×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

AT&T-Time Warner Antitrust Trial: Judge May Look at Impact of Google, Facebook on Competition

WASHINGTON — The federal judge in the AT&T-Time Warner antitrust trial indicated that he would like to hear about the competition that the companies face from much bigger internet giants like Google and Facebook.

U.S. District Judge Richard Leon did not say whether he would ultimately use the information to define the competitive landscape, but his broaching of the topic spurred attorneys for the Justice Department and AT&T-Time Warner to address the issue of how traditional media players adapt in the fast-changing consumer landscape.

Daniel Petrocelli, the lead attorney for AT&T-Time Warner, said that the “question of these giants goes directly to the nature of the market, directly to the definition of the market.”

He used the term FANG to describe Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, and Google, and noted that their combined market cap was $3 trillion, compared to $300 billion for an AT&T-Time Warner combination. Facebook and Google command 90% of the digital ad market, he said, and “now they are entering into television.” Netflix has said it would spend $8 billion on content this year, “vastly more than HBO,” a unit of Time Warner.

He said that a combined AT&T-Time Warner would be able to do what internet giants do: Use consumer data to offer much more targeted advertising. With the merger, AT&T will be able to rely on DirecTV consumer data in selling “way more valuable” advertising on Turner networks. That, he said, would put less pressure on passing along Turner costs to consumers.

As it is, Petrocelli said, Turner and other cable networks are “suffering” as advertising revenue migrates to digital platforms, while DirecTV has been losing subscribers along with other pay-TV platforms. He said that 4 million dropped their subscriptions to cable and satellite last year. “They are leaving in droves,” he told the court.

AT&T and Time Warner leaders have said that a key rationale for the merger is the competitive threat posed by internet giants, particularly in advertising.

Randall Stephenson, the CEO of AT&T, will testify about the bulked-up competition, Petrocelli said, having already noted, “We’re chasing their taillights.” He also said that Stephenson will tell the court that traditional pay-TV subscribers have reached a “gag point,” as customers will no longer accept price increases.

The Justice Department plans to argue that while the industry is changing, the competitive marketplace is still in the delivery of pay TV service. Its lead attorney, Craig Conrath, said that Netflix has peeled away some subscribers, but “mostly they are a complement” to a consumers’ multichannel pay-TV service. He said that 85% of Netflix subscribers also have traditional cable and satellite service. He added that the projections of AT&T will show continued durability of the traditional model.

He also noted that the AT&T-Time Warner merger would have an impact on the ability of “virtual” multichannel distributors, like Dish and Sling, to grow and offer their own set of competitive channel bundles. He noted that they need Turner channels like TBS and CNN at a “reasonable price and on reasonable terms.”

He also said that AT&T-Time Warner’s arguments about the competitive threat from Google and Facebook should be treated as one of their defenses in the trial, weighed against the potential for consumer harm. Petrocelli disagreed, saying that it is actually a central rationale for the merger.

The discussion of Google, Facebook and other tech giants was a diversion from the other focus of Tuesday’s proceedings, having to do with issues of confidentiality and whether to clear the court in order to hear testimony from AT&T rivals.

The Justice Department indicated that it planned to call an executive from Cox Communications to testify about how the merger will put them at a bargaining disadvantage because the merger will give AT&T-Time Warner increased leverage.

The DOJ wants at least part of the testimony to be in a closed courtroom, warning that a public forum could reveal the bargaining strategies of a rival to AT&T. But Petrocelli argued that the testimony should remain open, as much of the information he expects to be offered by rivals will be speculative on what they think will happen in the marketplace.

Opening arguments are scheduled for Wednesday.

Popular on Variety

More Politics

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    Peter Coyote Riffs on 'Country Music' and How He Admires and Challenges Ken Burns

    Though an instantly recognizable face from films such as “E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial,” “A Walk to Remember” and “Erin Brockovich,” it is Peter Coyote’s voice — a coolly authoritative baritone with a Zen master’s holy roll — that has endeared him to documentary lovers and makers. Alrhough director-writer Alex Gibney used Coyote’s wisened narration for “Enron: [...]

  • Lowell Smokes Cafe Marijuana

    With Cannabis Lounges, On-Site Consumption, Marijuana-Infused Meals Go Legit

    Can this century’s Roaring ’20s repeat history but with pre-rolled joints instead of whiskey flasks and soccer moms as the new flappers? This month, West Hollywood will see the opening of the nation’s first at least quasi-legal cannabis consumption lounge, officially dubbed Lowell Farms: A Cannabis Café, located at 1211 N. La Brea between Fountain [...]

  • President Donald Trump waves as he

    Trump Holds Fundraiser in Hollywood's Backyard

    President Trump paid a visit to Los Angeles on Tuesday, as part of a West Coast fundraising swing expected to raise $15 million. Trump is set to appear at a dinner at developer Geoffrey Palmer’s house in Beverly Hills, where tickets range from $1,000 to $100,000 for VIPs. Though set in Hollywood’s backyard, the event [...]

  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's Burning Image Debate Ad

    ABC Runs Debate Ad Showing Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's Burning Image

    ABC aired an ad during Thursday’s Democratic debate that depicted a burning image of Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and likened her politics to those that caused the Cambodian genocide. New Faces GOP funded the ad, which features Elizabeth Heng, a Republican who lost a bid for a Fresno-area congressional seat last year. Ocasio-Cortez responded on Twitter, [...]

  • Joe Biden, Elizabeth Warren, Kamala Harris.

    ABC News' Democratic Debate Lacked Energy and Purpose

    At long last, former Vice President Joe Biden and Senator Elizabeth Warren were on the same stage. And the result was a long and fairly dull evening. After two Democratic Party debate stages in which the field of candidates had been bifurcated — splitting, in both cases, the perceived frontrunners from the establishment and insurgent [...]

  • Former Vice President Joe Biden responds

    Protesters Interrupt Joe Biden During Democratic Debate

    Protesters interrupted presidential candidate Joe Biden during Thursday’s democratic debate. The chants came nearly two and a half hours in as moderator George Stephanopoulos asked the former vice president about any professional setbacks he’s faced and how he recovered from them. “We’re going to clear the protesters,” Stephanopoulos said as the chants began. “We’re sorry.” [...]

  • Bernie Sanders, Joe Biden, Elizabeth Warren,

    Dems Debate in Houston: Moderates Push Back on Medicare for All

    The third Democratic debate on Thursday was billed as the first showdown between the top contenders: Vice President Joe Biden, Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Sen. Bernie Sanders. Biden did challenge the liberal senators on health care early in the debate, which was broadcast on ABC. He asked repeatedly how they would pay for their multi-trillion [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content