is considered part of the late-night set even though it airs well within a time slot considered to be primetime.) Much of this activity was fueled by the late-night-host hopscotch that jumped off in the wake of the retirements of Jay Leno from NBC’s “Tonight Show” in 2014 and David Letterman from CBS’ “Late Show” in May 2015, not to mention ABC’s decision to move Kimmel ahead of “Nightline” in January 2013.

But the history of late-night is filled with less successful efforts to join the fray: For every Arsenio Hall, there has been a Pat Sajak, Joan Rivers or Chevy Chase. Still, more keep jumping aboard. Showtime is developing a weekly late-night series with Desus Nice and The Kid Mero. HBO ordered a second season of Wyatt Cenac’s “Problem Areas,” as did Hulu with Sarah Silverman’s “I Love You America,” which will launch its sophomore effort in September.  Even Netflix has more in the works, with a series from Hasan Minhaj.

Now, late-night’s bull market might be nearing its cyclical end. It’s easy to blame Netflix’s unorthodox structure for the late-night pullback. The SVOD service has gotten viewers hooked on binge-watching, but there’s little proof it can force viewers to tune in to a genre that is timely, not timeless.

CBS, ABC and NBC earmark precious minutes of their schedule every day to promos that bark out the latest guests on each evening’s latenight broadcasts, and with very good reason. Everything on these shows has got a sell-by date nearly concurrent with the moment it’s conceived. Stephen Colbert’s monologues, Jimmy Fallon’s antics, Jimmy Kimmel’s pranks, and Seth Meyers’ “Closer Look” segments riff off the latest headlines. Within 24 hours, they move from fresh to stale. And while one may see a Colbert promo during “NCIS” or a Fallon alert during “This Is Us,” a Netflix user would be hard-pressed to recall an urgent message showing up during a binge-view of “All About The Washingtons” reminding them of see-it-or-miss-out material from Wolf or McHale.

Something else playing a role in late-night retrenchment. With audiences splintering around a dizzying array of hosts, video entertainment options, viewing behaviors, and even political leanings, many of the new efforts aim for fragments of the audience, not the bigger field. Johnny Carson had to be all things to all people; Stephen Colbert, Samantha Bee and Trevor Noah do not. Nor do they want to be.

To hook viewers in the future, perhaps the hosts and the networks should try to grab more of them, rather than merely aiming for the niche or demographic most likely to align with their particular brand of comedy. There are some recent signals – a musical guest on Samantha Bee, a T-Mobile sweepstakes and special Central Park broadcast of Fallon’s “Tonight”, an intensification of efforts to snare hard-line conservative guests for Bill Maher – that the time has come to do more late-night for many, rather than more late-night for a few.

That would make a growing number of people smile – especially the executives who are on the hook to deliver late-night results that make their companies look good in the bright light of day.

More TV

  • The 100 -- "Sanctum" -- Image

    'The 100' Boss Breaks Down Season 6's New World and Theme of 'Can We Do Better?'

    When “The 100” returns for its sixth season on April 30, the CW drama will thrust its characters into a brand new world. After escaping a no-longer habitable Earth at the end of the fifth season, the characters went into cryostasis until the planet was ready for life again. One hundred and twenty-five years later, [...]

  • David Milch Deadwood

    'Deadwood' Creator David Milch Diagnosed With Alzheimer's

    David Milch, the creator of “Deadwood,” revealed his Alzheimer’s diagnosis in an interview published Tuesday. “As best I understand it, which is minimally, I have a deterioration in the organization of my brain,” Milch told Vulture. “And it’s progressive. And in some ways discouraging. In more than some ways — in every way I can [...]

  • Jim Lanzone

    CBS Interactive Chief Jim Lanzone: 'We Have a Tiger by the Tail' With Streaming Growth

    MENLO PARK, Calif. — CBS All Access can’t serve up addressable advertising inventory fast enough for marketers hungry to reach consumers watching premium video online. That was the upbeat outlook shared by CBS Interactive CEO Jim Lanzone during his keynote address on Tuesday at Variety’s Silicon Valleywood presented by PwC. “There’s not a form of advertising [...]

  • ÒThe One Where Diane and Liz

    'The Good Fight' Renewed for Season 4 at CBS All Access

    “The Good Fight” has been renewed for a fourth season at CBS All Access, Variety has learned. The legal drama, executive produced and run by Michelle King and Robert King, is currently streaming its third season on the Eye’s digital network. The show “continues to be a flagship original series for the service,” said Julie [...]

  • Netflix Orders Adult Animated Comedy 'Inside

    Netflix Orders Adult Animated Comedy 'Inside Job' from Shion Takeuchi

    Netflix is set to add another adult animated show to its burgeoning slate, Variety as confirmed. The streamer has put out a series order of “Inside Job” from “Gravity Falls” and “Disenchantment” writer Shion Takeuchi. The show will be the first series Takeuchi produces under her recently-signed overall deal with Netflix. The 20-episode adult animated series [...]

  • Peabody Award Logo

    Peabody Awards Announce First-Ever Catalyst Award and 2019 News and Radio/Podcast Winners

    The Peabody Board of Jurors have selected “$2 Tests: Bad Arrests,” “Anatomy of a Killing,” “Back of the Class,” “Cambridge Analytica,” “The Plastic Problem,” “Separated: Children at the Border” and “Spartan Silence: Crisis at Michigan State” as the 2019 Peabody Award winners in the news category, Variety has learned. Additionally, “Believed,” “Buried Truths,” “Caliphate,” “Kept [...]

  • Ryan Murphy Walk of Fame

    Ryan Murphy Says He Has 10 Greenlit Projects at Netflix

    At the Time 100 Summit on Tuesday, Ryan Murphy revealed that he has 10 greenlit projects in the pipeline at Netflix, including three documentaries, four TV shows, and three movies. Murphy has previously announced five titles slated for a Netflix release. Three are shows, including “Ratched,” the drama series starring Sarah Paulson as the infamous [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content