You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Facebook, Twitter Will Face GOP Questions of Political Bias at Congressional Hearings

Twitter’s Jack Dorsey and Facebook’s Sheryl Sandberg are scheduled to appear on Capitol Hill on Wednesday, and it’s not too difficult to figure out what they should expect from Republican lawmakers: claims of political bias in their algorithms.

In defense of the Silicon Valley titans, there’s no real evidence to back up such claims, whether they be President Trump’s attacks on big tech platforms as “unfair” in trying to suppress conservative voices, or congressional Republicans who offer individual anecdotes to try to make the case that there is some sort of systemic problem.

To the detriment of the internet giants, though, is the fact that the way algorithms work can be hard to explain and easy to be misunderstood.

“This gets back to the fact that they do have these algorithms that control what you see and what you don’t see, and the algorithms are secret,” says David Chavern, the president and CEO of the News Media Alliance, which represents the newspaper industry.

“As long as you have secret rules of what you see and don’t see, people are going to say the rules are biased.”

Popular on Variety

Tech companies keep their algorithms secret for competitive reasons, but their lack of transparency has led to a plethora of alternative, and often incorrect, explanations.

A 2016 study authored by researchers from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign found that Facebook users frequently develop and share their own unverified “folk theories” about the signals Facebook uses to curate its newsfeed.

In fact, Facebook users frequently utilize these theories in their interactions with the service in order to manipulate the company’s algorithms. For instance, they will “like” posts they’re not really interested in just to get to see more content of a certain user. “In other words, they were forced to deceive the algorithm by changing their behavior,” the researchers wrote.

Trying to outsmart Facebook’s algorithm may be relatively harmless, but the opacity that makes users develop these theories also has some suspecting that Facebook uses their phone to listen to everything they say — something the company has vehemently denied — or that Google suppresses conservative sources in search results.

The internet industry has tried to push back against these claims by arguing that it is a matter of simple common sense.

Michael Beckerman, the president of the Internet Association, which represents major Silicon Valley companies, is a conservative who has spent decades working in Republican politics, but “it’s clear to me and to most people that there is not political bias in search and there is not political bias on social media.”

“Conservative voices are now more prominent than ever because of social media,” he says. “Online platforms offer the most open and accessible form of communication for all Americans. The platforms themselves don’t have a political ideology, and it is counter to business interests of the companies to stifle the speech of half their customers.”

One solution suggested by the authors of the University of Illinois study is to introduce more obvious clues into tech products, even if that may make those products less polished.

The flip side of that approach is that the increased transparency can also encourage abuse. Companies like Google have gotten pretty good about preventing search result manipulations, but they still frequently fall prey to other forms of misuse. Just last week, someone was able to rename New York to “Jewtopolis” in Snapchat’s and the Weather Channel’s mobile apps by duping a third-party data source.

It’s also important to remember that the congressional scrutiny over the past year was triggered largely by a bevy of concerns like privacy, data manipulation, and, most of all, Russian-linked use of web platforms in the 2016 election and up to the present day.

Dorsey and Sandberg are scheduled to appear before the Senate Intelligence Committee in the morning, and Dorsey is set for a House Energy and Commerce Committee hearing in the afternoon.

In prepared testimony released by the Energy and Commerce Committee, Dorsey said, “Twitter does not use political ideology to make any decisions, whether related to ranking content on our service or how we enforce our rules. We believe strongly in being impartial, and we strive to enforce our rules impartially.” He added that “from a simple business perspective and to serve the public conversation, Twitter is incentivized to keep all voices on the platform.”

Lawmakers sought an appearance from Google CEO Larry Page, but the company instead offered its chief legal officer, Kent Walker, but that was rejected, sources said.

The scrutiny of Google’s search practices, meanwhile, is not anything new: Content companies and record labels have been hammering tech platforms for years to do more with its algorithm to fight piracy. Trump’s contention that Google, Facebook, and Twitter are in an “antitrust situation” may be misguided in its rationale, but it echoes a longtime policy debate in Washington that existing laws haven’t kept up with the growth of the new players.

At the hearings this week, though, those issues are likely to take a backseat to claims that the system is “rigged,” as Trump calls it.

When Mark Zuckerberg testified in April, there was a lot of focus on those issues, but he was also confronted by Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), who asked why some sites, like a Chick-fil-a Appreciation Day page, were taken down. In fact, Facebook has said that it was a mistake and it was restored within 12 hours.

Since that hearing, though, Republicans’ attacks on tech platforms and claims of bias have only intensified, so there’s every expectation that they will be front and center this week.

“There needs to be policies that promote competition, privacy, and data transparency and algorithmic transparency,” says Gigi Sohn, a former FCC official and now distinguished fellow at the Georgetown Law Institute for Technology Law & Policy. “All this talk about conservative bias is going to be a sideshow.”

More Politics

  • Donald Trump Hollywood Racism

    House Judiciary Committee Votes to Impeach President Trump

    The House Judiciary Committee voted to adopt two articles of impeachment against President Trump on Friday morning, sending the matter to the full House for a vote next week. The articles accuse Trump of abusing his power by pressuring Ukraine to interfere in the 2020 election and of obstructing the impeachment inquiry. Both articles were [...]

  • Boris JohnsonConservative Party rally on eve

    Boris Johnson Is Re-Elected as British Prime Minister, Pledges to Deliver Brexit

    UPDATED: The third general election in Britain in four years has returned former London mayor Boris Johnson as prime minister and given his Conservative Party a commanding majority in Parliament. Johnson campaigned on a promise to finally pull the U.K. out of the European Union after three-and-a-half years of political infighting since Britons voted to [...]

  • Boris Epshteyn

    Sinclair Drops Political Commentary Segments From Boris Epshteyn, Ameshia Cross

    Sinclair Broadcast Group has decided to scrap the political commentary segments that have aired across its vast station group since 2017. Boris Epshteyn, former Trump campaign official turned chief political analyst for Sinclair, has been delivering commentary segments that were mandated to run adjacent to local newscasts on all Sinclair stations since the spring of [...]

  • From left House Speaker Nancy Pelosi,

    House Leadership Unveils Impeachment Articles Against President Trump

    House Democrats unveiled two articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump on Tuesday morning, accusing him of abusing his power and obstructing Congress in its impeachment inquiry. Two committee chairmen — Jerrold Nadler and Adam Schiff — laid out a case that Trump interfered in the 2020 election by pressuring Ukraine to announce an investigation [...]

  • Pete Buttigieg

    Pete Buttigieg to Open Fundraisers to the Press

    Pete Buttigieg will open his fundraisers to the press and will release names of his bundlers within a week, the campaign announced on Monday. Buttigieg made the commitments three after Sen. Elizabeth Warren challenged him to be more transparent about his fundraising. “From the start, Pete has said it is important for every candidate to [...]

  • 2019 Kennedy Center Honoree singer Linda

    Linda Ronstadt to Mike Pompeo: Stop 'Enabling' Donald Trump

    WASHINGTON, D.C. — Linda Ronstadt, one of this year’s Kennedy Center Honorees, had sharp words for Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Saturday night during a State Department reception for the Kennedy Center kudos. Ronstadt and Pompeo faced off in the U.S. State Department’s ornate diplomatic greeting rooms at the traditional event that precedes Sunday’s [...]

  • Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi,

    Nancy Pelosi Announces House Will Proceed With Impeachment

    Speaker Nancy Pelosi announced Thursday morning that the House will proceed with articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump. Pelosi said the impeachment inquiry has shown that Trump abused his power by withholding military aid and a White House meeting from Ukraine in an attempt to pressure the country’s president to announce an investigation into [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content