×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Appeals Court Questions Why FCC Revived UHF Discount Rule

WASHINGTON — A panel of appellate judges questioned why the FCC reinstated a rule that allows media companies to amass a greater number of stations and still fall within ownership limits.

Sinclair Broadcast Group has counted on the provision — known as the UHF discount — to secure regulatory approval for its proposed acquisition of Tribune Media. Just weeks after the FCC’s action, Sinclair announced the $3.9 billion merger, which would give it a station group covering about 72% of the country.

Sinclair’s stock price fell 3.92% to close at $29.40 on the NASDAQ exchange.

The three judges on the DC Circuit Court of Appeals panel raised some concerns about the rationale behind the FCC’s decision in April, 2017, to reinstate the UHF discount after abolishing it a year earlier.

The rule allows station groups to discount their UHF holdings by half. That has allowed major station groups to acquire many more stations and still fall within a national ownership cap, which is 39%.

Judges Patricia Millett and Cornelia Pillard also expressed concerns that the FCC had restored a rule that is considered obsolete.

The discount was established in the 1980s to account for the lesser quality and reach of UHF stations. But those differences disappeared as stations got placement on cable and satellite lineups and, later, in the transition to digital television.

The FCC shifted from a Democratic to Republican majority in 2017, and current FCC Chairman Ajit Pai argued that the rule should be reinstated until the agency can also consider changes to the national ownership cap. The FCC voted 2-1 to restore the UHF discount.

The agency has since started a proceeding to examine the 39% ownership cap and the UHF discount.

Judge Gregory Katsas noted to the FCC’s attorney, James Carr, that while the FCC “might want to raise the cap,” there was “no reason for thinking at that the end of the day, part of the solution will be keeping the discount.”

“I think that is probably fair, your honor,” Carr replied. He argued that the UHF discount shouldn’t be eliminated without considering its implications to the 39% cap.

The challenge to the FCC’s action was brought by public interest groups,  including Free Press, Common Cause, and the National Hispanic Media Coalition, represented by Andrew Jay Schwartzman, challenged the FCC’s reinstatement of the discount.

The judges did have questions about the standing of the plaintiffs. Schwartzman was asked whether he would object to filing a supplemental declaration in case they found a lack of standing, and he replied, “Absolutely not, your honor.”

An FCC spokeswoman had no comment.

Chris Ruddy, the CEO of Newsmax, who has been highly critical of the FCC’s action, as well as of the Sinclair-Tribune merger, said in a statement that “the judges on the DC Circuit reviewing the FCC’s UHF discount were left scratching their heads wondering why the rule was re-instated when everyone — Republicans and Democrats alike — agree that the discount is an analog relic and makes no sense in a digital world.

“The FCC should avoid the appearance of impropriety and proceed with a transparent national ownership cap proceeding to set a level playing field before approving any merger that benefits just one company, namely Sinclair.”

A spokeswoman for Sinclair did not immediately return a request for comment.

More Politics

  • Sarah Huckabee Sanders Jemele Hill

    Sarah Huckabee Sanders to Leave the White House

    White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders is leaving her position at the end of the month, President Donald Trump said Thursday. In two tweets, Trump announced Sanders’ departure for her home state of Arkansas before thanking her for “a job well done.” He also recommended her for the Arkansas governor position, writing, “She is [...]

  • Kellyanne Conway

    Federal Watchdog Says Kellyanne Conway Should Step Down

    A federal watchdog has recommended that White House counselor Kellyanne Conway should be fired for repeated violations of the Hatch Act. In a report on Thursday, the U.S. Office of Special Counsel found that Conway had used TV appearances and social media platforms to disparage Democratic presidential candidates while speaking in her official capacity. “Ms. [...]

  • Jessica Biel Clarifies Anti-Vaccine Stance

    Jessica Biel: 'I Am Not Against Vaccinations'

    Jessica Biel clarified her stance on vaccinations after public outcry over news that the actress joined Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to lobby against a California state pro-vaccine bill. “I am not against vaccinations,” Biel wrote on Instagram Thursday morning. “I support children getting vaccinations and I also support families having the right to make educated [...]

  • 'The Sinner' film premiere

    Jessica Biel Joins Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to Lobby Against California Vaccine Bill

    Jessica Biel joined the controversial anti-vaccination advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to lobby against a California state pro-vaccine bill on Tuesday, revealed in several social media posts. “Please say thank you to the courageous @jessicabiel for a busy and productive day at the California State House,” Kennedy posted on Tuesday with a series of pictures [...]

  • Hope Hicks Resigns

    Hope Hicks to Give Closed-Door Testimony to Judiciary Committee

    Hope Hicks, the chief communications officer at Fox, has agreed to answer questions before the House Judiciary Committee next week. The hearing will be held behind closed doors, but the committee will make a transcript available afterward. The committee is continuing to follow up on the report of Special Counsel Robert Mueller. Hicks is set [...]

  • Michael Wolff Fire and Fury

    5 Takeaways From Michael Wolff's 'Siege: Trump Under Fire'

    Michael Wolff’s “Siege: Trump Under Fire” looks at the 45th president’s second year in office, detailing everything from a potential indictment to Melania Trump’s mysterious hospitalization. It’s the follow-up to Wolff’s “Fire and Fury,” and though this installment likely won’t reach the commercial heights of its predecessor, it’s certainly not lacking in titillating reveals. Several [...]

  • Donald Trump

    Trump Says His Meghan Markle ‘Nasty’ Comment Was Taken Out of Context

    After first denying he made the comment, President Trump now says his remark describing Meghan Markle as “nasty” was taken out of context, telling Piers Morgan instead that he thinks the Duchess of Sussex is actually “very nice.” Trump called Markle “nasty” in an interview with British tabloid The Sun ahead of his three-day state [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content