×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

AT&T-Time Warner Trial: DOJ Goes After Claims of Merger’s Cost Savings, Revenue Growth

WASHINGTON — The AT&T-Time Warner antitrust trial began to wind down on Monday as the Justice Department presented two expert witnesses who have raised doubts about the cost savings and new revenue that can be tied to the merger.

AT&T’s John Stankey, tasked with overseeing the integration of the companies, last week testified that his group had identified about $2.5 billion in merger synergies, including cost savings and additional revenue. Those synergies may play a role in how U.S. District Judge Richard Leon ultimately views the transaction, as they make the case that the merger will produce certain efficiencies.

One of the DOJ’s witnesses, Ronald Quintero, said that none of the companies claimed synergies that he studied could be verified through documentation or were not specific to the merger. He said that some of the figures that AT&T-Time Warner used were speculative.

In a contentious cross-examination, AT&T-Time Warner attorney Rob Walters tried to attack Quintero, suggesting that he “turned a blind eye” to finding out more about how the companies came up with the figures.

“I only know what they provided in documentation,” Quintero said.

Walters pointed to claimed cost efficiencies from corporate overhead that will come from the merger. For instance, there will be savings from the elimination of the Time Warner board of directors and the departure of Jeffrey Bewkes, its CEO, he said.

Quintero said that while such savings may be achieved through the merger, the companies had not provided adequate material for him to give them credit for the efficiencies in his review.

Another witness, Stanford professor Susan Athey, questioned AT&T’s projections for the growth of its ad business because of the merger.

AT&T projects expanding the sales of ads by “several hundred million per year” by 2020, Athey said, via the use of data to better target ad spots, including those on Time Warner’s Turner networks. She said that the projected revenue growth appeared to be based on assumptions, and that such targeting can be achieved via data sharing arrangements and without merger.

She also questioned whether AT&T’s plans to build an automatic ad platform, in which buyers and sellers across the industry could buy spots across screens and devices, would actually work. She said that Google tried to do something similar starting in 2007, but it shut down five years later because potential participants “didn’t see the value” in going to the platform.

AT&T-Time Warner attorney Mike Raiff highlighted how Time Warner’s Turner networks have been largely unsuccessful in acquiring useful ad-targeting data from third parties. He also pointed out that AT&T’s  automatic ad buying platform will initially depend on the availability of the Turner networks ad inventory.

The DOJ is seeking to block the merger, claiming that the combined company will gain increased leverage over AT&T’s distribution rivals for the rights to carry Time Warner’s Turner networks. That will ultimately lead to higher prices for consumers, the government says.

The trial is now in its sixth week, and witness testimony is expected to wrap up in the next several days. Carl Shapiro, the government’s economic expert, is expected to return to the stand on Tuesday. It probably can’t come soon enough. Leon on Monday instructed an attorney for AT&T-Time Warner, Rob Walters, that he had just one question left as his cross-examination of Quintero went on apparently too long. The judge later told Athey to answer questions directly, rather than provide lengthy explanations.

“You aren’t teaching a course here,” Leon said. “Answer the question.”

More Politics

  • Trump Jim Acosta CNN White House

    The Gradual Disappearing Act of the White House Daily Press Briefing

    WASHINGTON — The Trump White House has dropped an event that used to be a prized invite for journalists and their families in D.C.: A holiday party for the media. But another tradition has been disappearing from the West Wing agenda as well: the daily press briefing. The regular televised afternoon back and forth between [...]

  • Nexstar Logo

    Nexstar Settles With Justice Department Over Sharing of Ad Information

    WASHINGTON — Nexstar Media Group, which recently announced plans to acquire Tribune Media and become the largest owner of TV stations in the country, has settled with the Justice Department as it investigates broadcasters’ sharing of competitive advertising rate information with rivals. Six other station groups, including Tribune Media, reached a settlement with the DOJ [...]

  • Donald Trump

    National Enquirer Parent Admits to Making Karen McDougal Payments to Help Trump in 2016 Election

    WASHINGTON — Federal prosecutors said National Enquirer’s parent company, American Media, admitted that it made a $150,000 payment to ex-Playboy model Karen McDougal “to ensure that the woman did not publicize damaging allegations” about Donald Trump in advance of the 2016 presidential election. AMI’s admission could bolster any case prosecutors make against Trump for violating [...]

  • Ajit Pai

    FCC to Launch Review of Media Ownership Rules, Including Ban on Broadcast Network Mergers

    WASHINGTON — The FCC will review whether to modify or even eliminate a series of media ownership proposals, including a current ban on mergers among the four major broadcast networks. The review, mandated by Congress every four years, includes no specific policy proposals, but will take public comment on whether changes are warranted. The FCC will [...]

  • US Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader

    Ruth Bader Ginsburg Says She's 'Feeling Just Fine' After Falling Last Month

    WASHINGTON — As Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg watched Focus Features and Participant Media’s “On the Basis of Sex” for the first time at a National Archives screening in Washington, D.C., she got big applause for how she described her wellbeing after suffering a fall last month. “I’m feeling just fine, and I am meeting my [...]

  • Michael Cohen

    Michael Cohen Sentenced to Three Years in Prison

    Michael Cohen was sentenced to three years in prison after pleading guilty to a series of charges, including a campaign finance violation in which he implicated President Trump. In an appearance in a New York federal court before his sentencing, Cohen said that he was sorry for his crimes, explaining that when he served as [...]

  • Sundar Pichai Hearing

    Key Takeaways From Google CEO Sundar Pichai's Day in Congress

    WASHINGTON — Google’s CEO Sundar Pichai made it through a 3.5-hour hearing before the House Judiciary Committee free of committing the company to new business practices or behavior. He didn’t even promise not to pursue a censored search engine in China, even as human rights groups have called on the company to abandon the project. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content