×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

DOJ, AT&T-Time Warner Provide Conflicting Accounts of Pre-Antitrust Suit Clash

WASHINGTON — As the Justice Department pursues its appeal of a federal judge’s decision in favor of the AT&T-Time Warner merger, new court filings shed light on the tense meetings that ended with the filing of the landmark lawsuit.

The contentiousness in one key meeting revolved around the companies’ claims that they were being unfairly singled out for an enforcement action, because of President Donald Trump’s opposition to the deal and hatred of Time Warner-division CNN.

According to affidavits filed in federal appellate court on Thursday, a Nov. 8 meeting between the DOJ and Time Warner executives was particularly acrimonious, ending in what top government attorneys said was a verbal threat.

At one point, according to an affidavit from Makan Delrahim, the chief of the Antitrust Division, Time Warner general counsel Paul Cappuccio got up from his seat at a conference table “and said that if the Antitrust Division goes through with this, the case will be ‘a s—show like you’ve never seen,’ and that it would be like ‘Jimmy Hoffa and the firing of Jim Comey.'”

“I interpreted Mr. Cappuccio’s comments to mean that if we brought this enforcement action, defendants would employ personal attacks to denigrate the integrity of the Antitrust Division and myself,” Delrahim said in his declaration.

Andrew Finch, the deputy assistant attorney general for the Antitrust Division, also filed a sworn declaration describing the same details of the meeting.

Another person who was in the room was former attorney general William Barr, a member of the Time Warner board of directors. Barr happened to be in the building that day for the announcement of a new fellowship program, and Delrahim said he asked to attend the meeting. Delrahim agreed.

In his affidavit, Barr provides a different account of what was said, characterizing Delrahim and Finch’s version of events as “incorrect.”

“Mr. Cappuccio did not stand up and wag his finger at Mr. Delrahim and I do not recall any references to either James Comey or Jimmy Hoffa. No reasonable person could have attributed Mr. Cappuccio’s comments as a threat that the companies would personally attack Mr. Delrahim or anyone else in the event of litigation,” Barr said.

He also said the discomfort he felt at the meeting was not over what Cappuccio said, but “was the result of my concern that Mr. Delrahim’s position that the alleged harms from this merger and his inexplicable ipse dixit rejection of remedies short of extreme divestitures were the product not of a well-versed substantive analysis, but rather political or other motivation. As a former Attorney General, that is disturbing to me.”

The DOJ filed suit against the merger on Nov. 20.

The sworn declarations were made in February, just before AT&T-Time Warner sought to pursue discovery on their claims that they were unfairly singled out for antitrust enforcement. But U.S. District Judge Richard Leon rejected that motion and kept the trial focused on antitrust law.

Delrahim has denied that CNN and its coverage of the administration was a factor in the decision to file suit, and he also said he did not receive any orders to do so from Trump or the White House.

“My decision was based on the merits and my belief that the transaction would likely substantially lessen competition and harm American consumers in violation of Section 7 of the Clayton Act,” he said in his declaration.

An AT&T spokeswoman said in a statement, “Our opinion of the government’s lawsuit is no secret, and we appreciate former Attorney General Barr stepping forward to provide his first-hand account of DOJ’s interactions with us in the days prior to filing suit.”

Barr was attorney general from 1991 to 1993 under the presidency of George H.W. Bush.

Leon’s opinion, issued on June 12, rejected all of the government’s arguments against the merger. The two companies completed their transaction two days later.

In their filing, the Justice Department said Leon “rejected the economics of bargaining” in his opinion, and that AT&T has failed to address those “inconsistencies” as it argues that the decision should be upheld.

The DOJ argues that the combined company would gain increased leverage over pay-TV rivals, as it could threaten to black out channels like CNN, TNT, and TBS. Customers would then drop their service and perhaps sign on to AT&T-owned DirecTV, the government claims.

In their filing, the DOJ said AT&T “cannot explain how Time Warner had leverage from threatening blackouts before the merger, but could not have any credible ability to threaten blackouts after the merger.”

More Politics

  • Ajit Pai

    FCC to Launch Review of Media Ownership Rules, Including Ban on Broadcast Network Mergers

    WASHINGTON — The FCC will review whether to modify or even eliminate a series of media ownership proposals, including a current ban on mergers among the four major broadcast networks. The review, mandated by Congress every four years, includes no specific policy proposals, but will take public comment on whether changes are warranted. The FCC will [...]

  • US Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader

    Ruth Bader Ginsburg Says She's 'Feeling Just Fine' After Falling Last Month

    WASHINGTON — As Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg watched Focus Features and Participant Media’s “On the Basis of Sex” for the first time at a National Archives screening in Washington, D.C., she got big applause for how she described her wellbeing after suffering a fall last month. “I’m feeling just fine, and I am meeting my [...]

  • Michael Cohen

    Michael Cohen Sentenced to Three Years in Prison

    Michael Cohen was sentenced to three years in prison after pleading guilty to a series of charges, including a campaign finance violation in which he implicated President Trump. In an appearance in a New York federal court before his sentencing, Cohen said that he was sorry for his crimes, explaining that when he served as [...]

  • Sundar Pichai Hearing

    Key Takeaways From Google CEO Sundar Pichai's Day in Congress

    WASHINGTON — Google’s CEO Sundar Pichai made it through a 3.5-hour hearing before the House Judiciary Committee free of committing the company to new business practices or behavior. He didn’t even promise not to pursue a censored search engine in China, even as human rights groups have called on the company to abandon the project. [...]

  • Jamal Khashoggi

    Jamal Khashoggi, Other Journalists Named Time's Person of the Year

    Time selected Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi, Philippine editor Maria Ressa, jailed Reuters reporters Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo and the Capital Gazette of Annapolis, Md. as the magazine’s Person of the Year, recognizing the journalists as “guardians” at a time of a “war on truth.” “In its highest forms, influence — the measure that has for nine [...]

  • White House Chief of Staff John

    John Kelly to Depart as White House Chief of Staff, Trump Says

    WASHINGTON — White House Chief of Staff John Kelly will leave his post toward at the end of the year, President Trump told reporters on Saturday. Kelly has long been rumored to be on his way out. At one point, Trump announced that Kelly would stay in his post through 2020, but that didn’t end [...]

  • Paul Manafort

    Manafort Lied About Contacts With Trump Administration, Robert Mueller's Team Says

    WASHINGTON — Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s team said Paul Manafort, President Donald Trump’s former campaign chairman, lied about his contacts with Trump administration figures, breaching his plea agreement. “Manafort told multiple discernible lies — these were not instances of mere memory lapses,” Mueller’s team said in a filing on Friday. Much of the filing was [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content