You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Why ‘American Horror Story’ Should End This Season (Column)

This season has been a snappy, sharp return to form for FX’s “American Horror Story.” Which is exactly why the show should end.

It’s nice to go out on a high — and “Apocalypse,” the eighth installment and an imaginative comeback after the shoddily made “Cult” season, is certainly that. But at a moment at which “Horror Story” maestro Ryan Murphy has stepped away from FX, the show seems coincidentally enough to have reached a completion of its vision. “Apocalypse” doesn’t just bring together disparate beloved corners of the show’s mythology, from its first-season “Murder House” to the witches of fan favorite season “Coven”; it depicts the literal end of the world. Where can a story go from there?

From its earliest moments — a premiere depicting the fall of civilization and generating, for the first time in at least a season, genuine terror and not just campy spookiness — “Apocalypse” was evidently doing something different. Weaker recent seasons had sought to recreate past success with diminishing returns; “Apocalypse” featured both a compelling new villain in the form of the son of Satan (a magnetic Cody Fern) and remixed the show’s own history in intriguing ways. Characters had returned before, but never at such length or with as much depth. Even if the intent hadn’t been to give one last look at past favorites before the show wraps, the effect was pleasantly valedictory. We got glances at many characters from the show’s history, and saw where they ended up — with Jessica Lange’s Constance Langdon, for instance, a more-troubled-than-ever prisoner of her own demons. And the show, so often worth criticizing for its manic shifts in attention, here used its lack of focus to bring different past storylines into relief. It was a fitting use of the show’s format, and would provide a fitting goodbye to many characters fans have come to love.

“Apocalypse’s” hairpin turns, depicting first one of the last outposts sustaining the fragile flame of humanity and then delving back in time to show the origin of the end of days and how “Coven’s” witches were involved, turned one of “American Horror Story’s” weaknesses into a great strength. This series has long been both overplotted and feebly structured, throwing tons of ideas into a season and letting them, eventually, wither. By completely resetting the gameboard every few episodes, transforming from a series about cataclysm into a show about that cataclysm’s origins into a “Coven” sequel, “Apocalypse” proved, after a down season, that its scattered approach to storytelling can surprise and delight. 

Viewers knew that, of course, but could be forgiven for having forgotten. It’s been a while since “American Horror Story” burst onto the scene: so long, in fact, that its format, with a repertory company of actors telling entirely new tales each season, felt revolutionary then. (It’s since yielded such franchises as FX’s “Fargo” and ABC’s “American Crime.”) Drawing together its disparate stories into a single narrative — encompassing the witches of “Coven,” the cursed family of “Murder House” and the hellish inn of “Hotel” — is another wild paradigm shift for a show whose inventiveness tends to be a bit underrated by those telling the recent history of television.

Over the course of the season, we’ve caught up meaningfully with the witches of “Coven” and seen how Cordelia (Sarah Paulson) exists in her capacity as a leader: Her loyalty to the sorceresses under her easily becomes fecklessness when faced with real evil. We’ve returned to where the show began in “Murder House.” And we’ve enjoyed a story that, skittering between Murphy preoccupations, ends where all stories, carried to their absolute conclusion, must: With everyone dying. Every horror story has to end somewhere; particularly scary ones find the end of life on earth and the ascension of Satan an apt place to stop. What better time to close the curtain on an era of television, and to look ahead to what Murphy will innovate next?

More TV

  • New England Patriots running back Sony

    CBS and Fox Cheer Big Turnout for NFL Conference Championships

    Sunday’s AFC and NFC championship games were nail-biters that went into overtime and sent viewership into overdrive. CBS harvested a whopping 53.9 million viewers as New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady led his team to their third consecutive Super Bowl berth in a hard-fought primetime game against the Kansas City Chiefs. Viewership for the AFC [...]

  • RENT: Top L-R to Bottom L-R:

    TV Shows to Watch the Week of Jan. 21, 2019: 'Rent,' 'Celebrity Big Brother'

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “Rent: Live” airs on Fox and “Celebrity Big Brother” returns for a second [...]

  • Black Monday: How Showtime Dusted Off

    'Black Monday': How Showtime Dusted Off An Old '80s Logo For Its New Comedy

    Cocaine’s a hell of a drug, but you’re not seeing things: That, indeed is Showtime’s old 1980s-era logo pasted all over marketing materials and promos for “Black Monday,” a tongue-in-cheek tale of the excesses exhibited by Wall Street traders in the lead-up to the stock market crash of 1987. The logo, which hasn’t been in [...]

  • 'Russian Doll' Review

    TV Review: 'Russian Doll'

    This is a particularly tricky review to write, but not because the merits of “Russian Doll” are at all ambiguous. On the contrary, the show is so striking and smart that I made a note to include it on my favorite TV shows of 2019 immediately after blowing through the season — which is saying [...]

  • Black Earth Rising Review

    TV Review: 'Black Earth Rising'

    Bringing to bear a talented cast on a story of real geopolitical significance, “Black Earth Rising,” Netflix’s drama about the long-tail aftermath of the Rwandan genocide, would seem to have had the potential to be one of 2019’s early television successes. Which makes its falling short all the more painful and pronounced. The show, previously [...]

  • DIRTY JOHN -- "This Young Woman

    'Dirty John' Finale Hits New Ratings Highs in Live+3

    The Season 1 finale of “Dirty John” on Bravo continued the scripted show’s ratings hot streak in Live+3. The finale, which aired on Jan. 13, grew to 3.3 million viewers in delayed viewing with 1.3 million of those falling in the key adults 18-49 demographic. That is up 10% in total viewers and 15% in [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content