You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Debate Over ‘The Affair’ Star Ruth Wilson’s Awkward Exit (Column)

In an interview with “CBS This Morning” this week, Ruth Wilson created something rare for daytime talk: the sort of tense, awkward moment that reminds you that a show is unscripted, and live. Asked about the end of her role on “The Affair” — her character, Alison, was recently killed — Wilson told “This Morning” host Gayle King that “I did want to leave, but I’m not allowed to talk about why.”

This sort of mysteriousness around the decisions made by or for actors is nothing new; TV fans are still waiting, and likely will be forever, for clarity on why Julianna Margulies and Archie Panjabi stopped filming “The Good Wife” together. But Wilson’s bluntness, delivered with a tense smile, stopped the “This Morning” chat dead. Attempting to restart the interview, King asked if rumors she’d heard about gender-based pay disparities on “The Affair” were true (itself a surprising bit of hearsay to surface on a morning show, particularly one aired by Showtime’s corporate partner). “I’ve never complained to Showtime about pay parity,” Wilson said, choosing her words with lawyerly care before issuing the sort of tight chuckle that indicates a topic is closed.

Speculation online has since run wild — not surprising, perhaps, given Wilson’s crypticness and scrupulous phrasing, but also striking given that the show at issue is an aging cable series heading into its final season.

Characters — even lead characters — are killed off shows frequently. And Variety‘s reporting indicates that the decision was nowhere near as dramatic as it seems, having been rooted in Wilson’s decision to leave the show to pursue a BBC/PBS miniseries about her family history. But Wilson’s crypticness helped turn what would otherwise have been ultimately business as usual for a TV industry that traffics in huge twists into a social media bonfire. And Showtime’s statement did little to defuse it, indicating that the parting of ways had been a mutual decision by all parties. Ultimately, per Showtime, it had been agreed that “the most powerful creative decision would be to end Alison’s arc at the moment when she had finally achieved self-empowerment.”

Something isn’t adding up. What’s the truth here? Was it Wilson’s decision solely, or was it a mutual one? What exactly is Wilson prevented from telling us?

All this nebulousness makes Wilson seem like a victim of something. She may well have been aware that by citing strictures against speaking freely, she’d call to many viewers’ minds just how much Hollywood misbehavior was until recently papered over by actresses signing non-disclosure agreements. Or she may just be deflecting a conversation she’d prefer not to have, unwittingly making it worse. Either way, Showtime is learning that once a performer is no longer in your employ, they owe you nothing, as Wilson is, intentionally or not, fueling the sense she was, somehow, treated nefariously.

The irony of this affair over “The Affair” is that it mirrors the show itself; as a drama that relies on fractured perspectives, it’s created a drama of fractured perspectives. What to Wilson may have been an innocuous conversation-ender is to the commentariat online the start of what could become years’ worth of feverish speculation. And what may have seemed to her like a proactive decision to quit may have seemed to the network like a truly mutual agreement. Perhaps the rest of the cast and Treem will soon find a way to merge the two sketchy narratives. In an age where openness and frankness, within limits, is generally accepted, ambiguity has the tendency to tarnish shows as it festers.

More TV

  • CBS

    CBS Entertainment Pledges to Audition Actors with Disabilities

    CBS Entertainment has signed the Ruderman Family Foundation’s Audition Pledge, a commitment to audition actors with disabilities for new productions picked up to series. The company, which includes CBS Television Studios and CBS All Access, is the first in the industry to respond to the advocacy organization’s request for increased disabled representation. “We take pride [...]

  • Rob Ortiz Brian Agboh Julie Katchen

    Paramount TV Names Three New Hires To Executive Team

    Paramount Television has made three new hires for its executive leadership team, naming Rob Ortiz as its new senior vice president of physical production, Brian Agboh as senior vice president of business affairs, and Julie Katchen Swidler as director of Paramount TV’s newly created current team. “I’m so excited to welcome these new valuable executives [...]

  • Discovery Corporate New Logo

    Discovery, FuboTV Strike Distribution Pact

     Discovery, Inc. and FuboTV said they have struck a multi-year deal that brings 13 of the cable-programmer’s networks to Fubo’s live-TV streaming service in coming weeks. The agreement extends a relationship that had been in place between Fubo and the former Scripps Networks Interactive, which Discovery acquired in 2018. That pact included carriage of five [...]

  • Rosamund Pike A Private War

    Rosamund Pike to Lead ‘Wheel of Time’ TV Adaptation at Amazon

    The long-gestating “Wheel of Time” TV adaptation has finally found its lead. Rosamund Pike cast been cast as Moiraine, a member of the powerful all-female organization called the Aes Sedai, in the Amazon Studios and Sony Pictures Television co-production. Based on Robert Jordan’s best-selling fantasy novels, “The Wheel of Time” is set in a high [...]

  • Julie Andrews

    Julie Andrews Joins Shondaland's Bridgerton Netflix Series

    Julie Andrews is the first person officially cast in one of Shonda Rhimes’ upcoming Netflix shows. Andrews has joined the untitled series based on Julia Quinn’s Bridgerton family novels. She will voice the character Lady Whistledown. Anonymous to readers, the sharp-tongued gossip writer uses a curious mix of social commentary and scathing insult to send [...]

  • Riverdale Alladin Avengers Endgame

    'Avengers: Endgame,' 'Riverdale,' 'Aladdin' Top 2019 Teen Choice Award Nominations

    The nominations for the 2019 Teen Choice Awards have been revealed, and voting has opened for the top movies, TV shows and music that has dominated the last year. “Avengers: Endgame” and “Aladdin” are the top contenders in the movie category with nine and five nods, respectively. In TV, “Riverdale,” “The Flash” and “Shadowhunters” each [...]

  • Chilevisión, RTVE, Boomerang, Amazon Share ‘Inés

    ‘Inés of My Soul’s’ Production Details, Shoot Date Unveiled at Conecta Fiction

    PAMPLONA, Spain — A project pitched three years ago at the very first Conecta Fiction in the Galician city of Santiago de Compostela, “Ines of My Soul” was back at the international co-pro and networking summit, this year in Pamplona, where it was held up as one of the still-young event’s most significant success stories. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content