You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Emmy Awards: Why Rules Were Made to Be Broken (Column)

For years, the Emmy Awards stuck stubbornly to their old favorites: The same shows would get nominated year over year, much to everyone’s frustration.

But then two things happened: Peak TV exploded, and the voting rules changed. And suddenly, the only thing you could count on was not being able to count on anything. With 9100 submissions across over 120 categories, it’s become nearly impossible to offer any sense of predictability to the nominations.

As always, this year’s list offered the usual array of snubs and surprises, which Emmy prognosticators — Variety included — dutifully weighed in on. But the main takeaway from the nominations is simply this: rules are made to broken, which is a very good thing.

Star power matters — until it doesn’t.

In the past, the surest way to land a nomination — not to mention the trophy itself — was for an established male movie actor to star in an HBO movie. Witness: Al Pacino (“Angels in America,” “You Don’t Know Jack”), Geoffrey Rush (“The Life and Death of Peter Sellers”), Michael Douglas (“Behind the Candelabra”), Paul Giamatti (“John Adams”).

But Pacino didn’t make the cut this time out for a role that was prime Emmy bait: embodying the embattled Paterno in HBO’s film.

Yet that ephemeral fairy dust of star power worked its magic for other high-profile actors, including Antonio Banderas, who scored for NatGeo’s “Genius,” and John Legend, who’s now in contention for an EGOT for “Jesus Christ Superstar: Live.”

Ensembles matter — until they don’t.

Voters went deep on shows they loved — showering series like “The Handmaid’s Tale” with 20 noms overall and eight for its actors, including the surprise recognition of Kelly Jenrette, who played Luke’s ex-wife. Ditto “Westworld,” whose 21 nominations folded in 5 acting nods and “The Assassination of Gianni Versace,” which scored 18 overall and 6 for its cast. Those casting sweeps mean that co-stars will be vying against each other in many of those races.

Yet inexplicably that love didn’t extend as deeply to the other series that Emmy fawned over: Somehow among “Game of Thrones” 22 nominations only three actors made the cut — snubbing series leads (and audience favorites) Emilia Clarke and Kit Harington (perhaps it was their jump from supporting to lead?).  And while four of “This Is Us'” nods came from the acting categories, somehow the women of the cast escaped the notice of voters — notably Mandy Moore and Chrissy Metz, key members of the show’s ensemble. “GLOW” is competing for best comedy series without its lead actress in contention (Alison Brie), as is “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” (Ellie Kemper).

Timing matters — until it doesn’t.

Given the glut of programming, voters could be forgiven for forgetting those series that aired last summer at the start of the eligibility window, in favor of those that piled up in March and April. That spring timing certainly benefited series like “Killing Eve,” which scored a nod for star Sandra Oh, and HBO’s movie “The Tale,” which snuck in just under the wire. And while it’s the first season of “GLOW” that’s in contention, coverage of the second season, which dropped June 29, kept it top of mind for voters.

Yet voters proved they can remember what matters to them: Tatiana Maslany wrapped her run as the star of “Orphan Black” last June, yet the winner of the Emmy in 2016 is back in contention to defend her trophy. “Insecure” aired its second season last July, yet Issa Rae broke into the acting race.

History matters — until it doesn’t.

Consistency has been the hobgoblin of Emmy voters, who’ve rewarded the same shows year after year. Consider the reality races, which — but for the addition of “Queer Eye” — are virtually the same slate as in years past.

The talk series category was long a victim of a similar problem, making it impossible for new, more relevant series to break through.

Yet this year there was a shakeup: For the first time since 1995, Bill Maher did not earn an Emmy nomination for his onscreen work, whether for “Politically Correct” or “Real Time with Bill Maher.” “Modern Family,” which has been nommed every season since its debut, didn’t make the cut in the comedy series race. And Emmy favorites Jon Voight and Liev Schreiber fell out of favor for their work on “Ray Donovan,”

There was no consistency among voters when it came to reboots and revivals, TV’s trend du jour. Of course, we all know why “Roseanne” didn’t make the cut — with the notable exception of awards favorite Laurie Metcalfe, but while voters warmed to Larry David’s latest iteration of “Curb Your Enthusiasm” they also cooled to “Will & Grace,” which had been an Emmy darling in its first run, as well as David Lynch’s “Twin Peaks.”

Netflix matters — until it doesn’t.

The day of the nominations, countless headlines (again, Variety included) trumpeted the success of Netflix, which had dethroned longtime king HBO atop the leaderboard of Emmy nominations, after a nearly two-decade long run. And while the spread was only 4 nominations, the symbolic victory heralded the triumph of streaming services. And to be sure, Netflix’s deep bench of content — spread across nearly every category in the race — fueled its success. Those 112 nominations were spread out across 40 series: Yes, even “Fuller House” got a nod, now competing as a children’s program.

But the millions spent by Netflix didn’t guarantee noms for all of its contenders. “Mindhunter,” the critically adored thriller from David Fincher, scored just one nom for guest star Cameron Britton; “One Day at a Time” also landed just one nod (for editing), as did “Alias Grace” (for dramatic score).

But the Netflix effect wasn’t just limited to its own originals: That magical algorithm and user-friendly interface also brought attention to some of its acquired series. One of the most celebrated surprises of Emmy morning was the recognition of Ted Danson, for his work on “The Good Place.” Insiders credit the debut of “The Good Place” on Netflix with finally bringing Mike Schur’s celebrated comedy — now in its second season — to the attention of Emmy voters.


More TV

  • Jussie Smollett

    Jussie Smollett's Bail Set at $100,000, Must Surrender Passport

    A Chicago judge set a $100,000 bond for Jussie Smollett on Thursday, as the “Empire” actor made his first court appearance. Smollett faces one felony count of filing a false police report. Police allege that Smollett staged a Jan. 29 attack, telling detectives that he was accosted by two men who used racial and homophobic [...]

  • Michael Jackson Estate Accuses HBO of

    Michael Jackson Estate Sues HBO for Non-Disparagement Contract Breach

    The estate of Michael Jackson sued HBO on Thursday, accusing the cable channel of violating a non-disparagement clause by agreeing to run “Leaving Neverland,” a documentary accusing Jackson of sexual abuse. The suit seeks to compel HBO to litigate the matter in a public arbitration process, and claims that the estate could be awarded $100 [...]

  • Jussie Smollett Hoax: Robin Roberts Calls

    Robin Roberts Calls Jussie Smollett Hoax a 'Setback For Race Relations'

    A week after her candid interview with Jussie Smollett about the actor’s alleged attack, “Good Morning America” host Robin Roberts has reacted to news of Smollett’s arrest. In a turn of events, Smollett was taken into police custody Thursday and is being charged with filing a false police report. “This touches all the buttons,” Roberts said [...]

  • Mindy Kaling Kate Spade

    Mindy Kaling Exits Universal for New Overall Deal at Warner Bros. TV

    Mindy Kaling is departing Universal Television after more than a decade at the studio. The “Mindy Project” creator has signed a new six-year overall deal at Warner Bros. Television. Under the deal, Kaling will develop, write and produce new television projects for all platforms, including broadcast, cable channels, and streaming. According to sources, Kaling stands [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Celebrities, Politicians React to Jussie Smollett Arrest: 'This Story Is Pathetic'

    Following the arrest of Jussie Smollett on Thursday, with the “Empire” star facing charges of filing a false police report and disorderly conduct after allegedly staging an attack, celebrities and politicians were quick to weigh in on social media. President Donald Trump tweeted Thursday morning, “What about MAGA and the tens of millions of people [...]

  • Shelby Shaftel

    NBC Names Shelby Shaftel Senior VP of Alternative Programming and Development

    Shelby Shaftel has been promoted to senior vice president of alternative programming and development at NBC. There, as part of her position, she will oversee projects from concept through post-production and direct creative, staffing decisions, talent, marketing and high-level brand partnerships. Among the shows she currently oversees are “The Titan Games,” “Making It,” and “The [...]

  • Jennifer Lopez

    Jennifer Lopez Joins TikTok App to Promote NBC's 'World of Dance'

    Jennifer Lopez is the latest celebrity to hop on TikTok, the short-form video app owned by Chinese internet giant ByteDance — more proof of the app’s growing traction, and reflective of media companies’ desire to reach its young-skewing base. Lopez had a very specific aim: to get fans excited about “World of Dance,” the NBC [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content