You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

AT&T-Time Warner Trial: DOJ Grills Executive on ‘Cash Cow’ Comment

WASHINGTON — An attorney for the Justice Department, seeking to show that AT&T sought Time Warner as a way to preserve its lucrative pay-TV revenue stream, grilled an executive who once referred to the business as a “cash cow.”

But during Thursday’s testimony in the AT&T-Time Warner antitrust trial, the company’s legal team highlighted how the executive, Gregory Manty, was far from the ranks of decision makers on the merger. He joined the company in 2014.

During his opening arguments in the trial last month, the Justice Department’s lead attorney said that they would show that AT&T was buying Time Warner as a “weapon” to protect its pay-TV “cash cow” and slow the innovation in the industry. AT&T owns DirecTV.

So it was not a surprise that the government called Manty, a director of corporate strategy at AT&T, as an adverse witness.

On the stand, he was questioned by DOJ attorney Julie Elmer about his work on a document he created in April, 2017, for the corporate merger integration teams.

The draft of the document described the merger as a way to “ensure stability” as the pay-TV business experiences a “slow structural decline.” Manty also wrote a note that the pay-TV business will be a “cash cow” for years to come.

After Manty sent the report to his superiors, the language in it was revised to say “encourage stability.” In an email in response at the time, Manty wrote that the changes made the wording “too bland,” but also noted that it was subject to review by lawyers.

Elmer pressed Manty on whether the presentation had been “sanitized,” but he resisted that characterization.

AT&T-Time Warner’s attorney, Randy Oppenheimer, tried to highlight that Manty was not in the ranks of senior executives at the company. He asked Manty whether he had anything to do with the decision to merge the two companies, and Manty responded, “No.” Manty also said that the merger integration teams of the two companies were “highly regulated” and subject to lawyers’ review because the deal had yet to close.

More Politics

  • Roger Stone (L), longtime advisor to

    Judge Places Gag Order on Roger Stone Case

    WASHINGTON — A federal judge imposed a gag order on Roger Stone’s legal proceedings that places some limitations on what he, his lawyers, and other parties say about the case. Stone, a longtime associate of President Donald Trump, was arrested last month after special counsel Robert Mueller brought charges that he misled the House Intelligence Committee [...]

  • Donald Trump

    Trump Declares National Emergency Because of ‘Invasion’ at Border

    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump has declared a national emergency to secure funding to build a physical barrier along the U.S.-Mexico border, a move that is certain to provoke a constitutional legal challenge. In a speech at the Rose Garden at the White House, Trump said, “we are talking about an invasion of our country.” [...]

  • Democratic Debates

    NBC-MSNBC-Telemundo and CNN Land First Two Democratic Debates

    WASHINGTON — NBC, MSNBC, and Telemundo will air the first Democratic primary debate in June, and CNN will show the second event in July, the Democratic National Committee announced on Thursday. The DNC is planning 12 presidential primary debates over the 2020 cycle, but news networks had been vying for the rights to air the [...]

  • Donald Trump

    Trump to Declare National Emergency to Build Border Wall, Mitch McConnell Says

    UPDATED WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump has indicated that he will sign a spending bill to keep the government open, but also plans to issue an emergency declaration to build a wall or physical barrier along the U.S.-Mexico border, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said on Thursday. “I’ve just had an opportunity to speak with [...]

  • William Barr

    Senate Confirms William Barr as Attorney General

    WASHINGTON — The Senate confirmed William Barr to be the next attorney general, as his nomination survived Democratic opposition related to concerns over his independence from the Trump White House. He was confirmed by a vote of 54-45. Democrats Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona, Doug Jones of Alabama and Joe Manchin of West Virginia voted for [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content