Broadway Review: ‘Carousel’ Starring Joshua Henry, Jessie Mueller

“Carousel” is sheer bliss in this immaculate revival of Rodgers & Hammerstein’s 1945 dramatic musical starring Jessie Mueller, Renee Fleming, and the thrilling Joshua Henry.

Joshua Henry, Jessie Mueller, Renee Fleming, with Lindsay Mendez, Alexander Gemignani, Margaret Colin, John Douglas Thompson, Amar Ramasar, Brittany Pollack, et al.

Audiences encountering Joshua Henry’s electrifying performance as the charismatic but star-cursed Billy Bigelow will long remember the experience. In this new Broadway revival of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s “Carousel,” Henry shows off the exceptionally beautiful voice of a genuine actor-singer, a voice that while warm and mellow, can also soar with joy and tremble in despair.

Director Jack O’Brien has given us a conventional production of “Carousel,” in the sense of a show that takes no risks but preserves and protects all the original values of a great American musical.  This isn’t obvious at first glance, because Santo Loquasto has designed a breathtaking abstract vision of a carousel — complete with flying horses/dancers — to open the show. But the rest of the musical settles into visual comfort zones for scenes set along the waterfront of the 19th-century New England mill town where the show is set.

Hammerstein bagged the plot from Ferenc Molnar’s “Liliom,” and while he moved the action from Budapest to Maine, he retained the original tragic love story of a young woman from a modest fishing village who falls in love with a roustabout carnival barker who moves from town to town. Here, the original contributions of Rodgers and Hammerstein are some of the musical theater’s most beautiful and enduring songs.

The love story is haunting, with its dark plot about an impulsive hero who brings nothing but tragedy to himself and the wife he dearly loves. But the show is really all about the music, which is handled with kid gloves in this production. Adhering to Jonathan Tunick’s crystal-clean orchestrations, music director Andy Einhorn oversees a full-scaled orchestra the likes of which we rarely see anymore. (There’s even a harp!) And the principal players, who fully embrace the music, are a joy.

In addition to the eye-and-ear-popping Henry, Jessie Mueller (“Waitress,” “Beautiful”) is enchanting as Julie Jordan, who falls for Henry’s attractive but dangerous Billy Bigelow.  Renee Fleming, resident opera diva, sings us straight to heaven as Julie’s warmhearted friend, Nettie Fowler.  Lindsay Mendez and Alexander Gemignani make a delightful second couple as Carrie Pipperidge and her Mr. Snow. And Amar Ramasar, principal dancer with the New York City Ballet, endows the villainous Jigger Craigin with the kind of beauty that draws young ladies to bad boys like bees to honey.

 Yes, this is definitely it — the kind of musical they don’t write anymore.

After changing the face of the Broadway musical theater forever in 1943 with “Oklahoma!,” Rodgers and Hammerstein followed that up in 1945 with the darker and more daring “Carousel.” It’s a hard piece to stage, with its romantic love story streaked with cruelty and violence. Not to mention the fact that the leading man, who hits his wife, dies in the first act.

Operatic in tone and treatment, the score is close to being sung-through. Rodgers (who declared “Carousel” to be the favorite of all his musicals) said he briefly considered — and decided against — making the show an opera. But he wanted the music to be almost continuous, trusting Hammerstein to advance plot and develop character through his lyrics. With the vocal challenge of “You’ll Never Walk Alone” (Fleming had the house in tears) and the emotional demands of the seven-and-a-half-minute “Soliloquy” (Henry rocks it), this is a show that demands first-rate singers with an operatic musical range.

Not to mention dancers, because dance is “Carousel’s” second language. With wunderkind Justin Peck, resident choreographer of New York City Ballet, in charge of all things dance, a fabulous ensemble of singer-dancers who can actually dance gives wings to this revival. And with Brittany Pollack, a young soloist with City Ballet, making her Broadway debut as Louise, that demanding ballet in the second act plays its originally allotted seven-and-a-half minutes in ravishing style.

Buoyed by a full, rich-voiced chorus, ensemble numbers like “A Real Nice Clambake” and “June Is Bustin’ Out All Over” sound like the anthems of little American towns that vanished in the aftermath of two world wars. Danced by townspeople clad in Ann Roth’s pretty, simple country duds, “The Carousel Waltz” is another remnant of more innocent times, while “You’ll Never Walk Alone” is a 19th-century retort to 20th-century cynicism.

There are many ways to update vintage material to make it more “relevant” for contemporary tastes. But it’s wonderful to see a classic work as it was written and how it was meant to be played. And it’s especially enlightening to see what Broadway managed to create while the rest of the country was at war.

Broadway Review: 'Carousel' Starring Joshua Henry, Jessie Mueller

Imperial Theater; 1006 seats; $250 top. Opened April 12, 2018. Reviewed April 7. Running time: 2 HOURS, 20 MIN.

Production: A presentation by Roy Furman, Scott Rudin, Barry Diller, Edward Walson, Universal Theatrical Group, Benjamin Lowy, Eli Bush, James L. Nederlander, Candy Spelling, John Gore Organization, Peter May, Ronnie Lee, Sid & Ruth Lapidus, Stephanie P. McClelland, Sandy Robertson, Caiola Productions, Len Blavatnik, Dominion Ventures, SHN Theaters, the Araca Group, Patty Baker, Al Nocciolino, Darlene Marcos Shiley, Julie Boardman & Marc David Levine, Jennifer Fischer & Olympus Theatricals, Candia Fisher & Allen L. Stevens, Jon Jashni & Matthew Baer, Thomas S. Perakos & Jim Fantaci, Wendy Federman & Heni Koenigsberg, Bruce Robert Harris & Jack W. Batman, executive producers Joe Parnes, Sue Wagner & John Johnson of a musical in two acts with music by Richard Rodgers and book and lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II, based on the play “Liliom” by Ferenc Molnar, as adapted by Benjamin F. Glazer.

Creative: Directed by Jack O’Brien. Choreographed by Justin Peck. Sets, Santo Loquasto; costumes, Ann Roth; lighting, Brian MacDevitt; sound, Scott Lehrer; music supervision, direction & vocal arrangements, Andy Einhorn; orchestrations, Jonathan Tunick; dance arrangements, David Chase; hair, wigs & makeup, Campbell Young Associates; production stage manager, Tripp Phillips.

Cast: Joshua Henry, Jessie Mueller, Renee Fleming, with Lindsay Mendez, Alexander Gemignani, Margaret Colin, John Douglas Thompson, Amar Ramasar, Brittany Pollack, et al.

More Legit

  • The Kilroys The List

    Listen: New List, New Leaders as the Kilroys Push for Parity

    The collective of writers and producers known as the Kilroys has been pushing for gender parity in the theater for five years now. With the launch last week of the latest edition of the List — the group’s annual round-up (inspired by Hollywood’s Black List) of plays by women, trans and non-binary writers — members [...]

  • Annette Bening

    Star-Studded Cast to Perform Live Reading of the Mueller Report

    Haven’t perused the Mueller report yet? A star-studded cast, including Annette Bening, Kevin Kline, and John Lithgow, can read it to you. For one night only on Monday, June 24, stars will perform a live reading of passages from the Mueller report for “The Investigation: A Search for the Truth in Ten Acts,” Robert Schenkkan’s [...]

  • Paula Vogel Never Expected 'Indecent' to

    Paula Vogel Never Expected 'Indecent' to Be This Timely

    When Paula Vogel began writing “Indecent” in 2010, she had no idea how resonant its exploration of immigration woes, anti-Semitism and homophobia in the past century would become in the current political climate. The Tony-nominated play, running until July 7 at L.A.’s Ahmanson Theater, traces the theatrical history of 1907 Yiddish play “God of Vengeance” [...]

  • Bitter Wheat review

    West End Review: John Malkovich in David Mamet's 'Bitter Wheat'

    How soon is too soon? Hardly a year had passed since allegations against Harvey Weinstein were made public before David Mamet announced that his satire on the subject, “Bitter Wheat,” was set to star John Malkovich in the West End. Six months later, we’re sat watching a corpulent, super-rich movie mogul — Barney Fein (cough, [...]

  • Batman Julia Roberts Spike Lee

    Batman, Julia Roberts, Spike Lee Among 2020 Walk of Fame Honorees

    Batman, Julia Roberts and Spike Lee are among the names selected to be inducted into the 2020 Walk of Fame. The full list of honorees was announced by the Hollywood Chamber of Commerce’s Walk of Fame Selection Committee via an exclusive livestream by Variety. Chosen from hundreds of nominees during a selection meeting in June, [...]

  • Tracy Letts

    Tracy Letts' Comedy 'The Minutes' to Hit Broadway in 2020

    Playwright Tracy Letts’ comedy “The Minutes” will hit the Broadway stage in Feb. 2020. “The Minutes,” written by actor, producer and playwright Letts, is a comedy taking a look at the current state of American politics through the lens of a small, fictional town called Big Cherry. The play is set in a city council [...]

  • Jamie Forshaw Tapped as Executive Producer

    Jamie Forshaw Tapped as Executive Producer of MWM Live (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jamie Forshaw has been named executive producer of MWM Live, Variety has learned. The theater veteran most recently served as VP of production for Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Really Useful Group. In his new role, he will oversee MWM Live’s slate of stage productions with an emphasis on expanding the division’s work on Broadway. MWM Live [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content