×

Emmys Best Drama: Five Second-Season Returnees All Got Better This Past Year

Last year, the Emmy Best Drama field was filled with brand-new nominees — five first-season shows, among them Netflix’s “The Crown” and “Stranger Things,” HBO’s “Westworld,” NBC’s “Stranger Things,” and the eventual winner, Hulu’s “The Handmaid’s Tale,” made the cut. It was a marker of a particularly dynamic year in TV, one in which dominant player “Game of Thrones” was ineligible, other old standbys had begun to fade away, and a slew of diverse new shows, from period drama to mindbending sci-fi to dystopian drama, made their mark.

This year? They’re all back. The five new shows from last year make up a slate very heavy on second seasons, along with older shows “The Americans” (nominated for its sixth and final season) and “Game of Thrones” (in its seventh appearance). It’s a logjam that means that for the first time since 2009, when the second season of “Mad Men” took the prize, no new drama is in contention for TV’s top prize.

To be sure, there were few credible new contenders. Other nominations picked up by Netflix’s “Ozark” — two directing nominations, and a Best Actor nod for Jason Bateman — suggest it might have found its way in had another series faltered. I’d have preferred mention for Netflix’s “Mindhunter” or HBO’s “The Deuce,” but both shows seemed widely forgotten by the time nomination voting had happened.

And not only were there few new shows with the profiles of Best Drama nominees, none of the returning series missed a beat in their second seasons. The “sophomore slump” is nothing new in television, but each of the five returning series became a deeper and more fully realized version of itself in its second outing. “This Is Us” moved towards more complex understanding of even the characters who’d at first been sketchily drawn, while keeping the flagrant heart-tugging fans love. The congenitally cold-blooded “The Crown” stayed obsessed with regal power while beginning to ask more seriously just how it harms those who wield it. “The Handmaid’s Tale,” no more rockily than in its first outing, built out Gilead effectively and showed us precisely what complicity looks like through the monstrously effective Serena Joy plotline. “Stranger Things” managed to keep its sensation status alive by deepening its mythology and upping its spectacle. And “Westworld” became, for my money, among the best TV shows of our era, and the one that’s doing the most potent job of showing what it’s like to live through times of seismic change.

Any of these shows could have fallen off, or, at least, have lost its favor with Emmy. (In recent memory, the awards blanked “The Americans” for its slower fifth season just after welcoming the show in for season 4; it also didn’t nominate “Mr. Robot” for Best Drama again after its breakout first season.) The law of averages suggests at least one ought to have done so. While the outcome, an all-returnee field with five shows that debuted together last year, lacks the buzzy excitement of lots of moving parts, it’s a testament to the focused power of TV at its best — that we can assume the greatest of what’s on TV will continue to grow in power rather than losing its nerve or going down a blind alley. All five season 2 shows in the Best Drama race took big risks this past year; all five trusted their audiences to follow, and all five were rewarded. The field lacks novelty, but it’s proof of what TV at its best can do—reward our year-in and year-out attention by building on itself, counting on viewers (awards voters or no) to stay along for the ride. At least a couple of them, surely, will still be getting nominated when they’re as far into their runs as “The Americans” and “Game of Thrones”; I’m eager to see in what bold place they’ve ended up by then.

More TV

  • Harley Quinn DC Universe

    4 Things We Learned at TCA 2019: Day 1

    The 2019 Television Critics Association summer press tour kicked off on Tuesday with presentations from DC Universe, A+E Networks, and Nat Geo. DC Universe, the DC-branded streaming service, brought their adult animated series based on “Harley Quinn,” while A+E brought along a range of projects from across their portfolio. It was also announced that A+E [...]

  • The Boys Amazon Prime

    TV News Roundup: Amazon Drops 'The Boys' Final Trailer (Watch)

    In today’s roundup, USA releases the trailer for the second season of “The Purge” and Amazon drops the final trailer before “The Boys” launches.  RENEWALS Viceland has renewed the pro wrestling docu-series “Dark Side of the Ring” for a second season. The upcoming season will feature 10 hour-long episodes chronicling the lives of wrestlers inside [...]

  • WGA West Logo

    WGA West Unveils Candidates for Election That Reflects Discord Over Agency Campaign

    The WGA West has unveiled the slate of candidates for officer posts and board seats in the election that reflects the divisions among members over the guild’s handling of the campaign to reform its rules governing talent agents. Scribes Phyllis Nagy (“Carol”) and William Schmidt (“Yellowstone”) are set to challenge David Goodman for the president’s [...]

  • The Code CBS

    'The Code' Canceled After One Season on CBS

    Freshman military drama “The Code” is officially done at CBS. The news comes just one day after the show’s season finale, which will now serve as the show’s series finale. “Thank you to all you wonderful people who watched [‘The Code’],” series star Dana Delany wrote on Twitter. “Last night was our finale and sadly, [...]

  • Matt Tolmach'Venom' film premiere, Arrivals, Los

    Amazon to Develop Human IPO Series With Matt Tolmach Producing

    Amazon is developing a series inspired by the true story of a man who sold shares of himself to investors, Variety has learned. In a competitive situation, Amazon has landed the project, titled “JNNA.” It is described as a half-hour comedy about the next big investment craze — humans. It is inspired by Mike Merrill, [...]

  • Olympics

    NBCUniversal Projects More Than $1.2 Billion in Ad Sales for 2020 Olympics

    NBCUniversal projected it would sell more than $1.2 billion in advertising for its 17 days of broadcasts of the 2020 Olympics from Tokyo, citing the event as a rare opportunity for Madison Avenue to reach big audiences without the worry of politics getting in the way of a commercial message. The Olympics is “one of [...]

  • R Kelly Sexual Assult Accusations Mugshot

    'Surviving R. Kelly' Follow Up, Jeffrey Epstein Docuseries in the Works at Lifetime

    Lifetime is working on a follow up to the hit docuseries “Surviving R. Kelly” and a new docuseries about Jeffrey Epstein. Rob Sharenow, president of programming for A+E Networks, made the announcements at the Television Critics Association summer press tour on Tuesday. “The Aftermath” will be a four-part series featuring interviews with new survivors, psychologists, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content