×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Album Review: Justin Timberlake’s ‘Man of the Woods’

Contrary to early assumptions, there's nothing too rootsy about Justin Timberlake's decidedly funk-filled "Man of the Woods" after all... unless you count the happy, homey lyrics about his wife and child and their shared flannel.

Trailers for movie tentpoles blow up the internet on a regular basis, but it’s not every day, or even every decade, that a trailer for an album has the same effect. So it was newsworthy in early January when Justin Timberlake’s minute-long video teaser for “Man of the Woods” was met with the same blogger fascination that might’ve greeted a “Star Wars” preview that had a perceived canonical error. The “Suit & Tie” guy now wanted us to picture him in leather and fringe, standing in rivers below snowy mountains, with every indication he’d be downplaying his signature R&B for a folksy roots move, if not going country. “It’s meant to be heard outside even more than inside,” Timberlake revealed in a subsequent clip, while a track list revealed earth-dad titles like “Livin’ off the Land” and “Montana.” We had every reason to believe he’d be flying the flannel, because, well, he was coming out with a song called “Flannel.”

There was just one problem with this narrative, which you’ve already guessed if you’ve heard “Filthy” and “Supplies,” the first couple of singles to be released from the album: The music is as studiously funk-soul as ever. Sure, it’s Americana, if old Michael Jackson and Chic records are Americana. As promised, Timberlake does bring in Chris Stapleton, the Southern belter he helped turn into a country superstar, for three co-writes and a duet. But you’ll have to have serious powers of excavation to pick out the country elements in that or any of the tracks that have all-star helmers Pharrell Williams, Timbaland and Danja mixing ’70s R&B revivalism with every contemporary trick of the rhythmic trade. Timberlake may aspire to be a dude of the timber, but his super-producers remain urban men of steel.

The lowdown is that if you can get past the marketing (which is, admittedly, a tall order), and maybe avoid listening to many of the lyrics or any of the spoken asides (which we’ll get to in a minute), it’s hard to imagine anyone who ever liked Timberlake not having a blast for most of the duration of “Man of the Woods.” Much of it is due to the dominance of the Neptunes, aka the team of Williams and Chad Hugo, whose nine new songs with Timberlake mark the first time they’ve worked with him since his solo debut, “Justified,” in 2002. Their canny collaborations have a fleetness of foot that extends to the economy of song lengths; while nearly all of the tracks on Timberlake’s 2013 album “20/20 Experience” clocked in at more than seven minutes, only one out of 16 on the new one even crosses the five-minute barrier. A not-too-secret weapon here — since Timberlake gives the instrumentalist a shout-out at one point — is guitarist Elliott Ives, who provides more slinky rhythmic lines than anybody since Nile Rodgers. But the Neptunes are all about the electronica when it comes to the rhythm section, creating sounds that break down the barrier between fake bass and faux drums, while sampled background chants sputter from speaker to speaker.

Timberlake reserves a special credit for himself for producing all his own vocals, and you can see why he’d take enough pride in that to not want to share that particular glory with Williams, Timbaland, et al. He knows he’ll never match his soul heroes in pure power, but his gift for arranging and stacking his falsetto in hurried settings is so much fun that it never seems presumptuous when he keeps reminding us what a good time we’re all having. He’s ballad-avoidant these days — with such a happy life on the ranch, rivers are strictly for wading in, not crying — but he can still strike up a healthy variety across 16 tracks, from the swooshy space funk of “Filthy” to the strictly retro Commodores party that is “Midnight Summer Jam” to the Caribbean reggae of “Wave” to the album’s alternately sexy-cute and brooding duets with Alicia Keys and Stapleton, “Morning Light” and “Say Something.”

But if the pre-release buzz has you looking for, as they used to say, “both styles of music, Country and Western,” those are absent, apart from some Stapleton growls and guitar grit that hint at the long history of Nashville/Memphis crossover. Which is not to say that the infamous teaser trailer was a complete fake-out. As the album continues, the promises of parties that go on till six in the morning recede, and Timberlake takes to writing more about his bucolic life on that Montana ranch with Jessica Biel — or Jessica Timberlake, as she’s billed for the multiple spoken-word appearances she makes, playing the mystical rural muse and/or mother to their 2-year-old son, Silas. The final track, “Young Man,” has Timberlake doling out banal life advice to his kid (“When you fall, you don’t have to stay down.… If you want to make God smile, make plans”) even as we hear the Timberlakes teaching him to say, “I love you, Daddy,” in real time. This is not as risible as the minute-long interlude in which Mrs. Timberlake discusses how sexy she feels wearing her husband’s shirt. (And you thought interludes were already an ignoble genre.)

Certainly these TMI moments will help make the performer an easy target, which he probably didn’t need after that inadvisably earnest trailer, or the horrendous video for “Supplies,” which squandered a vast budget on a dystopian mess that seemed designed mostly to make him look woke to racial and feminist causes. These all add up, paradoxically, to a guy who’s so completely expert at sketch comedy not always having a sense of when his most serious moments also come off like straight-faced skits.

And yet there are plenty of reasons to like “Man of the Woods,” not least that it’s got a good beat and you can dance to it. Although he’s not really mixing musical genres as originally promised, he’s mixing up some music and lyrics that shouldn’t really go together, which makes this one crazy peanut butter cup of an album — at least by the time it gets to Timberlake sincerely extolling “Flannel,” accompanied by such trademark R&B that you’re still convinced he must be singing in praise of “Chanel.” It’s the utterly weird boldness of Timberlake figuratively dragging Pharrell and Danja into the middle of a frosty field that makes the album memorable. This is undeniably the real him right now — funkster, family man, firewalker — so as long as we don’t want to stop the feeling, maybe we can allow him his woodsman privilege.

Album Review: Justin Timberlake's 'Man of the Woods'

More Music

  • Assistant Attorney General, Antitrust Division nominee

    DOJ Sides With Irving Azoff Against Radio Stations

    The Department of Justice is taking sides in another hot-button antitrust battle, this time siding with Irving Azoff’s upstart music licensing firm against a group representing 10,000 radio stations. The DOJ Antitrust Division filed a brief on Thursday arguing that the Radio Music License Committee may have engaged in illegal price-fixing when it refused to [...]

  • Dua Lipa

    Green Day, Dan + Shay, Dua Lipa Among 'New Year's Rockin' Eve' Performers

    Green Day, Dan + Shay, Dua Lipa, Paula Abdul, Kelsea Ballerini, Blanco Brown, Ava Max, Megan Thee Stallion, Anthony Ramos, Salt-N-Pepa and SHAED will perform on “Dick Clark’s New Year’s Rockin’ Eve with Ryan Seacrest 2020,” dick clark productions and ABC announced today. The broadcast will also feature Ciara as West Coast host, who said, [...]

  • Taylor Swift "Christmas Tree Farm"

    Taylor Swift's 'Christmas Tree Farm' Video Is a VHS Wonderland

    Taylor Swift may have set a “Farm”-to-market land speed record with the release of “Christmas Tree Farm” Thursday night, just four days after the tune was written, and with much less time than that since it was lushly orchestrated for maximum holiday glee. The biggest revelation of the accompanying video — at least for anyone [...]

  • darlene love

    Darlene Love's Blue Christmas: Singer Says NBC Tree Lighting Organizers Are Ageist

    Darlene Love’s iconic Christmas song, “Christmas (Baby, Please Come Home),” was performed Wednesday night on NBC’s “Christmas in Rockefeller Center” tree lighting special — but the woman who made it famous was iced out and she is furious about it. Love, 78, explained her frustrations on Facebook, calling out Brad Lachman Productions for excluding her [...]

  • Joycelyn Savage, Azriel Clary. Azriel Clary,

    Joycelyn Savage Denies Creating Patreon Account Exposing R. Kelly

    One of R. Kelly’s longtime girlfriends, Joycelyn Savage, has come forward publicly to refute claims that she’s turned on the R&B singer after an Instagram account claiming to be her suggested as much. In a video obtained by TMZ, Savage, first reading pre-written statements on her cell phone, strongly denies the assertion that she had [...]

  • Jagged Little Pill review

    Broadway Review: 'Jagged Little Pill'

    Nearly 25 years after “Jagged Little Pill” hit the shelves of record stores, Alanis Morissette’s innovative 1995 album has arrived on Broadway under the muscular direction of Diane Paulus, who launched this galvanic production at the American Repertory Theater. The show’s supportive book by screenwriter Diablo Cody interprets Morissette’s musical idiom as a universal domestic [...]

  • Who album cover

    Album Review: The Who's 'Who'

    Not only did the death wish expressed 55 years ago in “My Generation” not come true, but the Who have now become the first major rock act of their generation to come up with a whole album that’s actually about getting old. And this from an outfit that pretty much entirely skipped its own middle age, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content