×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

CNN’s First Legal Threshold in Acosta Case: A Temporary Restraining Order

WASHINGTON — CNN’s lawsuit against the Trump administration will get its first major test on Wednesday, when a federal judge will hold a hearing on whether to grant a temporary restraining order to restore White House correspondent Jim Acosta’s hard pass.

The hearing is scheduled in Washington before U.S. District Judge Timothy J. Kelly, a Trump appointee.

CNN’s lawsuit, filed on Tuesday by a legal team that includes Ted Boutrous and Ted Olson, is drawing support from a number of First Amendment and journalism groups, who see the case’s potential impact on access to the White House and press freedom in general.

In seeking the temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction, CNN has to prove that it is likely to succeed on the merits, and that Acosta is likely to suffer irreparable injury without such immediate relief, among other things.

Media law experts say at the very least, the network has a strong case that procedures were not followed.

Gary Bostwick, a media and First Amendment attorney based in Los Angeles, noted that CNN is not only claiming that Acosta’s First and Fifth Amendment rights were violated, but that the episode also flouted the Administrative Procedure Act. The Secret Service is named as a defendant in the lawsuit, and “they are supposed to give him a hearing and put up evidence,” Bostwick said.

Frequently cited is a 1977 D.C. Circuit opinion in the case of Robert Sherrill, a reporter for the Nation who had been denied a hard pass. The judges ruled that the government had a limited right to deny a media pass, namely for reasons of presidential security, but that procedures had to be in place so that the journalist could have a written explanation of the denial and an opportunity to rebut.

CNN said that didn’t happen. The Trump administration “has never suggested — nor could it suggest in good faith — that Acosta’s presence in the White House briefing room caused ‘concern for the physical security of the President and his family,’ or any other exigent circumstance requiring urgent decision-making,” the network said in its filing.

“It’s obvious that the White House took this action precipitously without giving him any notice or opportunity to respond, much less a written decision based on articulated criteria,” said Douglas E. Mirell, a specialist in the First Amendment for Greenberg Glusker.

CNN is also trying to show that the incident was a “pre-textual and unabashed attempt to censor a report and a network that the President views as one of his critics,” in violation of the First Amendment. In one of its briefs, CNN’s legal team laid out the many instances in which Trump has gone after the network as the “enemy of the people” and “fake news.” The purpose is to show that the President “has been very clear about his antipathy” toward the network and other journalists.

Still, Bostwick noted that this is “not an open-and-shut case where [the government] comes in and tries to shut down a newspaper. This is more attenuated.”

“To be more plain, the First Amendment obviously prohibits the government from gagging someone from speaking, but there are subtle ways of trying to gag someone,” he said. “This is one of the more attenuated ways to stop the press from reporting and giving the news. It is not a direct gagging. It is an indirect ban. ‘We don’t like the way you are covering us.'”

That is more of a challenge to prove than if a government entity tried to shut down a press outlet, Bostwick said.

“They are going to have to go to greater lengths to show that the purpose and the outcome is to stop the freedom of the press,” he said.

Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders, in a statement on Tuesday, noted that CNN already has “nearly 50 additional hard pass holders, and Mr. Acosta is no more or less special than any other media outlet or reporter with respect to the First Amendment.”

“After Mr. Acosta asked the President two questions — each of which the President answered — he physically refused to surrender a White House microphone to an intern, so that other reporters might ask their questions. This was not the first time this reporter has inappropriately refused to yield to other reporters,” she said.

“The White House cannot run an orderly and fair press conference when a reporter acts this way, which is neither appropriate nor professional,” she said.

CNN’s case also outlined the reasons why it is urgent for Acosta to have his credentials restored. He is their chief Washington correspondent and, as he stated in a sworn declaration, “the revocation of my White House press credential not only destroys my ability to perform my current job, it will follow me the rest of my career.”

The network is trying to show that the Trump administration’s explanation for why his credentials were revoked — that he placed his hands on a White House intern in conduct that was “inappropriate” — have shifted.

The video does not show Acosta placing his hands on the intern, but one hand inadvertently touching her arm as she tried to grab the microphone. CNN said the video that Huckabee Sanders sent out of the incident, in which portions are slowed and sped up, “shows that its justification was pre-textual and not in good faith.”

CNN also pointed to what Trump himself has said since the incident, including a remark he made on Friday that there “could be others also” who have their credentials revoked for not “treat[ing] the White House and the Office of the Presidency with respect.”

“I think there’s very little to be lost in pursuing this,” Mirell said. “Indeed, in my view, this is a righteous lawsuit which deserves to be adjudicated in an appropriate way, unless the White House determines that the cost of doing so is outweighed by simply returning the hard pass to Mr. Acosta.”

More Politics

  • Hope Hicks

    Hope Hicks Gives Closed-Door Interview on Mueller Probe

    Hope Hicks appeared at the House Judiciary Committee on Wednesday morning to give closed-door testimony on her involvement in the special counsel investigation of President Trump. The Fox communications chief was subpoenaed in May to provide documents and testimony that would aid in the committee’s investigation into obstruction of justice. After extensive negotiation, Hicks agreed [...]

  • Prince Mohammed bin Salman Abdulaziz al

    Saudi Crown Prince Should Be Investigated Over Khashoggi Killing, U.N. Report Says

    Mohammed bin Salman, the crown prince of Saudi Arabia, should be investigated in connection with the killing of Jamal Khashoggi because of “credible evidence” that the prince is among those liable for the dissident journalist’s death, a United Nations report said Wednesday. While no “smoking gun” has yet been found that directly incriminates the prince [...]

  • Sarah Huckabee Sanders Jemele Hill

    Sarah Huckabee Sanders to Leave the White House

    White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders is leaving her position at the end of the month, President Donald Trump said Thursday. In two tweets, Trump announced Sanders’ departure for her home state of Arkansas before thanking her for “a job well done.” He also recommended her for the Arkansas governor position, writing, “She is [...]

  • Kellyanne Conway

    Federal Watchdog Says Kellyanne Conway Should Step Down

    A federal watchdog has recommended that White House counselor Kellyanne Conway should be fired for repeated violations of the Hatch Act. In a report on Thursday, the U.S. Office of Special Counsel found that Conway had used TV appearances and social media platforms to disparage Democratic presidential candidates while speaking in her official capacity. “Ms. [...]

  • Jessica Biel Clarifies Anti-Vaccine Stance

    Jessica Biel: 'I Am Not Against Vaccinations'

    Jessica Biel clarified her stance on vaccinations after public outcry over news that the actress joined Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to lobby against a California state pro-vaccine bill. “I am not against vaccinations,” Biel wrote on Instagram Thursday morning. “I support children getting vaccinations and I also support families having the right to make educated [...]

  • 'The Sinner' film premiere

    Jessica Biel Joins Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to Lobby Against California Vaccine Bill

    Jessica Biel joined the controversial anti-vaccination advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to lobby against a California state pro-vaccine bill on Tuesday, revealed in several social media posts. “Please say thank you to the courageous @jessicabiel for a busy and productive day at the California State House,” Kennedy posted on Tuesday with a series of pictures [...]

  • Hope Hicks Resigns

    Hope Hicks to Give Closed-Door Testimony to Judiciary Committee

    Hope Hicks, the chief communications officer at Fox, has agreed to answer questions before the House Judiciary Committee next week. The hearing will be held behind closed doors, but the committee will make a transcript available afterward. The committee is continuing to follow up on the report of Special Counsel Robert Mueller. Hicks is set [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content