Golden Globes 2018: The Year of the White Women (Column)

There’s no greater bellwether of the mood in Hollywood than the Hollywood Foreign Press, and this year, its members are saying it’s time to make way for women. It was likely to be a woman-centric year anyway, following Hillary Clinton’s loss in the presidential election and the installment of President Trump. But with the rolling wave of sexual harassment and assault allegations cresting through Hollywood, the media and Congress, the gender dynamics of the nominees seem more pointed than ever.

For Emmy-winning series “The Handmaid’s Tale,” in which women are marked possessions, the patriarchal dystopia of Offred’s (Elisabeth Moss) world seemed to anticipate the horror we have all felt upon learning about Harvey Weinstein’s chokehold on the women around him in the entertainment industry. But maybe more importantly, that dystopia isn’t just happening in that one specific area; it is all around us. The past few months have been those of reckoning for Hollywood, which often — especially in awards season — holds itself up as a beacon of progressivism and inclusion. But with more and more stories appearing of long-hidden misconduct coinciding with awards season, it’s not surprising that the noms feel like they are compensating for bad news; as if Hollywood is trying to assert that despite the headlines, there are good people comprising a good industry that makes good, forward-thinking, accepting works of art.

So, the nominations are flooded with women, in what is almost a parody of Netflix’s infamous recommendation for more stories with “strong female leads.” Several of the nommed stories showcase violence against women, whether that is in the privileged enclaves of HBO’s “Big Little Lies” or the widespread regime of Hulu’s “Handmaid’s Tale.” Both present women at very different levels of privilege, but with intimate challenges and victories that surround children, family and the domestic sphere. Offred and Celeste (Nicole Kidman), both Emmy winners, are abused survivors — both chained to brutally violent men who pursue them sexually, both trying to find a way to press that precarious position to their advantage.

Showtime’s “Twin Peaks: The Return,” from auteur David Lynch, is a show founded on the murder of one woman, whose haunting scream in the final seconds cracks through the firmament of the show’s more superficial appeal. Stories such as FX’s “Feud: Bette and Joan” and USA’s “The Sinner” emphasize systemic disadvantages against women, while also showcasing meaty performances by Susan Sarandon, Jessica Lange, and Jessica Biel, playing suffering, flawed women.

Then there are the Clinton surrogates — the stories about women in leadership positions being thwarted by existing power structures, including Queen Elizabeth II (Claire Foy) in “The Crown.” Even, arguably, the film nominee “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri,” about a disliked middle-age woman trying to effect change in her community, has traces of grappling with the Clinton phenomenon: Frances McDormand’s character is unlikeable, and “likability,” as a construct, has proven to be an enormously gendered one in 2017.

And perhaps most relevant, there are several nominated stories about women who present themselves as figures of consumption for an audience — whether that is the sex workers of HBO’s “The Deuce,” who strut on 42nd Street, or the costumed wrestlers of Jenji Kohan’s “GLOW,” on Netflix. “GLOW,” like film nominee “I, Tonya” and the aforementioned “Feud,” examine media representation of female rivalries — exploring not just the real-life dynamics of these easily dramatized relationships, but also why the viewing audience so desperately wants to witness such a competitive dynamic. Even “Battle of the Sexes,” for which Steve Carell was nominated for comedy actor and Emma Stone for comedy actress, examines the dynamics of gender rivalry, albeit from the perspective of pitting men directly against women.

The focus on gender inequality is so pronounced that even seemingly such unrelated films as “The Post” are, in fact, saturated with observations about gender dynamics. Those that aren’t focused on gender, including film nominees “Dunkirk” and “The Greatest Showman” and TV nominees “This Is Us” and “Stranger Things,” seem like tales from a different era.

But the focus on gender representation does come at the expense of what had until recently been the focus of the big Hollywood award shows — racial representation, as popularized in the hashtagged movement #OscarsSoWhite. A few years ago, the racial dynamics of awards shows were front-and-center; now that conversation has taken a backseat to the revelation that misogyny is alive and well in Hollywood. As a result, women may dominate the stories, but they are mostly white women — whether that is Saoirse Ronan’s charming misfit lead in Greta Gerwig’s “Lady Bird,” or the leads of Jane Campion’s moody second installment of “Top of the Lake: China Girl.” Only one TV nominee (“Insecure’s” Issa Rae) is a woman of color, though things are slightly more inclusive when looking at film’s supporting actress category: Octavia Spencer, Mary J. Blige and Hong Chau take three of the five spots.

It’s strange: Performances from such actresses as Foy, Moss, Kidman, Maggie Gyllenhaal and Margot Robbie have captivated Hollywood this year, marking the female performers more captivating and projecting a sense of more timely significance than their male counterparts. But these performers are all white, and though it is wonderful to embrace talented female performers, it is difficult to reconcile their homogeneity with the desperate need for representation across the board in Hollywood. Trailblazing white women are a great place to start, but one hopes that the Hollywood Foreign Press will not stop here.

More TV

  • monty-python-are-fifty-in-2019

    Previously Unreleased Monty Python Audio to Get Airing for Troupe's 50th Anniversary

    Michael Palin will exec-produce series of radio specials containing never-before-released audio from Monty Python as part of the 50th anniversary celebrations for the iconic comedy troupe. They will play on the BBC in the U.K. and then go out in the U.S. Palin and his fellow Pythons – John Cleese, Terry Gilliam, Eric Idle, Terry [...]

  • TV News Hopes NBC's Democrat Debate

    TV News Hopes NBC's Democrat Debate Spurs More Than a Political Windfall

    NBC News is gearing up to cover two sprawling Democratic debates. But the trappings around them may remind viewers of another network staple: “Sunday Night Football.” NBCUniversal will televise debates among the Democratic candidates for U.S. presidency over two nights and across three different TV networks, as well as via host of digital venues, including [...]

  • Netflix’s ‘Undercover’ Gets New Season With

    Netflix’s ‘Undercover’ Gets Second Season, With a Story on Illegal Arms Sales

    A second season of Netflix’s first Benelux original, “Undercover,” is in production, and the story will move from focusing on the illicit drugs trade to the illegal arms business. Non-English-language drama is finding a global audience on streaming platforms, and “Undercover” has ranked as one of Netflix’s most popular series in that category in the [...]

  • Hasan Minhaj

    Nahnatchka Khan, Hasan Minhaj, 'Just Mercy' Cast Talk Inclusion

    “Always Be My Maybe” was “satisfying” to create because it gave focus to two characters that wouldn’t typically be portrayed as romantic leads, said director Nahnatchka Khan of her Netflix film at the CAA Amplify conference in Ojai, sitting on a panel with comedian Hasan Minhaj and NBA star Chris Paul. “We’re all big fans [...]

  • Ridley Scott DGA lifetime achievement award

    Netflix Adds Sion Sono, Ridley Scott and ‘Grudge’ Films to Japan Originals Slate

    Netflix unveiled its lineup of original programming from Japan. It includes major local and international names. Among the most highly anticipated entries is “Ai-naki Mori de Sakebe” (literal translation: Shout in the Loveless Forest), a three-part series inspired by a real multiple murder case set to stream this summer. The director is international cult favorite [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content